Need Low Cost Replacement for Radeon 5670 that died

hogan773

Distinguished
Oct 9, 2010
227
0
18,690
Hi all and thanks for the help. My Radeon 5670 appears to have died. Had pixelated mouse pointer yesterday then son was playing an online game and screen went black. Mobo gets stuck on GPU error when posting and GPU is hot. Swapped in the only other really old GPU I could find from an old Dell and it works so its not Mobo.

Given that we don't do a lot of heavy PC gaming and my system is i7 2600K and still perfectly fine for me, I don't want to spend a lot of money. However if it turns out that today's "budget" cards are a few steps better horsepower than a 5670 then I happily take that in the process. But if the choice is spending $25 to get something basically equivalent to what I had (which allowed my son to play some games) and $75-100 to increase framerates, then definitely I'd spend $25 just to get me back to where I was and save the cash. But if I can get a 5670-equiv for $25 but only $10 more gets me something several steps better on the Tom's chart then I would do that I think.

System: Asrock P67 Extreme 4, i72600k, 8gb RAM, 380W Antec PSU.

My 5670 didn't require a direct plug in to the PSU so if my new card needs one I'll need to understand what that socket looks like to make sure I have the correct extra plug on my PSU. I don't want to go down the rabbit hole of also upgrading PSU "while I'm at it"

BASICALLY I GUESS MY QUESTION IS WHAT IS THE CHEAPEST CURRENT GPU I CAN BUY RIGHT NOW THAT IS AS GOOD OR BETTER THAN THE RADEON 5670. Or should I buy old stock or used on Ebay and try to target a 5770 or something a few steps up the ladder from the 5670? But I want something that doesn't need separate power. This is why I'm so confused so asking you guys

 
Solution

RX 460 for 90 bucks? Sign me up. Seriously, the RX 460 is much better than either of those cards. If you can afford it, I say go for it. It isn't the most future proof card, but it can run games at medium 1080p at pretty decent frames. In the future, if your PSU, mobo, and case can handle it, you could even throw a second one in there for CrossFire.

Good luck!
well the R5 230 from AMD would be an even match for the 5670 from ATI (the HD series truly no longer exist)
new egg has a variety of those new to bu7y price vary from 30 to 90$
https://www.newegg.com/Product/ProductList.aspx?Submit=ENE&DEPA=0&Order=BESTMATCH&Description=r5+230&ignorear=0&N=-1&isNodeId=1

the next step up from your 6570 would of been the 7770 series for ATi, which turns into the AMD Radeon R7 250 series
newegg again has those, from 55$ to 150$ low prices are refurbished products if you can tolerate those
https://www.newegg.com/Product/ProductList.aspx?Submit=ENE&DEPA=0&Order=BESTMATCH&Description=r7+250&ignorear=0&N=100007709&isNodeId=1

as a side note, you could get a Nvidia GTX 750 TI (no power plugs needed)
newegg again has them for about 85 to 146$ (lower prices for refurbished again)
https://www.newegg.com/Product/ProductList.aspx?Submit=ENE&DEPA=0&Order=BESTMATCH&Description=GTX+750+TI&N=-1&isNodeId=1
 

hogan773

Distinguished
Oct 9, 2010
227
0
18,690


Thanks for this. I was poking around while waiting for an answer here. Looking at what were the best budget cards from a couple years ago and seems R7 260X was the $100 card in 2014. Would it make sense to buy a used one on Ebay? Or better to get a brand new card even if a 240 as you suggest so I know it hasn't been ridden hard and put away wet, so to speak. I would only worry with buying a used one that it will die again in a year and I'll be back here again !
 

RylieDetchon

Honorable
Nov 21, 2016
322
1
10,865

If you trust used electronics, it may not be a bad idea. I've personally had bad experiences with used electronics, but it's all up to you, and what you want to run on your computer. With your CPU, you are able to run almost if not all GPUs, so that shouldn't be worrying.
 

hogan773

Distinguished
Oct 9, 2010
227
0
18,690
Paladin the first link you have above is to a HD5450. Is that just a successor to the 5670 or did you link the wrong thing?

Honestly I get so frickin confused between all these different graphics cards even when using the Tom's hierarchy chart.
 

RylieDetchon

Honorable
Nov 21, 2016
322
1
10,865

I am so sorry for any confusion. That is clearly a 5450 that I accidentally linked, as I thought you had a 5450. On another note, the 5670 is much better than a 5450, so unless you want a slight downgrade, I would not recommend it.
 

hogan773

Distinguished
Oct 9, 2010
227
0
18,690
Looking further it appears that to get something similar or better than my dead 5670, I need to be in the R7 250 area or higher. Or maybe R7 240. Some benchmarks suggest that the 240 is equivalent to the 5670 although the 240 appears two notches lower on the Tom's Hierarchy so I'm not sure what that's about
 

RylieDetchon

Honorable
Nov 21, 2016
322
1
10,865

What is the most you are willing to spend on this GPU?
 

hogan773

Distinguished
Oct 9, 2010
227
0
18,690


I thought I could get away with getting a cheapo replacement for 25 bucks or something but it appears that isn't right. So I guess probably 50 to 75 is what I'm gonna have to spend to maintain similar. I will look at 75-100 though if there is a major increase/futureproof. For example if a 240 or 250 that is the same performance as my dead 5670 costs $50-75 bucks but a new 460 could be had on sale for $90 or something and it was a much better unit, then I would consider that. The thing that is always hard to know on balance is getting a great deal on "old stock" of something vs also getting a great deal on a competitively priced newest product. Sometimes the old stock isn't really attractively priced vs the newest stuff. But on graphics cards my brain melts down because one year's 7750 becomes the next years 240 or whatever even though they are basically the same card (I'm just making up those numbers) so it is hard to know what is what. And that isn't even counting trying to buy something used off Ebay. I'd think there is probably a good oppty to buy someone's awesome GPU from a couple years ago for a great price and the only reason they're selling is because they are the type who wants the newest and best. But as you said, that can be a riskier path.

Basically I am probably fine just getting whatever $50-ish graphics card and moving on with life, but I'm the type of person who would like to know whether I am getting crap for $50 but there is a great discounted card for $65 that would be noticeably better......
 

hogan773

Distinguished
Oct 9, 2010
227
0
18,690
Looks like I can get RX 460s for around 90 bucks, and R7 360s for 75ish, and R7 250 for 60ish depending on what kind of memory.

Is the RX460 a substantial step up that I should pay then extra 15 to 30 dollars vs the others?
 

RylieDetchon

Honorable
Nov 21, 2016
322
1
10,865

RX 460 for 90 bucks? Sign me up. Seriously, the RX 460 is much better than either of those cards. If you can afford it, I say go for it. It isn't the most future proof card, but it can run games at medium 1080p at pretty decent frames. In the future, if your PSU, mobo, and case can handle it, you could even throw a second one in there for CrossFire.

Good luck!
 
Solution

hogan773

Distinguished
Oct 9, 2010
227
0
18,690
I ended up purchasing a GTX 1050 card from Newegg. With $20 rebate it is only $99.99, plus I get some free game thingy that maybe I can sell on Ebay for a few bucks. I did some research and it appears the GTX 1050 is generally 15-20% better performance than the RX 460 and it was only 10 bucks more than the RX 460.
 

RylieDetchon

Honorable
Nov 21, 2016
322
1
10,865

That's true, the GTX 1050 does perform better in most games due to it performing better in DX 11 as opposed to AMD's favoured DX 12. Enjoy your new card! :)