Extending WiFi with Router and Powerline Advice Please

Witterings

Distinguished
Dec 23, 2016
60
1
18,535
I apologize for the long post and that I have limited IT knowledge but any help really would be greatly appreciated !!!!

The only ADSL entry point in the house is in the worst place it could be so my WiFi range needs extending and I've been using one of these
http://www.pcadvisor.co.uk/review/powerline-adapters/tp-link-300mbps-av500-wifi-powerline-extender-review-3491664/

With the current set up my laptop continually drops the wireless connection and chromecasts constantly disconnect and won't connect again without a power cycle ... if I sync them to the main routers wireless connection rather than the secondary TP Link wireless connection they stay connected but the speed is dismal due to walls / distance.

I was talking to someone today that works in IT and they commented that the wireless adapters connection is pretty carp and you're much better off using the wired powerline connected to a router as the secondary access point.

My main router is a TP Link Archer MR 200 ... I've had a lot of problems with it dropping VoIP calls and only the other day found out how to prioritise bandwidth and ... for now it so seems to have stopped doing it.

I live a long way from shops and whilst there bought a Netgear Nighthawk R 7000 before I resolved the current VoIP issue (supposedly they're quite good for VoIP) but am thinking about using it via a plugged in powerline adapter to provide the main wireless connection that everybody uses.

If so ... am I best keeping the TP Link as the primary router connected to the ADSL line and the Netgear with the higher wireless capability and where the demand is or the other way round?????

I'd rather the Netgear was the primary (just works better for some functions in a home office) but not if it means the WiFi is weaker at the secondary stage or will that be a minimal difference ... we're not huge users ... office / VoIP is hard wired into the main router .. secondary is streaming music / videos for personal use.

Any help really would be appreciated!!
 
Solution
AFAIK, powerline equipment of the szem standard in interchangeable. I don't use it any more so I can't say from practical experience. If you own the home, it may be worth the money to have an installer run a few ethernet cables. It is amazing what a experienced installer can do.

For anyone that will rely on tech support help, I suggest buying from only one company though so there can be no passing of tech support responsibility on to another company.

Pooneil

Honorable
Apr 15, 2013
1,222
0
11,960
Yes home wifi equipment is not very easy to set up so that it really works. Sometimes it is not possible without some form of wired network, eithernet or powerline.

If you absolutely can't run ethernet, powerline is the better option to extend your network. The newest standard is "AV2." It makes use wires in a way that gives it a better chance of crossing through circuits that are on different sides of the breaker box.

Check out this site for some ratings and reviews.

https://www.smallnetbuilder.com/tools/rankers/powerline/view

My personal experience with powerline was a while ago and it was what prompted me to wire up my home with ethernet. All it really took was watching a installer make one drop to learn enough to do the rest myself.
 

Witterings

Distinguished
Dec 23, 2016
60
1
18,535
Pooneil,
I ended up extending and using the cheaper plug in Adaptors I have rather than the wireless adaptor and certainly there's a massive improvement already both in terms of down / upload speeds but also the chrome casts now stay connected and are visible on the network.

Certainly ideally ethernet extension would be the best but Murphy's law where it is there's no way to run it where it wouldn't be highly visible unfortunately ..... think I'll try my latest setup for a while and look at maybe upgrading to and AV2 standard at some stage as well so the link was very useful!!!

Are all powerline adaptors compatible ie if I changed to AV2 and had the main one off the router and another "this end" ... if I then have older ones plugged in elsewhere in less important places would they still work or would I have to upgrade them all???

Thanks for your help and inout!!!!
 

Pooneil

Honorable
Apr 15, 2013
1,222
0
11,960
AFAIK, powerline equipment of the szem standard in interchangeable. I don't use it any more so I can't say from practical experience. If you own the home, it may be worth the money to have an installer run a few ethernet cables. It is amazing what a experienced installer can do.

For anyone that will rely on tech support help, I suggest buying from only one company though so there can be no passing of tech support responsibility on to another company.
 
Solution