Cost effective NAS for non-expert

Peds013

Honorable
Mar 17, 2012
70
0
10,640
Hey all,

I've got a custom PC which I've had about 4 years, the boot SSD seems to have gone kaput... I can deal with that, however, that's by far the newest drive in that PC. I've got about 4.5 Tb of other HDDs that I use for backup, one of them is about 8 years old.

Everything I care about is spread across those drives, family photos, music, films, work projects, school prjects etc... It's made me start to worry about the security of all that stuff! I've been thinking about getting a NAS drive for a number of years but the enclosed systems (even the one's excl. HDDs) work out to be hideously expensive - especially as I'd want one drive redundancy. I'm not a mug with computers (basic Linux and coding experience) but I'd never attempt to call myself a sys admin!

I wonder if there's a stand out winning option - either a cost effective complete NAS system, or an easy way to self build a server that has all the functionality of, say, a Synology NAS system.

To make things more complicated, my household runs a mix of Windows, android and Mac devices.

Any help or guidance would be much appreciated. Thanks and best regards,
Pete
 
Solution
Define "cost effective".

The newer NAS boxes are pretty good.
I recently got a QNAP TS-453A.
https://www.qnap.com/en-us/product/model.php?II=212
https://www.amazon.com/QNAP-Professional-Grade-Attached-Supports-TS-453A-4G-US/dp/B017YB7T6U

A little box of awesomeness.

Just add whatever drives you want.
Currently I have 4 x 3TB in it, in RAID 5. So 8TB effective space.
This is also backed up to an 8TB USB connected drive (once I finish setting it up).

I used to use just a regular small PC with a bunch of drives.
HTPC and house server functions.
This NAS box is taking over all of that, and doing it better.
Cheapest solution is to get a Synology or Qnap 2-bay NAS... both are compatible w/ Windows and Mac, just turn on the different protocols.

More fun, turn the PC into a FreeNAS device. I have 2.

PM me for details on the FreeNAS setup, if you want to go that way.
 

USAFRet

Titan
Moderator
Define "cost effective".

The newer NAS boxes are pretty good.
I recently got a QNAP TS-453A.
https://www.qnap.com/en-us/product/model.php?II=212
https://www.amazon.com/QNAP-Professional-Grade-Attached-Supports-TS-453A-4G-US/dp/B017YB7T6U

A little box of awesomeness.

Just add whatever drives you want.
Currently I have 4 x 3TB in it, in RAID 5. So 8TB effective space.
This is also backed up to an 8TB USB connected drive (once I finish setting it up).

I used to use just a regular small PC with a bunch of drives.
HTPC and house server functions.
This NAS box is taking over all of that, and doing it better.
 
Solution

Darthutos

Reputable
Sep 15, 2014
757
2
5,160
the main cost of any nas system is in hdds. e.g. for an average 8tb hdd the cost is 300 or so dollars.
if you just need a empty nas box, I myself, eg. is using a pentium g3258 (65w) with an asrock z97 mobo, in a silverstone gd08 htpc case. and a regular ocz 80 plus 750w psu. about 200 dollars tops.
I also have3x4tb in dmdraid 5 2x8tb seagate archive which eventually I will make a dmdraid 1 setup. I also have another hgst hdd. all told I spent probably more than 3000 dollars or even more.
You see it's all about how many hdd and how big you want your hdd to be.

I recommend you diy nas. except maybe in california where the power/watt is king kong and you want to save every cents from power bill. otherwise I cannot recommend a prebuilt nas if you have a simple computer know how.