Choose between the two motherboards

JKKirit

Commendable
Feb 10, 2017
5
0
1,510
Hi,

I'm struggling to choose between Gigabyte Aorus 270X Gaming K5 and Gigabyte 270X Ultra Gaming motherboards. The price difference is not huge, however, I'm just thinking if there's any value in spending those extra bucks. Can someone throw some light on this please. Thanks.
 
Solution

JKKirit

Commendable
Feb 10, 2017
5
0
1,510
I did compare the ports, PCIE slots etc, though not sure how to compare thermal wise protection as I'm a beginner.
Not much of a difference in the ports - they are + or - 1.
Display ports - there is the default HDMI however as I will use a graphics card, I'm not much worried about display ports.
What I would like to know is how with the PCIe channels will be used if I install devices in all of them. I read several reviews (though I can't understand much about how installing devices in these express slots makes the other ports useless). All I see is a Killer LAN port in the Gaming K5, additional M2 slot, but again in one of the reviews, there is some mention about this using x1 if filled, so not sure if this means slower performance of the M2 SSD. However, both these options doesn't support why I should go for a Gaming K5 (in my perspective). I'm looking to know if having an Aorus board will give me a better advantage in terms of BIOS layout, future proofing, difference in speed etc which techies would already have an idea on.
 
Buy the Gigabyte Z270X Ultra Gaming unless you want these additional features of the Gigabyte Z270X Gaming K5:

1.) On-board DisplayPort instead of an on-board DVI-D port.
2.) An add-on amplifier (TI Burr Brown NE5532P) and support for Sound Blaster X-Fi MB5.
3.) Killer E2500 LAN chip instead of Intel GbE LAN chip.
4.) An additional M.2 socket
5.) An additional SATAe connector
6.) An additional Audio Gain Control Switch in the motherboard
7.) One less USB3.0 rear port

If you feel that you direly need the above 7 items, then by all means get the Gigabyte Aorus Z270X Gaming K5. If not, then you're fine with the Gigabyte Z270X Ultra Gaming.
 

JKKirit

Commendable
Feb 10, 2017
5
0
1,510
Thanks raisonjohn.

Does this mean that apart from the above additional items, there will be no difference in how the actual software (firmware) behind works? Will the software on one be more advanced than the other, of course excluding the additional piece of code to support the additional items? I have read reviews where they used some tools/ games to stress test the various components and compared various mobos and highlighted differences which made me think that despite the physical differences, there could be software based differences too which can determine the performance mainly during overclocking etc.
 
ok
1. Killer Lan Port is a brand that isn't selling anymore in this areas (Texas) because many reviewed showed their Killer Lan port did nothing for lag and speed a 20$ NIC card from Netgear or TPLINK did already. its a gimmick name in my eyes and worth nothing.
2. M.2 Ports are used Mostly for SSD Drives, and what they all say is when the M.2 Port is filled with an Device, the first SATA port will be disabled, but that matter not, just plug other drive in Stata #2 port and off you go. this again is standard
3. I looked at them both , I see nothing outstanding between them

4. comparing the basics
Gigabyte GA-Z270X-Gaming K5 LGA1151 ATX RAM 4 up to 64GB $179.99
Gigabyte GA-Z270X-Ultra Gaming LGA1151 ATX RAM 4 up to 64GB $164.89

myself I would pick the later of the two.

 


As I have enumerated above, those 7 features are the only differences between the 2 motherboards (aside from the general layout of connectors and headers, and of course, the overall look, which is subjective).

The PCIe lane sharing of both boards are the same. They both have three PCIe x16 slots and three PCIe x1 slots. In Z270 Chipsets with 7th gen. Intel CPUs, the CPU usually accounts for a maximum 16x PCIe lanes, while the Chipset accounts for the 24x PCIe lanes, giving you a total of 40x PCIe lanes.

The 16x lanes controlled by the CPU in these motherboards are the two PCIe x16 slots, namely: PCIEX16 and PCIEX8. This means that when you plug in 1 video card in the PCIEX16 slot, it will run at [x16] bandwidth. If you plug in 1 video card in the PCIEX8 slot, it will run at [x8] bandwidth only. If you plug 2 video cards, one in the PCIEX16 and one in the PCIEX8 slots, then the video cards will run in [x8/x8] bandwidths. 8x + 8x = 16x, that's your total PCIe lanes controlled by the CPU.

The rest of the other lanes are controlled by the Z270 Chipset and in no way will direly affect the bandwidth and performance of the two PCIe x16 slots I mentioned above.

The 24x PCIe lanes controlled by the PCH are the following:
- The DMI3.0 Link between PCH and CPU running at [x4]
- The third x16 expansion slot (PCIEX4) running at [x4] BUT may decrease to [x1]* when PCIEX1_2 or PCIEX_3 is occupied
- The first x1 expansion slot (PCIEX1_1) running at [x1]
- The second x1 expansion slot (PCIEX1_2) running at [x1]* (Shares bandwidth with PCIEX4)
- The third x1 expansion slot (PCIEX1_3) running at [x1]* (Shares bandwidth with PCIEX4)
- The rear USB3.1 Type-A port running at [x2]
- The rear USB3.1 Type-C port running at [x2]
- The LAN module running at [x1]
- The M.2 socket (M2A_32G), if configured in PCIe mode, running at [x4] or [x2]
- (For Gaming K5 only): The second M.2 socket (M2M_32G), if configured in PCIe mode, running at [x4] or [x2]
- The rest would be some SATA ports (I cannot find a block diagram on this).

So, generally speaking, you won't have any concerns in populating the x16 slots as the CPU covers the required lanes. Your concern would be the M.2 sharing bandwidth with the SATA ports.

In the Gigabyte Z270X Gaming K5, there are 2x M.2 Sockets share some bandwidth with the SATA connectors:
The M.2 socket (M2M_32G), if populated in whatever mode, disables the SATA3_4 and SATA3_5 connectors. This M.2 socket DOES NOT disable the SATA3_0, SATA3_1, SATA3_2, and SATA3_3 connectors.
The M.2 socket (M2A_32G), if in SATA-mode only, disables the SATA3_0 connector only. If this M.2 socket is in PCIe x4/x2-mode, it DOES NOT disable any SATA connectors.
Note that in the Gigabyte Z270X Ultra Gaming, there is only 1x M.2 Socket (M2A_32G).
 
Solution