Transferring ye olde camcorder tapes to MODERN DVD. Best method?

Solution
DVD is not the best thing to store family videos or any file, because it has a lifetime of about 1 to 6 years, maybe more, but you should store it on another medium aswell, like an external Hard Drive.

edit:


https://www.amazon.co.uk/Aplic-grabber-compatible-processing-post-processing/dp/B01D9T8E1U/ref=sr_1_4?s=electronics&ie=UTF8&qid=1481883357&sr=1-4&keywords=LogiLink+Audio+and+Video+Grabber

This one has a software encoder which could be a bit difficult depending on the performance of your PC.

Better would be a capture unit with hardware encoder (x264) like:
https://www.amazon.co.uk/Hauppauge-Capture-Definition-Hardware-Encoders/dp/B001M0MY10/ref=sr_1_28?ie=UTF8&qid=1481884000&sr=8-28&keywords=capture%2Busb%2Bvideo&th=1...
DVD is not the best thing to store family videos or any file, because it has a lifetime of about 1 to 6 years, maybe more, but you should store it on another medium aswell, like an external Hard Drive.

edit:


https://www.amazon.co.uk/Aplic-grabber-compatible-processing-post-processing/dp/B01D9T8E1U/ref=sr_1_4?s=electronics&ie=UTF8&qid=1481883357&sr=1-4&keywords=LogiLink+Audio+and+Video+Grabber

This one has a software encoder which could be a bit difficult depending on the performance of your PC.

Better would be a capture unit with hardware encoder (x264) like:
https://www.amazon.co.uk/Hauppauge-Capture-Definition-Hardware-Encoders/dp/B001M0MY10/ref=sr_1_28?ie=UTF8&qid=1481884000&sr=8-28&keywords=capture%2Busb%2Bvideo&th=1

additionally you will need an s-video or Composite video cable (depending on your specific camera model) and a 3.5 Headphone jack to cinch cable:
Composite video: https://www.amazon.co.uk/Cable-Tex-Phono-Digital-Composite-Coaxial-x/dp/B0041RNUKA/ref=sr_1_19?ie=UTF8&qid=1481884621&sr=8-19&keywords=composite+cable

S-video:https://www.amazon.co.uk/d/460/CDL-Micro-Mini-DIN-S-Video-Cable-Plated-Plugs/B001QV1EPW/ref=sr_1_2?ie=UTF8&qid=1481884527&sr=8-2&keywords=s-video

Audio: https://www.amazon.co.uk/Wentronic-50018-GB-Audio-Video-Stereo/dp/B000L0W5BG/ref=sr_1_3?ie=UTF8&qid=1481884567&sr=8-3&keywords=cinch+to+3.5




 
Solution

Componentgirl90

Distinguished
Jan 9, 2015
538
2
19,015
Thank you for the advice guys.

The aim of the transfer is to preserve the memories that are on there, especially of our dog. I will make sure to save it to hard drive instead and make copies.

I was hoping that you could do it with a cheap TV capture card and some free software. It would save me a bit of money if I did this. Would that be possible?
 

Componentgirl90

Distinguished
Jan 9, 2015
538
2
19,015
@helpstar

One last question: You listed two solutions, one with hardware and one with software. My CPU is fairly good (i5 4690k @ 3.5GHz). Would the quality of the image be better from the hardware encoder solution you listed compared to the software encoder?
 

Componentgirl90

Distinguished
Jan 9, 2015
538
2
19,015
I have opted for the Aplic Software encoder.

Tbh the audio cable listed by the chosen answer doesnt look like the audio cable that is included with my camera originally. It has a headphone jack and two RCA plugs whereas the original has a single RCA plug for Audio (Male to Male) (Black). It also has a single RCA male to male for Video (yellow).

I want to buy a new set of wires because the set I current have is old. I cannot buy that audio plug anyway because it doesn't arrive before christmas and I need it before then.

Can anyone suggest a new audio wire option.
 

Componentgirl90

Distinguished
Jan 9, 2015
538
2
19,015
The camera is like that. Except it has 2 large sockets, 1 black (labelled audio) and 1 yellow (labelled video) with that small hole with the same label "RFU DC OUT".

The cable is like the three on the right of the cable image. The left hand plug does not exist as part of the cable. There are two cables. One black for audio and one yellow for video. Both ends of both cables are Male RCA. We plug one end into a scart socket with a female RCA and then the scart socket into the TV.

It is a Sony Video 8 XR. Handycam vision. 64x Zoom.

I appreciate all this help, it has been very useful. Cheers.
 

Paperdoc

Polypheme
Ambassador
OK, your camera has female RCA connectors for its outputs - Black for Audio, and Yellow for Video. The Audio, by the way, is single-channel (NOT stereo), and that's why there is only one.

The inputs to most video capture cards are also female RCA connectors, usually using Yellow for Video (more precisely, Composite Video, which is what you're doing here), Red for the Right channel of stereo Audio, and White for the Left channel. Very commonly, of you have only monaural sound (the Black source), you'd connect it to the Left input channel, but check your capture card's manual. Even if your capture card has a smaller 3.5mm jack hole for its inputs, it very likely comes with a cord or adapter to allow you to arrange inputs via RCA connectors.

So, what you need is a simple pair of RCA cables with male connectors on each end. You could use a common cable with three wires in it - Yellow (Video), Red and White (two stereo channels) and just NOT use on of those colours. You could even use a common two-wire cable intended for simple stereo audio, with Red and White, and just use your own colour coding to make the connection. For example, Camera Yellow (Composite Video) gets cable Red, the other end of Cable Red goes to Capture card's Yellow (Video) input, and use the cable's White for Audio.

There is nothing special inside the cables with the different colours in such multi-wire cables. The colour codings are ONLY there to help you keep your connections straight. I have seen a few sets, though, where the Yellow Video part of the cable set is heavier for slightly better quality on that more complex signal.

By the way, the Sony (and other makers) "Hi 8" system was just a slightly better-quality recording system than the original 8 mm video tape system. It made almost no difference to how the signals were exported from the camera to the TV or recording device; the output still was Composite Video plus monaural or stereo audio. A few cameras also had an S-Video output in addition to the Composite Video (S-Video connectors are different), but most of them also had stereo audio so I suspect your camera does not have this port.
 

Componentgirl90

Distinguished
Jan 9, 2015
538
2
19,015
hi guys,

thanks for the help. I am doing ok with the cables that came with it so I wont order for now. I have managed to transfer one Hi 8 tape into avi format. I was not able to capture the video with the included software but used a free software from the web.

@Paperdoc - Many thanks for this detailed reply. I just ended up plugging the single audio channel into one of the audio connectors and when it plays back it comes out of one speaker in my headphones. However I will experiment with both audio input channels to see if that makes the sound play in both ears. I never knew you could use the audio cables like that for video so that is useful information. Cheers. I will just buy a dual sound cable if I need to replace this cable at any point.
 

Paperdoc

Polypheme
Ambassador
If you really want to have your monaural audio signal from the camera recorded on both stereo channels so that both speakers play the same sound, you can do this. Get a small adapter that converts one audio signal into two parallel outputs that you can feed into both stereo inputs of your capture system.

Glad to hear you are having success.