I7 7700k Delid or Not to Delid

boredboy94

Reputable
Oct 13, 2015
20
0
4,510
Hey everyone,

I recently purchased a 7700k (new from microcenter) and a fractal design celsius s36 aio liquid cooler and, with stock clocks, I'm getting 80°C on prime 95 tests. It's a 360mm radiator, so my idle temps of 30-40°C is warm (ambient room temp is warm, maybe 78-80°F, fyi) and I'm getting into the 80°C range under load. I even have Noctua NF-F12 fans on the radiator. I thought the cooler wasn't mounted 100% so I removed the included thermal paste on the cooler and replaced with arctic silver 5 and getting the same temps with new thermal paste and a second mounting of the cooler. Should I delid the CPU? Temps are high already without any overclocking. Case is a fractal define c. Delid or not to delid? And are up to 20°C lower temps with liquid metal after delidding true? Share thoughts and ask questions below. I appreciate your help! Thanks
 
Solution
Guys,


About Prime95:

Do not use Prime95 versions later than 26.6 on 2nd through 7th Generation i3, i5 or i7 CPU's, which all have AVX (Advanced Vector Extension) Instruction Sets. Prime95 versions later than 26.6 run AVX code on the CPU's Floating Point Unit (FPU) which causes unrealistic temperatures up to 20°C higher. The FPU test in the utility AIDA64 shows similar results.

AVX can be disabled in Prime95 versions later than 26.6 by inserting "CpuSupportsAVX=0" into the "local.txt" file in Prime95's folder. However, since Core temperatures will be the same as 26.6, it's easier to just use 26.6. AVX doesn't affect Core i 1st Generation, Core 2, Pentium or Celeron processors since they don't...

boredboy94

Reputable
Oct 13, 2015
20
0
4,510
@mdd1963

My bad on the down vote. Trying to type this on my phone and tapped the wrong button.

5ghz is the goal for me. So vcore would go up a bit to make sure it's a stable overclock.

Thanks!
 
Most will require a vcore bump to hit 5 GHz, but, all cpus are different...; you really won't no what , if any, core voltage bumps might be necessary until you test to 4.7 GHz, then 4.8 GHz, etc...

Many are stable at slightly lower freqs than the magical 5 GHz without the VCore bump. (Most people don't really need it anyway, save for perhaps a few trying to hit /maintain 144 Hz refresh rates on some monitors, and even then just with a few demanding gaming titles with a GTX1080Ti, etc...)
 
I am for a delid since to be honest I find the 7700k pretty crappy with the current temps with stock TIM that intel uses...
But not all 7700k`s are the same, some perform pretty well even at 5GHz with stock intel TIM. But some others ( mine included ) are really really bad.

Mine did hit 92C with Prime95 and about 82C - 86C while gaming... At stock speeds and Vcore... And this is on a full custom waterloop with a 480mm hardwarelabs black ice nemisis GTX with 8 fans the EK Vardar F4 120ER in push / pull and an ek supremacy evo waterblock.
My water temps stay around 22C - 24C then and even after delid, so there is no change in water temps cause of the overall setup.
But....
After the delid when running CPU at 5GHz with 1.312 Vcore I never ever go above 64C on the cores and while gaming I stay around 48C - 55C depending in what game I am running. Right now while sitting and typing this my ambient room temp is: 22C
My idle temps are:
Core 1 : 25 - 26
Core 2 : 23 - 24
Core 3 : 24 - 25
Core 4 : 24 - 25
Package : 25 - 26
Motherboard : 23
PCH : 35
Water Temp : 22

Fans running at rpm`s:
5 x 140mm case fans : 830ish rpm
8 x 120mm radiator fans : 550ish rpm
D5 pump : 1750ish rpm


So overall a pretty cool and very silent system.
So yea if you ask me if a delid is worth it? YOU BET!
It all depends on what kind of 7700k YOU got. Not what everyone else got. Some are very good some are very bad. I got a bad one and it looks like you have gotten one to.

If you are unsure about my temps you can click on my signature in bottom right corner here and it will take you to my CPU-Z validator page and you can see CPU temps there from a load in CPU-Z to validate my clockspeed, temps, settings, etc etc.

Sidenote: I use Thermal Grizzly Conductonaut between the CPU die and IHS. Thermal Grizzly Kryonaut between the IHS and waterblock.
 

CompuTronix

Intel Master
Moderator
Guys,


About Prime95:

Do not use Prime95 versions later than 26.6 on 2nd through 7th Generation i3, i5 or i7 CPU's, which all have AVX (Advanced Vector Extension) Instruction Sets. Prime95 versions later than 26.6 run AVX code on the CPU's Floating Point Unit (FPU) which causes unrealistic temperatures up to 20°C higher. The FPU test in the utility AIDA64 shows similar results.

