High power PSU shutdown itself randomly with low quality motherboard

NewXeneration

Commendable
Sep 11, 2016
11
0
1,520
Something really interesting happened to me during these days while repairing a PC that came to my place. It was an M2N-E motherboard, AM2+ which i saved from a burnt PSU (not literally, but the fuse was burnt because the owner connected it with the wrong AC volt input line; the PSU was repaired later), but when i tried it with a Coolermaster RS-700-PCAA-E3 psu i had random shutdowns for almost a day. On next day after searching for burnt components on the board and not finding anything, the system just turned on and it worked with no failures for almost 20 hs. The next day i had the same issue again (constant random shutdowns), which made me test the board again, but i didn't want to take all the capacitors out trying to find a little failure; so i decided to test a lower 300W psu and it worked. It boot up with no problem so it made me think that the PSU could be the problem; but after testing it with my motherboards (all of them better and newer than the M2N-E) i found that the PSU was working fine, the voltage reading were fine, the ripple was not high, and no sign of instability. I had an issue with this psu one month ago testing an old 754 unit with instant shutdown and no video showing on screen, but i really didn't care that much, because those old units could have problems, even when those worked with an old 100W PSU, but now i don't know what to think about it.

Somebody have any idea why did that happen? I think about many possibilities, but i'm sure for none of them.
 

Lutfij

Titan
Moderator
I hope you have other more reliable units in your arsenal to vouch for your statement that higher power units aren't working with your old motherboard. In fact how old are the units in question? To that effect, what did you use to simulate load on your old PSU's? Speaking of PSU's please state all the PSU's you've used in the troubleshooting procedure and the full system's specs of your Asus system.

One possibility is that the PSU that went bad might've taken out a component on the Asus board which isn't serviceable like a surface mounted diode or IC for rectifying power.
 

NewXeneration

Commendable
Sep 11, 2016
11
0
1,520


I've repaired the PSU and tested with the ASUS system, and it's working fine right now. I have one more Thermaltake unit to test it. But what i feel it's weird is that i use that PSU (coolermaster) with an M5a88td-m system and it goes fine, used with a M4A78-EM and goes fine too; all those mobo have solid capacitors, which is the main differece apart from the chipset.

I don't know why the asus system goes fine when i use a generic PSU or an EVGA 430w. Also i've done a continuity test for SMD components, and found nothing weird.