S.M.A.R.T. Failure Imminent - No Obvious Problems

Ghost Pirate

Reputable
Nov 8, 2014
21
0
4,510
Yesterday, while recording with FRAPS to my secondary HDD that I've had for about a month, the game minimized and gave me the message saying that a problem with said HDD had been detected and that failure was imminent. This message continued to appear every few minutes for the duration of the session. When I booted up today, the BIOS gave me the S.M.A.R.T. status warning, but I've been using it for a few hours without receiving the Windows error message at all.

I've backed up everything important to a different location just in case, but I'm not 100% sure what the problem is, if there really is one. Check Disk found nothing wrong. I'm able to play games off of the drive with no issue, and I'm installing one to it as a test, also with nothing abnormal.

If the BIOS thing keeps up it's worth looking into the warranty just for that, but is there anything I can do to better test or fix this myself? Any help would be much appreciated.
 
Solution
For future reference, what you saw is likely a SMART return status failure. It's a separate SATA command from the regular collect SMART attributes. This is a command that will only return pass/fail. The drive firmware will set this flag to fail if a critical SMART attribute exceeds a critical threshold.

While the drive will usually still be operational, the SMART status fail is firmware's way of telling you that something is very wrong with in the SMART health attributes and you should replace the drive. In this case, it seems that End-to-End failure count was the issue.

Ghost Pirate

Reputable
Nov 8, 2014
21
0
4,510


Reporting "End to End error." This was in red, everything else normal. Google seems to confirm this thing is screwed. Whelp.
 

rkzhao

Respectable
Mar 8, 2016
183
1
1,860
For future reference, what you saw is likely a SMART return status failure. It's a separate SATA command from the regular collect SMART attributes. This is a command that will only return pass/fail. The drive firmware will set this flag to fail if a critical SMART attribute exceeds a critical threshold.

While the drive will usually still be operational, the SMART status fail is firmware's way of telling you that something is very wrong with in the SMART health attributes and you should replace the drive. In this case, it seems that End-to-End failure count was the issue.
 
Solution