How do you compare motherboards? I have an Intel 6700K processor.

UKTone

Distinguished
Feb 24, 2015
129
4
18,695
1. I I have an Intel 6700K cpu, but I am stuck on which motherboard to get.

The hardest part for me is always picking the motherboard and/or the cpu since the rest of the components are dependent on them. You also have websites like userbenchmark to compare the other components, but not for the mobo. And I really don't want to build a computer then have to take everything off to return it.

I mainly want to use the computer for school, work, etc., but in 3-15 months I may become a pc gamer. I don't have plans to overclock and I would be happy to play games at 720p/1080p, ecstatic to play at 1440p/4k, but not mandatory for me, I'm mainly a Nintendo gamer so graphics don't mean a whole lot for me.

But, any way, apparently H170 would take away a lot of features from the cpu, so I am pretty sure I'm going with the Z series. So it's between Z170 and Z270.

I have a $1200 for the rest of my components, but of course I don't want to just throw money away.

2. I am leaning more towards the Z270 because of the Optane Technology that may come out Q2 2017, but should I go with Z170 or Z270?

3. I am also leaning towards an ATX form factor since it'll likely have more slots/ports and better for future proofing.

4. Using pcpartpicker, still makes it extremely difficult to choose. Please help me decide and give me guidance on picking motherboards in the future.

5. Lastly, http://www.microcenter.com/ (MI - Detroit/Madison Heights) is the place I want to get the components from, lots of the motherboards in pcpartpicker aren't available at microcenter, so could you recommend multiple motherboards starting from your best choice? Or if you have time could you check if they sale it/them?

6. Lastly, how can you find out how old a motherboard is? Is newer usually better (value and/or performance)?

Thank you in advance.

Edit: Video editing is a possibility too, but not for 3-15 months like with the gaming, I don't plan on getting a GPU until I am about to start video editing and/or gaming.
 
Solution
All of your questions kind of role together into a general, how to pick a motherboard question.

Partpicker will narrow you down to compatible choices, but only you have the information that will let you pick amongst them.

Form factor is an interesting subject. Your case ultimately decides the maximum size of the board. FATX, EATX, ATX, uATX, Mini ITX. Larger boards have more of everything usually. But a single GPU single/dual drive system doesn't take much and makes Mini ITX an option. Internal components can be a deciding factor.

What external devices do you/will you have. What ports do you need?
WiFi?
Colors? LED lighting (Z270 boards went all out, a lot of them have it, and room to expand)

For overclocking you will occasionally...

Eximo

Titan
Ambassador
All of your questions kind of role together into a general, how to pick a motherboard question.

Partpicker will narrow you down to compatible choices, but only you have the information that will let you pick amongst them.

Form factor is an interesting subject. Your case ultimately decides the maximum size of the board. FATX, EATX, ATX, uATX, Mini ITX. Larger boards have more of everything usually. But a single GPU single/dual drive system doesn't take much and makes Mini ITX an option. Internal components can be a deciding factor.

What external devices do you/will you have. What ports do you need?
WiFi?
Colors? LED lighting (Z270 boards went all out, a lot of them have it, and room to expand)

For overclocking you will occasionally see round ups between boards, but generally it is the CPU that is the limiting factor. It is best to avoid the cheapest Z class boards, as they will have minimal VRMs. But depending on your target, a mild overclock vs what the chip can handle, you can spend a lot on a board to gain only 100Mhz. Anything above $150 should be decent, anything above $120 or so will be good for a mild overclock. $200 and up and you will be looking at gaming features, premium audio & network, etc.

ATX boards are what I usually end up with. Kind of a jack of all trades and the cases can be reasonably sized.

Common pitfalls:
1) USB headers, how many, what type, and their position on the motherboard relative to the case you put the board in.
2) Fan headers, how many, what type (3-pin, or 4-pin PWM), where and what fans will end up in the case
 
Solution

Eximo

Titan
Ambassador
If you are building a new system today. Z270 and a Kabylake CPU are going to be my recommendation.

As to what exact motherboard, you are going to have to think about what you want on it. If you don't know, you can just pick one you think looks nice and stick to brands like ASUS, Gigabyte, MSI, EVGA, ASRock.