NZXT Noctis 450 or Silverstone Primera PM01 ???

Rotem_46

Distinguished
Sep 8, 2008
26
0
18,530
Hi,
I've just upgraded my 10 years old PC.
Back in the days, I bought the best of the best money (my money that is) could buy and my PC lasted for 10 wonderful years without any problem, going 24/7, that's 3650 days working non-stop :)
Anyway, I've decided to upgrade the "main stuff" to enjoy newer technology, so I only kept my Corsair HX620 PSU and my Gigabyte Aurora 3D case.
After putting everything together I've realized that my case does wrong to my beautiful new components and I've decided to upgrade.
After a lot of reading, I narrowed it down to 2 cases, the NZXT Noctis 450 and the SS Primera PM01. I actually first thought I'll be getting the Corsair 760T as it is amazing and I have optical drives, a Card Redar and a hard drive hot swap but those 2 cases blew me away (design wise).
Can you guys help me decide between the two?
First, I want a quiet case.
Second, I want it to last !
I'm not planing to OC anything as I'm not a gamer, I mainly use it for Photoshop.
My components are :
Asus Z270E Gaming
I7 7700K cooled down by my good old Thermalright TRUE 120 Extreme (Had to buy an adapter for it to fit the newer 1151 MB) with 2 Noctua 120mm fans.
32GB G.Skill Trident 3200 CL14 (2x16GB)
Asus GTX1070 Strix
Samsung Evo 500GB SSD
4 TB of hard drives for data (2x1TB + 1x2TB) but I can give some of them up.
Now, I know the 450 has a better fan hub as it has a speed controller.
I want to know what you guys think...
I've read somewhere that a guy with the 450 complained about the door thumb screws that are very bad and he is actually trying to avoid opening the door unless he really has too...
Anyway, if someone here had a chance to work with both cases I'll really appreciate any info.
Price wise the PM01 is the cheapest, it is not available in my country buy I can order it online.
The 450 costs like $50 more but available here.
Just for a comparison, the Corsair 760T cost roughly $50 more than the 450...
Thanks for your help and sorry for the long post :)
 

Aeacus

Titan
Ambassador
Since choosing a case is completely a personal choice, go with the one that likes you the most.

Out of the 2 cases, i'd go with Silverstone case. 2 reasons:
1. It supports 3x 140mm at front.
2. I can see the LEDs on front fans thanks to the see-through grille it has.

Though, i haven't worked with any of the 2 cases and i can't tell more about them based on my personal experience. But what i can tell you about is the Corsair 760T case since my Skylake build sits in it (full specs in my sig.) If you want to have LEDs in 760T, you can buy NZXT HUE+ like i did.
Here are few pics of my Skylake build if you're interested,
1st set of pics: http://www.tomshardware.co.uk/forum/id-3272328/show-newest-system-upgrade-components.html#19158458
2nd set of pics: http://www.tomshardware.co.uk/forum/id-3272328/show-newest-system-upgrade-components/page-2.html#19277195

As far as your concerns go, it's not the case that makes the PC quiet - it's the case fans you install in them. For example, if i were to take an epic fan like this and put it in any PC case, regardless how "quiet" the PC case is according to the manufacturer, you can be certain that your PC won't be quiet at all.

About longevity, your PC case can last decades if you take good care of it. Also the price of the case is a good indicator for build quality. As far as full-tower ATX cases go, you can get the cheapest full-tower ATX for $70.
pcpp: http://pcpartpicker.com/products/case/#t=4&sort=a8&page=1
Corsair 760T comes with premium price of $170, pcpp: http://pcpartpicker.com/product/x3Crxr/corsair-case-cc9011073ww
 

Rotem_46

Distinguished
Sep 8, 2008
26
0
18,530
Thanks for your answer Aeacus, Your system looks pretty cool :)
I've read that the PM01 fans are working at 100% so noise levels are pretty high so let me ask you this, can I replace the Silverstone's built in fan hub with say the Swiftech PWM fan controller? http://www.swiftech.com/8-WayPWMsplitter-sata.aspx
It will give me the ability to control all fans speed and basically control the noise level.
I also really like the Thermaltake Riing led fans and I would really love having them installed...I will have to read about them though to see if they are quiet.
 

Aeacus

Titan
Ambassador
Solution