Hi,
If everything was normal before remounting the cooler, slack off the tension screws. They can be over tight causing mobo board flex.
As for paste, too much is worse than too little. Heat has to transfer between the cpu and heatsink (You get that) but if too much paste the heat can't transfer through the paste properly or quick enough concealing heat like an oven.
There's many methods of applying paste, firstly starting off with the pea drop or line which ever. Then usually apply pressure with the heatsink to spread the paste, however i like the glad rap on finger method. I've overclocked a couple systems 920 in my sig (Still going strong) and 2600k @ 4.5. Both very good temps using noctuas, but your dark rock should be just as good.
I use glad rap over finger to create a smooth spread without any prints. I'd rather paste to cover the entire cpu rather than allow control over pressure from heatsink itself, i just don't trust it and since the whole cpu surface will be pretty hot, i want to make use of the entire heatsink surface rather than 3/4's of it i've seen in diagrams.