AVX can be disabled in Prime95 versions later than 26.6 by inserting "CpuSupportsAVX=0" into the "local.txt" file in Prime95's folder. However, since Core temperatures will be the same as 26.6, it's easier to just use 26.6. AVX doesn't affect Core i 1st Generation, Core 2, Pentium or Celeron processors since they don't have AVX Instruction Sets.

• Prime95 v26.6 - http://www.mersenneforum.org/showthread.php?t=15504

Recent motherboards address the AVX problem by providing Core speed multiplier offset adjustments in BIOS. Asus RealBench runs a realistic AVX workload, and is an excellent utility for testing overall system stability, whether you're overclocked or not.

• Asus RealBench - http://rog.asus.com/rog-pro/realbench-v2-leaderboard/


About delidding:

In my opinion as an i7 overclocker, I believe that 2nd Generation Sandy Bridge was the last Intel mainstream processor that was thermally well behaved, consistent and comparatively predictable due to a soldered IHS. Disappointingly, Intel's 22nm and 14nm processors require delidding in order to provide overclockers with thermal behavior similar to 2nd Generation and earlier processors.

Keep in mind that when reviewing Thermal Specifications in the Datasheets, Intel uses engineering samples with a soldered IHS for testing and developing specifications. The Datasheets do not reflect the poor thermal performance of retail samples.

However, Silicon Lottery - https://siliconlottery.com/collections/all/products/delid - is a company that tests, bins and sells delidded "K" CPU's, so you can by a 7700K tested at 5.0 GHz without having to wonder about what you're getting. They also offer delidding services, and give the following figures on how much Core temperatures at 100% workload are improved by de-lidding:

7th Generation ... Kaby Lake - 12° to 25°C
6th Generation ... Skylake - 8°C to 18°C
5th Generation ... Broadwell - 8°C to 18°C
4th Generation ... Devil's Canyon - 7°C to 15°C
4th Generation ... Haswell - 10°C to 25°C
3rd Generation ... Ivy Bridge - 10°C to 25°C

boredboy94,

You can safely de-lid by using the Rockit 88 De-lidding Tool - https://rockitcool.myshopify.com/ or if you don't want to delid yourself, then just send your 7700K to Silicon Lottery. They do a professional job and have quick turnaround times.

Like lumineZ, my personal rig is a delidded 7700K. Before delidding, Core temperatures were ridiculously high into the upper 90's.

After delidding with Liquid Ultra under the IHS and MX-4 under the cooler:

5.0 GHz at 1.363 Vcore, 72°C Core temperatures with Prime95 v26.6 Small FFT's at 22°C ambient, Cooler Master TPC 812 Push-Pull high-end single tower air cooler. Idle temperatures 25° at 22°C ambient. Quiet fan curves provide gaming at ~ 55°C in a modded Antec 902 V3 with clean cable management.

As a result of delidding, a 7700K overclocked to 5.0 GHz can achieve good Core temperatures on air cooling.

CT :sol:
 
Solution

SumTingW0ng

Reputable
Aug 6, 2017
433
7
4,865


What about Aida64 latest version?
 

CompuTronix

Intel Master
Moderator
SumTingW0ng,

On behalf of Tom's Moderator Team, welcome aboard!

Intel tests their processors under carefully controlled conditions at 100% TDP. Prime95 version 26.6 Small FFT's is ideal for CPU thermal testing, because it's a steady 100% workload with steady Core temperatures that typically runs Core i variants with Hyperthreading and Core 2 processors within +/- a few % of TDP. No other utility so closely replicates Intel's proprietary test. This is also the utility that Real Temp uses to test Core temperature sensors.

Although AIDA64's CPU test is a steady workload, it's far below TDP, which is insufficient for thermal testing. All other AIDA64 CPU test combinations are fluctuating workloads which are OK for stability testing, but again aren't well suited for thermal testing. And of course, AIDA64 is not Freeware, so the Trial version expires.

You might want to read this Sticky: Intel Temperature Guide - http://www.tomshardware.com/forum/id-1800828/intel-temperature-guide.html

See the Charts in Section 12 - Thermal Test at 100% Workload.
A steady 100% workload is crucial for thermal testing.

Once again, welcome aboard!

CT :sol:
 

SumTingW0ng

Reputable
Aug 6, 2017
433
7
4,865


So is ASUS Realbench v2.54 latest consider to be a good free tool for overclock stability test? Consider ASUS Realbench push my CPU 6C higher than Prime 95 V26.6 .

Also, I can confirmed Aida 64 FPU, OCCT AVX, or the latest Prime 95 sky rocket my CPU up to 90C roof in less than 10 secs.

And thank you for welcoming me to the great community.
 

CompuTronix

Intel Master
Moderator

Yes, and your findings are all correct.

With respect to the OP, we're getting off topic, which is delidding. However, since most members don't distinguish between P95 v26.6 and later versions with AVX, I'm always obligated to clarify this critical point which causes so much confusion.

If you'd like to discuss stability testing, then please feel free to start your own Thread.

CT :sol: