Accessing Internet but Blocking LAN through Unmanaged Switch

Vikesk

Prominent
Feb 27, 2017
5
0
510
I want to add three RJ45 sockets to an unmanaged switch. While the rest of the devices on the network are connected to each other I want to restrict access to the network to users on these 3 ports but allow them to use the Internet. Is there a device that I can use to do this or can it be configured via software/policy/permissions? The devices are on a workgroup, not a domain.
 
Solution
Vlans and layer 3 switches work for your problem except the requirement you added in a latter post of internet access. The one feature most layer 3 switches can not do it nat. A layer3 switch to not delay the traffic only supports features that do not change the data. Things like NAT and VPN modify the packets so you need a router.....this is really the main difference between a router and a layer3 switch.

Most consumer routers only support a single lan subnet. You need one that support multiple subnets which in most cases means it supports vlans. There are many lower end commercial routers that can do this but the cheapest way is to load third party firmware like dd-wrt on a consumer router that supports it.

When you have a...
If you have full control of the end machines via group policy and the users do not have admin control you can restrict what IP they can talk to.

Other than that you are going to need a managed switch and vlans to accomplish what you want. You can also do it via a feature on more advanced switches called private vlans or brute force traffic filters if you are willing to key those in.
 

Tina_Jiang

Prominent
Feb 24, 2017
10
0
520
I don't think you can do that. All internet access policies can only based on IP addresses, MAC addresses, or domain usernames. There is no way to limit internet via switch ports.
 

Vikesk

Prominent
Feb 27, 2017
5
0
510
Thanks for the responses. Tina_Jiang, it's not the internet I want to limit. I want full access to the internet but no access to the rest of the network (workgroup) from these three ports.
 

tiredteck

Distinguished
Jun 29, 2009
69
0
18,660


Hard code the IP address of the three machines for a separate LAN using the same subnet and Gateway as the current system. Or use a Netgear Prosafe Plus GS108 V3 with VLANs built in and configure VLAN.

tt/2
 

Vikesk

Prominent
Feb 27, 2017
5
0
510


Hi tiredtek, Thanks for your answer. I'm assuming that it needs to be the V3 (Layer 3) version of this switch. Am I correct in thinking the V2 is an unmanaged version and would not support VLANS?

 
Vlans and layer 3 switches work for your problem except the requirement you added in a latter post of internet access. The one feature most layer 3 switches can not do it nat. A layer3 switch to not delay the traffic only supports features that do not change the data. Things like NAT and VPN modify the packets so you need a router.....this is really the main difference between a router and a layer3 switch.

Most consumer routers only support a single lan subnet. You need one that support multiple subnets which in most cases means it supports vlans. There are many lower end commercial routers that can do this but the cheapest way is to load third party firmware like dd-wrt on a consumer router that supports it.

When you have a router that supports vlans you can either also use switches that support vlans (simple layer 2) or you can connect different physical switches to different router ports and then only the router need to be special.
 
Solution

tiredteck

Distinguished
Jun 29, 2009
69
0
18,660


The V2 version does support VLANS BUT requires a management program Provided by Netgear. The V3 Version of the Switch can use the same program but can also be access and managed with a web browser interface. The Web interface is much easier to use.