Reallocated Sector Count high but no problems found

Jasiek95

Prominent
Apr 12, 2017
36
0
540
Had a laptop HDD from 2012 lying around that once saw heavy use but was dropped after S.M.A.R.T detected critical irregularities. The one that seems to stick out the most is the "Reallocated Sector Count" entry with a raw value of "7C0430". I assumed that was in hexadecimal so I converted the numbered portion to decimal and got '1072', which is equal to the amount of "Bad sectors" detected by HD sentinel.

CrystaDiskInfo Screenshot:


The curious thing is that Chkdsk finds no issues and states that no remapping of sectors is necessary. The test also passes WD Lifeguard Diagnostic's quick and extended tests and HD tune's. HD Sentinel itself cant find any bad sectors during the surface and hard disk tests and Hitachi's WinDFT program finds no faults.

All sensitive data has been removed and a full format was completed prior to the creation of this post. The drive will not be used for running an OS (just for steam backups and some games) so i'm not too stressed if it bums out, just wondering how much life is left on the drive so I can put off buying an external HDD for a little bit longer.

Specs and extra info:

PC: Lenovo y510p gaming laptop (circa 2013)
HDD: 1TB SATAIII HDD (Main drive, unrelated to the HDD in question)
CPU: i7 4700mq (~3.4GHz, OC to 3.6GHz)
GPU: 2x 750m in SLI
OS: Windows 8.1 64 Bit

Problematic HDD: HGST Travelstar 2.5-inch 750GB SATAII HDD
Connected to PC via Orico USB 3 SATA Enclosure (as external drive)
- Power on time: 544 days & 5 hours
- Estimated Remaining lifetime: 7 days (been testing by writing things to it for the last month though
without any problems)
- Total Start/Stop Count: 4870



 
Solution
Windows can't see them, thats why chkdsk reacts like that

Realloacted Sector Count = INVISIBLE bad sectors that have been swapped with reserve sectors. These sectors are NO LONGER VISIBLE to your operating system and as such can NEVER cause any more problems.

Current Pending Sector = ACTIVE VISIBLE bad sectors that CANNOT BE READ but are still visible to the operating system. These are VERY DANGEROUS and cause ALOT of problems!

However, the value 200 you're seeing is a normalized value where the higher = better. You have to look at the RAW VALUE instead! For example, a raw value of 0 reallocated sectors might be the equivalent of a 200 normalized value. If the normalized value drops below the THRESHOLD value, that SMART attribute...

Colif

Win 11 Master
Moderator
Windows can't see them, thats why chkdsk reacts like that

Realloacted Sector Count = INVISIBLE bad sectors that have been swapped with reserve sectors. These sectors are NO LONGER VISIBLE to your operating system and as such can NEVER cause any more problems.

Current Pending Sector = ACTIVE VISIBLE bad sectors that CANNOT BE READ but are still visible to the operating system. These are VERY DANGEROUS and cause ALOT of problems!

However, the value 200 you're seeing is a normalized value where the higher = better. You have to look at the RAW VALUE instead! For example, a raw value of 0 reallocated sectors might be the equivalent of a 200 normalized value. If the normalized value drops below the THRESHOLD value, that SMART attribute counts as a FAILURE. So if the normalized value is 200 and the threshold value is 100, that would be perfect, while the normalized value being 98 and the threshold being 100 would mean that attribute signals a FAILURE.

My advice: do not look at the normalized values at all. Only look at the RAW values!

Important SMART attributes:
- Reallocated Sector Count = bad sectors in the past; this might have caused problems in the past but does not have to; drives replace weak sectors as a precaution which may never have caused any problems.
- Current Pending Sector = THE MOST DANGEROUS smart attribute; this should ALWAYS BE ZERO or you have severe problems! This can be either weak electric charge with insufficient ECC correction ability -OR- it can be physical damage. Writing to this sector will solve the problem; if there was physical damage it will be realloacted by a reserve sector and the Reallocated Sector Count raw value will increase.
- UDMA CRC Error Count = cabling errors; if this is higher than 1000 and increasing you have severe cabling problems; under 100 does not need to trigger any alarm. Technically this means the receiving end did receive a corrupted version of the data that was sent by the transmitter; the corruption was detected by CRC which means the data is NOT accepted and the request will be sent again. Unless you see very high values or it keeps increasing steadily, this usually is not a big issue.

https://arstechnica.com/civis/viewtopic.php?p=22062211

I don't think its a good sign but I don't think drive will just stop working. I would backup everything just in case and watch it as its a sign sectors are going bad and the hdd only has so many spare.
 
Solution