Reference Card (1080 series) vs Partner (ASUS, MSI, etc) and Overclocking

LanzoCommando

Commendable
Feb 21, 2016
142
0
1,710
So here's my question...

When buying a GPU if you are going to overclock yourself is there any real reason to buy and aftermarket "OC" version? I know they have "base" clocks that are higher...but if you are just going to do it yourself then does it make it pointless to buy the aftermarket "OC" version?

The 1080TI's are "out" and I want one...BAD. My worry is that if I wait for the non-reference cards to come out a week or so from now I may have to wait for the "rape and gouge" period to be over for people who are able to get the cards and hose the rest of us. I can't sit at a computer all day and wait for stock to fill...and I also don't want to pay a retailer markup just because.

NVIDIA is going to start taking pre-orders for the ref cards tomorrow, so, should I see if I can snatch up a order? My only worry is a "better" version from ASUS or someone else comes out a week later, but that's a gamble because 1. How much better can it be if I am going to overclock the reference anyway? and 2. I may not be able to get one for 699.00 even though that's what the press release says they will be.

What do you all think? I AM upgrading no matter what so the "need" of a 1080TI is not the question as it will set me up to upgrade to 4K (run 2K right now) down the road when a better monitor comes out (thinking about that new ASUS 4K 144 HDR).
 
Solution
So what I'd do is just hang tight. They're saying the TI actually uses vapor heat pipes like top of the line cpu air coolers. If so this might actually keep the temps a lot lower than previous generations.

The_Staplergun

Estimable
Jan 30, 2017
1,395
0
2,960
The aftermarket overclocked versions are guaranteed at least the clock sold at.

The FE cards or any reference cards have a very simple cooling solution but it isn't as good as aftermarket.

Aftermarket cards (not directly manufactured by Nvidia) are better off most times in cooling and therefore performance.
 

Math Geek

Titan
Ambassador
aftermarket cards are almost always better. they are quieter, cooler and tend to handle an oc better due to generally better design. as a result, the aftermarket cards are preferred in almost all cases. only time a reference blower ype card is suggested is for a small build where blowing the heat out the back is preferred over inside the case like the custom cards tend to do.

as for actual performance of an oc, that is VERY debatable. all the pascal cards so far have performed nearly identical. the custom cards tended to see a decent gain over the FE card but after that, they all did the same. no matter what speed it is set at out of the box, the custom cards all oc'ed to the same speeds and attained the same in game fps more or less. so the lowest priced 1080, performed the same as the highest price super cooled, over-engineered ones.

i don't expect anything different with a 1080ti. no reason to think it will based on all the other cards. but it is worth waiting for custom cards and choosing one of those. which will be the best?? doubtful anyone will separate itself form the others. but we won't know until we start seeing some reviews of the cards. give it a few weeks to see what the reviews say or take your chances on the first thing that comes by. personally i'd wait it out for a while then jump in with knowledge on your side.

as for worrying about buying and then something better coming along. that ALWAYS happens. no reason to let that stop you. the 1080 is not too old and was beaten by the titan x. now the titan x is beaten by the 1080 ti. Vega is coming out next month and who knows what that will bring. i am personally waiting out Vega and this card and letting the dust settle before making any decision. then i will buy knowing what i am getting and will have no regrets. 6 months from now i fully expect something new and better to come out, but that's just how electronics work. you'll never avoid that.

this thread has a list of all the various models available and links to many reviews if you wish to do some reading. as soon as the 1080ti models come out and reviews start to show i will be updating the thread with that info http://www.tomshardware.com/forum/id-3047729/nvidia-geforce-gtx-1000-series-megathread-faq-resources.html

but for now all we got is what nvidia said yesterday.

finally pricing has changed this time around. the FE cards tend to be more expensive than most custom cards. so if they say $700 for a reference 1080ti i expect custom cards to be less like they are for all the other pascal cards. rigth away they will be more costly but that is the early adopters tax you can't avoid the first few weeks.

give it a month or more and prices will level, the new Vega cards will be out and when the dust settles, you will have a better idea what covers your needs and at what price
 
Graphics card vendors bin their chips and use the better ones in factory overclocked versions
that they can sell for more. You may be able to OC more, but then again, perhaps not.
They try to differentiate by adding cosmetics and fancy coolers which also sell for more.
I do think you get fair value from a modest factory overclocked card.
If you need more performance, they buy a higher tier card in the first place.

GTX1080ti represents a big jump over anything else available today.
If you can buy a reference card early at a decent price, go ahead.
You may or may not be a winner in the binning lottery, but the base card will do very well.

If you can wait, the factory overclocked cards will give you fair value for your money.

I think it more likely that the first cards will command a price premium regardless.
 

LanzoCommando

Commendable
Feb 21, 2016
142
0
1,710


This is more my point. That "price premium" for the non-reference cards is going to be atrocious at first. The reference cards will be 699, says so on NVIDIA's shopping page as well, so if I can get it on the pre-order tomorrow then I can snatch one up for the 699.

I read SUPPOSEDLY NVIDIA is eliminating the "founders" premium this time and the 699 represents what the MSRP for aftermarket cards will be, but I'm guessing they'll be gouged by sellers in the beginning and run 8, 9, or even 1K.

I could run a reference TI (if I can get one in the AM) for a while, basically wait out the gouge/rape extravaganza, and when the non-ref cards even out sell it and take maybe a 100 dollar hit for the card I want IF there is any real tangible difference.

I don't mind a 100 dollar hit for 4, 5, 6 months of the performance I want.
 

LanzoCommando

Commendable
Feb 21, 2016
142
0
1,710


The presser had the 1080ti running at 2GHZ and mid 60's. That's enough for me to wait out the gouge extravaganza that is coming with those aftermarket cards.

Like I said above I'd take a 100 dollar hit for several months of that performance level while I wait out the gouge if those cards are going to be worth it.

I'm looking for tangible benefit...single digit frames aren't worth it if the reference card will run 2GHZ at mid 60s, at least in the sense of getting a TI now and then thinking about another switch in several months.
 

LanzoCommando

Commendable
Feb 21, 2016
142
0
1,710


Didn't the custom cards hold those "advantages" due to the overclock? I know they run a bit better, but my point is a ref 1070 and a base gigabyte or asus 1070 run near identical right? It's when you get into the OC versions where the benefits come in.

But since I'd OC the ref card it really doesn't make a huge difference in this case. I think? LoL.

You can see in my above responses references to temps and I'm definitely not worried about noise as I wear a headset and don't hear it anyway.

IF the cards are way better i'd be willing to take a 100 dollar hit to ride out the gouge and get an aftermarket card later...but my question is really about if I can get a 1080ti IN HAND for 699 if I should pull the trigger even though it's a reference card.
 

Math Geek

Titan
Ambassador
i am saying that all the custom cards get the same fps oc'ed or not!!. the EVGA SC which is a reference design gets the same fps as a FTW card which costs a lot more.

other thing to remember or learn if you don't already know is that Boost 3.0 will overclock EVERY card to it's max. and that max is the same for every card. been around 2.0-2.1 ghz for every single card put out from FE to top of the line custom models. difference with custom over FE is the cooler and quieter operation and a few extra fps due to that fact. so you speak of overclocking and i am telling you that it makes literally no in game fps difference on any of the pascal cards.

i don't expect a 1080ti to be any different as it is still a pascal card. you'll get a more stable max boost out of custom cards allowing for it to stay maxed out cooler, quieter and for longer periods. but don't expect any miracles from custom cards. i fully expect boost 3.0 to do the same for the 1080ti as it does for all the other cards. that is to get it to a top speed by itself and hit a max speed that they all will share.

so a 1080 set at reference 1600 mhz still boosts to 2.0+ ghz the same as one set at 1900 mhz out of the box. still boosts to 2.0-2.1 ghz. no real reason to drop extra money on top of the line card to get the same as much cheaper model. but in all cases the FE has been the worst performer every time and that should stay the same this time as well.
 

LanzoCommando

Commendable
Feb 21, 2016
142
0
1,710


So. I got in this morning and got a confirmed pre-order. LoL. It's almost a moot point now.

What I was thinking of is this. Right now this card, the founders edition, will CRUSH everything at 2K and get me in the 100's as of FPS all day every day.

Ekwb has reference blocks and I've been looking hard as possibly down the road going to a water cooled GPU (just because) so temps prob won't be an issue regardless, BUT, and this is the crazy part, towards the end of the year I'll be looking at upgrading to 4K, and IF somebody gets a tangible difference out of the STRIX cards or whatever then I can sell the founders 1080ti for like 500, probably a little more, and take 200 dollar hit as by then the rape fest will be over. 200 bucks for 4 or 5 months of no sacrifice 2K performance is worth it to me at this point.

Also...if by some miracle I can pick up one of the after market cards sooner, like within a month, without getting raped, I could just return the founders card to the NVIDIA store.

But this way I'm def gonna be in the 1080TI game ASAP. :) What do you think?
 

LanzoCommando

Commendable
Feb 21, 2016
142
0
1,710


LoL. Me to...but I forsee HIGH prices on those for a while. I doubt you'll pick one up for 699. If they release soon (within a month) and they release at 699 I'll get one and return the Founders Edition (if I can snatch one up).

