jaguarskx :
RAM do not actually have to be purchased in matching pairs for them to work in dual channel mode. /
No one said that. What was said is that "RAM absolutely must be purchased in matching pairs for them to be
guaranteed to work". If you have a 1 x 8GB stick installed and but another 8GB stick ... it may not work, I don't mean it may not work at double data rate, it may not work at all. And then the user is left with two sticks of incompatible RAM and no ability to return the product under warranty.... although you might get lucky at the store if returned within 30 days as many outlets have a no questions asked policy.
If you try an RMA after 30 days, you are not going be able to base a warranty claim based upon "I bought two separate packages of RAM and they don't work together" .... the manufacturer warrantees only that whatever comes in the package works together .... and that's why when you have a single stick fail in a matched pair that came in the same package, they send you 2 sticks not 1.
Your chances of getting it to work depend on several things:
1. The more things the same, the better. Make, Model, Speed, timings, module OEM, etc all factor in here, sometime counter intuitively. For example:
a) Many RAM vendors switch OEMs in the middle of a production run. Corsair's VP and Dominator line the performance level DDR3 used Hynix memory modules in the initial runs ... as production lines matured and yields improved, they decided to switched to a less expensive supplier. The used the same model number but the timings dropped from 10-12-12-28 to 10-12-12-31. As such, when getting that 2nd pair of RAM for your Corsair 10-12-12-28 VPs, you had a better chance of success buying Mushkin Redline w/ the identical Hynix 10-12-12-28 modules than the new Corsair VPs.
b) We had a user with RAM issues who wanted to upgrade back in the days of DDR2. He wanted to upgrade his set of Corsair 2 x 2 Gb to 4 x 2GB. My son was in a similar situation (Mushkin) so since I was looking, decided to grab 2 sets. Unfortunately neither Mushkin or Corsair were still making DDR2 and the only vendor available was GSkill w/ the same speed and timings. Adding the GSkill's to both boxes was a big fail. Before returning them, I tried the 4 Gskills together (two packages and it worked with a bit of a voltage tweak). On a lark, i tried the Mushkin w/ the Corsairs and they worked fine.
2. The 2nd issue is "just what are you asking for ?" With DDR3, as I said above, you have a pretty good shot. Yields on 1600 are obviously better than on 2400. So when "mixing pairs", the likelihood of a problem at 1600 is rather low ... however, the higher the performance, the harder it is to get a functioning matched pair. At 2400, you chances were about 50-50.