Be Quiet B8 550W vs Corsair CX 550M

Solution
BeQuiet doesn't make PSUs. they don't have the resources to do so, like many other brands (EVGA, Corsair, XFX,..)
so they buy designs from PSU manufacturers, combine them with some things they're good at and change a bit and then sell them as their own.
BeQuiet rebrands units from 3 different manufacturers: Seasonic for their Dark Power series (although I think they switched for the last one), FSP for their latest Straight Power line and HEC for the lower series
different manufacturers have different skillsets.
Seasonic only does high grade stuff. they always use high grade japanese capacitors, integrate all safe guards, use redundancies and so on. the cheapest Seasonic unit you can find is still a very decent PSU.
FSP has a variety of...

Bersjan

Prominent
Jul 29, 2017
6
0
510


What about the Be Quiet Power Supply 10 500W?
 

Rexper

Respectable
BANNED
Apr 12, 2017
2,132
2
2,510


There are several different Be Quiet "10" series (Dark Power Pro, Pure Power, and Straight Power). There are four different models which math your quote, https://pcpartpicker.com/products/compare/KdmxFT,9PnG3C,4kKhP6,LxKhP6/

Which of these is the one you are looking at?

I'd probably rank them from best to worse:
Corsair CX550M > Be Quiet Straight Power > Be Quiet Pure Power

Based on these reviews,
http://www.jonnyguru.com/modules.php?name=NDReviews&op=Story4&reid=517
http://www.jonnyguru.com/modules.php?name=NDReviews&op=Story5&reid=399
http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/corsair-cx650m-psu,4770-9.html

All of which, are above mediocre level though.
 

salerhino

Reputable
Mar 16, 2016
1,263
0
5,660


Hey man could you explain this please "the B8 is a group regulated HEC design"?
Thanks.
 

Bersjan

Prominent
Jul 29, 2017
6
0
510


Sorry for the trouble, but could you express an opionion on Seasonic M12II-520 or EVO
 
BeQuiet doesn't make PSUs. they don't have the resources to do so, like many other brands (EVGA, Corsair, XFX,..)
so they buy designs from PSU manufacturers, combine them with some things they're good at and change a bit and then sell them as their own.
BeQuiet rebrands units from 3 different manufacturers: Seasonic for their Dark Power series (although I think they switched for the last one), FSP for their latest Straight Power line and HEC for the lower series
different manufacturers have different skillsets.
Seasonic only does high grade stuff. they always use high grade japanese capacitors, integrate all safe guards, use redundancies and so on. the cheapest Seasonic unit you can find is still a very decent PSU.
FSP has a variety of units, some are lowgrade, some mediocre, some are actually pretty good.
HEC usually only does cheap stuff. mostly not dangerously cheap, but cheap. cheap chinese caps, no redundancies, bare minimum for a reasonably save and stable PSU.

As for group regulation: the PSU gets supplied with 115V / 230V from your outlet and regulates this to 12V / 5V / 3.3V
group regulated means basically (and overly simplified) that all of these voltages are regulated by one part directly from the incoming current. this is how PSU have been made for many years.
by now this design is outdated. currently it's done by adding DC-DC converters, basically meaning that the incoming current is regulated to 12V, then there is essentially a second PSU in there, that regulates the 12V current to 5V and 3V. A PSU within the PSU if you want.
this has some advantages, espacially with crossloads. power delivery is cleaner, the unit can supply almost all of it's power at 12V other than the group regulated PSUs. downside: it's a bit more expensive bcs of the extra parts needed.

this is pretty simplified and I'm sure not 100% accurate but I think it's understandable...


Seasonic M12II / Evo were good PSUs, but they're getting old tbh.
they are Seasonic, so safe, good quality and last forever.
their performance was great when they were released by now they're a bit dated.
I'd rate them around the same as the new Straight Power 10 and the 2016 Corsair CXM. They use a bit better parts but perform not as good (in terms of voltage regulation, ripple, noise)
 
Solution


yeah it depends a lot on your location. I'm fully aware that some garbage I'd never consider even looking at is sometimes by far the best unit you can find in some countries.

I would avoid HEC units at all cost, as I consider them lowest quality. but I mean, I got Seasonic & Super Flower units available all around. So I discourage everyone from buying HEC made units unless they're the only units available that aren't from a brand who have their HQ in a station wagon with a running engine...