But at least this way I'm in the 1080ti game ricky tick. I'm not getting gouged by some dirty nasty capitalist! :D

*I love capitalism it's just a joke. Haha
 

DrkHared

Prominent
Mar 3, 2017
2
0
510
I am in the same boat as you and am a bit of a noob myself, but think that many others go through this, or have, at some point in their shopping adventures.

I am mostly worried that since I will want to overclock a Founder's card that it will not do as well overclocking as some of the custom models. The cooler on the Founder's does not bother me that much, because if you want to cool your chip can always add an AIO watercolor from Corsair or NZXT to cool it later for maybe a hundred bucks or so (assuming you have room for that it in your case)--but from what I have read, the limiting factor for overclocking has been the power delivery of the Founder's editions, as well as perhaps VRM temps, which AIO coolers might not handle?

A water cooled Founder's edition that can OC just as well as any of the custom models, plus have all the benefit of quiet operation, is a real big win in theory for me. Anybody successfully cool and overclock FE cards this way?
 

LanzoCommando

Commendable
Feb 21, 2016
142
0
1,710


Yeah I saw the Firestrike leak and it supposedly had the ref edition running a constant 2062mhz with 120-some% power at 63 degrees, and that's WITH the stock vapor chamber setup that got reworked. Seems like that's pretty successful to me!?

As for the price of non-reference cards...I know they will MSRP at 699 but you won't be able to buy them in the beginning for that. No way. They'll sell out and be gouged or gouged a bit outright. I don't think 100 dollars is worth going from low 60's to high 50's, IF that's what those coolers will land you at. Only chance you have is playing the "refresh" lottery if they release for 699, and since they don't release the time like they did for the reference (which didn't open on time and still sold out in minutes) it's a crap shoot. I literally took dedicated break time at work to be ready for the pre-orders to go live and I think it's the only reason I got one.

Order on NVIDIA says "boxed shipment." I'm excited!
 

LanzoCommando

Commendable
Feb 21, 2016
142
0
1,710


I've seen this done all over man. That's pretty much my plan...custom block down the road.

As far as I can tell the OC's are the same across the board so long as you can keep the cards cool. The performance leak on the Chinese forums shows re-donky specs for the TI with the stock cooler holding to low 60's @2062 mhz. I'd wonder if a water block could push it harder but it seems like probably not since 63 isn't high anyway.

For me it's worth it to have a TI immediately...but if I hadn't bought one yet at this point i'd wait to see what the non-ref cards have to offer.

I only bought the pre-order ref edition because I DID NOT want to take the chance of getting gouged or having to wait, but since you can't get a ref edition now anyway (preorders are sold out) you might as well wait to see what the non ref bench's are...because rest assured as soon as the cards go live on the 10th those bench's will be out ricky tick.
 

LanzoCommando

Commendable
Feb 21, 2016
142
0
1,710


LoL.

They were "allowed' to release unboxing videos a few days ago so you know they already have all those bench videos ready to post. I can't really see how after the cards go to launch how they can keep them from posting the bench's YOU KNOW they've had to have done already....unless they really have the self-control to not put them in a machine.

But i guess I don't know for sure. LoL. And now that I really think about it they probably don't have access to the non ref cards, but if they "launch worldwide" on the 10th as well surely by now some of these guys have one. Then it's the same situation as above...how could you NOT put that in a computer and try it if you had it?

Either way if I didn't have one confirmed I'd wait for the bench's at this point. Hell I have one coming and I still may switch it out. Haha.
 

Math Geek

Titan
Ambassador
that i don't recall seeing but the 10th is the confirmed day. i'd assume stores will have them when they open and online likely would be early morning if past releases can be trusted.

but that's all i got there, just guesses as to what time. if you're trying online, you need to sit there with stores open and click refresh a lot :)
 

Math Geek

Titan
Ambassador
not specific times but was very early morning. don't recall it being midnight but very close to it for online stores to go live selling. they only have a date they can't sell before. i'd be on at midnight refreshing away if you have to have one first day.
 

LanzoCommando

Commendable
Feb 21, 2016
142
0
1,710


This is exactly why I pre-ordered, LoL. I searched for a hot minute to check the time from a few different sources and even then the NVIDIA store didn't go live on time, about 10 minutes late. I only had a dedicated 15min block of break time scheduled for the 10am Pacific time hack so I was sweating it.

Now it's the "right place/right time" refresh lottery. A lot of places will probably have E-Mail notification after they lose their initial stock but even then you're still in the trenches vs everyone else on the list and at the mercy of how often you can check your box (or how fast your box populates E-Mails it receives).