Laptop RAM failed ...then worked?

KushDragon

Reputable
Feb 25, 2015
19
0
4,520
My work laptop is an Alienware 15 laptop with two sticks of 16GB DDR4 GSkill laptop RAM. Today at work out of boredom, I took the bottom panel off of the laptop. I then removed one of the 16GB sticks of RAM, fondled her a bit for no reason, then put the stick back in. Shortly after re-insertion I realized that I hadn't turned the laptop off prior to removing the stick of RAM. So, in my head I was thinking "Darn, I might have to force the computer to shut down after I put the screw back in". Regardless of whether or not it's okay to take out a stick of RAM and put it back in while a computer is sleeping, I knew that there was a decent chance that the laptop hadn't fully gone to sleep, and that regardless, what I had done might end up necessitating a power cycle in order to restore functionality. However, I wasn't really nervous about any of this at this time. It was just kind of a "oh, I should've probably turned it off first" moment. Anyway, I open up the laptop and sure enough the screen is black and I have no control. I then held the power button to force a shutdown, but when I booted her back up I got a black screen and 3 or 4 beeping sounds. At this point I got a little nervous, but I assumed that I just hadn't secured the RAM sufficiently, so I took the bottom back off, unplugged both sticks and plugged them back in. BEEP, BEEP, BEEP. Now this is where it gets weird: After attempting to boot from each sticks individually, I determined that one of the sticks (we'll call it "stick B") had gone bad because the laptop would boot from stick A just fine. But out of curiosity I plugged stick A into the other RAM slot and attempted the boot. I got a black screen and beeps. At this point I assumed that it was the RAM slot on the mobo that was failing. But, once again out of curiosity, I plugged stick B (the one I had previously presumed to be dead) into the slot that I was now suspicious about, and I got a black screen and beeps. At this point I was so confused that I took out stick B, set it on a notepad next to stick A, left the laptop open, and just sorta sat down in a chair and stared at the wall. After a few minutes I plugged both sticks back in and turned on the laptop. It booted fine. Windows recognized all 32GB and everything was like normal.

How?
 
If the laptop was asleep, it was probably storing the "current windows state" in the ram, and then when you removed it the ram lost all it's data, but windows was looking for it. beep beep beep

After leaving both sticks out, they both lost their data, and any other data was or searching for previous windows states was stopped and it just booted from fresh.

Don't do it again as you likely got lucky.

Also any thing you had opened and unsaved is definitely gone forever.
 

KushDragon

Reputable
Feb 25, 2015
19
0
4,520


Thanks for the reply!
That makes a lot of sense, and it was sort of what I thought, however, I still wonder why the RAM didn't forget all data the moment it was unplugged. During that period of time where I couldn't get the laptop to boot there were definitely moments where I had forced the laptop to shut down, and had withdrawn both sticks completely before another was inserted, and yet I still got the beeps/black screen. It's as if one or more of the sticks of RAM needed several minutes of no power to forget all retained information. Is that possible? In other words, do you know how long it takes for RAM (from the time it's removed from power to the time it's plugged back in and given power) to completely forget all temporary data stored on it?

And yeah, fortunately I didn't have anything that needed to be saved at the time. I always save things before I shut my computer anyway.