Old i5 3470 or new Pentium G4560, which is better for a desktop gaming?

cifroes

Distinguished
May 3, 2011
40
1
18,535
For the same price I can get a 2nd hand PC with:
i5 3470
8GB DDR3 1333

or a new PC with:
Pentium G4560
Mobo B250M
8GB DDR4 2400

On both I would add a SSD and a 1050 2GB GPU.

For gaming purposes what would be the best performing CPU/DDR combo?
 
Solution
The i5 3470 is better, it has four physical cores and the G4560 has 2 physical cores and two virtual cores. Virtual cores are much worse than regular ones, the yeah, the i5 wins.
Both are somewhat comparable for now.
My guess is that the ageing 3470 is overpriced and not a good long term buy.


The B250m motherboard will support much higher cpu upgrades.
In addition, the G4560 HD610 graphics may let you defer on the discrete graphics until
you know better just how strong your graphics needs to be for YOUR games.

So far as I know, DDR4 ram starts at 2133 speed, no 1600 speed.
1600 was for ddr3.

Love the ssd; how big? who makes it?
Perhaps you should post the make/model of your proposed parts list.
 

cifroes

Distinguished
May 3, 2011
40
1
18,535
Userbench shows me this: http://cpu.userbenchmark.com/Compare/Intel-Pentium-G4560-vs-Intel-Core-i5-3470/3892vs2771 pending to i5, also because it has 4 real cores but I don't trust userbench very much, also because that's not gaming benchmarks.

The 'work'/processing heavy stuff that will be done on the PC are very simple Office tasks, so even a celeron from last century would be OK :) So it only matters the gaming performance of the CPU.

My mistake, DDR4 is 2400.

I just love Samsung SSDs so for either machine I would upgrade it with
+ 250 GB Samsung 850 evo (best price/quality around my country, 100€ around here)
+ MSI GTX 1050 Aero ITX 2g oc (130€ around here)

 

HagridPotterz

Prominent
Feb 26, 2017
54
0
660
The i5 3470 is better, it has four physical cores and the G4560 has 2 physical cores and two virtual cores. Virtual cores are much worse than regular ones, the yeah, the i5 wins.
 
Solution