1. The post you responded to proposed an SSHD not a HD, so HD is not really relevant.
2. We have been building PCs for 25 years. For example, because we and many of those we build for use AutoCAD, we could always justify expensive SCSI drives based upon a productivity / cost analysis. You can not do this today with SSDs because a) AutoCAD is no longer dependent upon storage subsystem performance and b) there is no productivity gain when actually tested. Opening a file takes same time regardless of SSD / SSHD / HD
3. Yes, if you tell someone look at a versus b and tell me which is faster they notice. But that's not "real life". Fact remains when you don't tell them, as in a blind test, they don't notice as they are multitasking. We now have a push button french press int he office makes cup of coffee at the push of a button (grinds beans, compresses then, injects water) .... I walk into office, press the button on coffee machine, walk to my desk, turn on PC, then walk back to the machine, grab my coffee and return to desk. I see no advantage whether I boot from the SSD in 15.6 seconds or the SSHD in 16.5 as by time I have grabbed the cup and thrown in some cream, both are at my desktop.
Now you could stare at the screen and appreciate the boot time difference but that doesn't get anything done... I'm at my desk drinking coffee while reading e-mails, when you are getting up to get yours. In short, when any intervening time is used productively (turn on MFP, Plotter, lights, take plastic bag outta trash can, replace your dead pen w/ one from the supply closet, whatever)
4. "Worth it" means various things to different people. A CEO is presented with a proposal from say Dell for 10,000 customer service workstations .... it includes a suggested option for adding SSDs for $85 per station. As a result of this addition, will he see a productivity increase ? With the CS operators take any more customer calls because they have an SSD ?
5. The difference between a SSD boot and an SSHD boot is less than a second ... can you do a cost benefit analysis and calculate the payback period for adding an SSD. Launching Witcher 3 I could stare at the screen and appreciate the fact that the SSD takes 26 seconds, the SSHD takes 27.5 of the HD takes 40 or i could spend the time loading the spreadsheets tracking what materials I need to collect for potions / crafts, armor parts I still need to find or Maps / Guide sites I use when I get stuck.... or even a bio or snack run.
6. In short, what I am saying is being able to "see a difference" and being able to accomplish something with that difference are two very different things. I can see a performance difference when I drive the Porsche, but I still get to work in the morning at the exact same time. Other than admiring the car's performance, it doesn't change my life in any way.
I will give you a real life. I put a 120 GB in my personal build soon after they became available. An employee suggested they I get him one too "so that he could improve his productivity". As he was a new employee, I asked him to do a cost benefit analysis as doing these would be part of his everyday job once I had him trained. I don't remember the exact particulars but let's say he came back with one showing a 10 second advantage in boot time and another 15 seconds throughout the day.
25 seconds x 220 days x 3 years ~ 4.6 hours @ $30/hr ~ $137 which was a bit what an SSD cost back then. The problem was, those numbers were not real. For example... I could view his daily routine from my office and it went like:
Arrive in office and turn on PC
Take of jacket and take out brown bagged breakfast (roll, muffin whatever)
Go to coffee machine and make pot of coffee
Bit of chit chat, "did you see the game last night" kinda thing
Listen to voice mails on office telephone extension
Go grab coffee now that it is done
Start answering calls while having coffee / muffin and going thru things I dropped in his inbox night before
By the time he even logs into his PC 10-20 minutes has gone by... the boot time advantage exists, but nothing is done with the time saved. People simply can not take advantage of the time saved ... if they do have to wait, they are capable of accomplishing something else that has to be done.