Lots of questions with PC upgrade. Help!

baterax

Honorable
Aug 28, 2013
106
0
10,680
So here's the dealio!

My current PC is here: https://pcpartpicker.com/list/yC4ytJ

Now, I'm moving to Canada and I'm not taking my monitors with me (right now I use a freaking 20 year old TV for my PC and two just as old monitors for my mac pro)

This creates a great opportunity for me to take advantage of those AMD Vega combos, where I can get the card + monitor.

This is the first question:

I want an ultrawide for SURE. I'm not a competitive gamer so I don't need the 144Hz but as a content creator, I do need the IPS panel.
The monitor in that combo is NOT an IPS panel, but it's got its own unique Quantum Dot tech from Samsung. Is this a good buy for me?
The combo would save me $200 on getting both a much needed upgrade from my GTX 970 and a new monitor which I also desperately need.

But I won't be settled in Canada before at least a couple months (or maybe 5-6 if my visa takes a little more to be ready)

So should I wait a little more and get the card and monitor separately, so I can get say, an HIS card which will probably be better than the reference cards, and an IPS monitor like the Acer one?
Oh and I also wanna make sure it's got Freesync (that Samsung one does have it)

Next question:

My Intel 5820K. I'm currently editing video on my mac but I intend to move everything to one machine, and this will be the PC.

Is Premiere going to use vega well, or is it still better with the green team cards?
And, as I understand, the processor needs to be able to handle this so I should probably swap this CPU for something better.
I want to go back to the red team so that means also a new motherboard.
Do I go Ryzen 7 or is Threadripper worth the extra dough?
Because I just saw a video (link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rl_ioGy2dds) where Ryzen 7 was kicking ASS in 4K editing, as in 75% faster compared to Intel's 6700K in some tasks,
which costs twice as much (but would allow me to keep my current motherboard so there's that)
Changing to red team would also mean new memory, right, because Ryzen and Threadripper can take advantage of faster quad channel RAM so I should get some 3200, right
Lastly, if FE and RX differentiate vega between workstation and gaming cards, is it worth it for me, getting an FE card that has twice the RAM in it for twice as much? Or no?
 
Solution
Hi,

I would recommend asking each of these questions separately in different threads, because this is not a long question, these are many questions that could attract many opinions and different answers.

Anyways. A few opinions from my side: Read up on the specific content creation tools that you use. Ryzen is great for multi threaded apps and content creation but you already have a 5820K which is still a potent content creation CPU. Perhaps best would be to keep that CPU and concentrate on other aspects for now, such as getting more RAM or more SSD or better video card. Threadripper is 999$, but if you can afford it, it will have very visible results in render speed if you do content creation that can actually make use of all those...

gaborbarla

Distinguished
Hi,

I would recommend asking each of these questions separately in different threads, because this is not a long question, these are many questions that could attract many opinions and different answers.

Anyways. A few opinions from my side: Read up on the specific content creation tools that you use. Ryzen is great for multi threaded apps and content creation but you already have a 5820K which is still a potent content creation CPU. Perhaps best would be to keep that CPU and concentrate on other aspects for now, such as getting more RAM or more SSD or better video card. Threadripper is 999$, but if you can afford it, it will have very visible results in render speed if you do content creation that can actually make use of all those cores. I personally doubt it would be MUCH better than a 6 or an 8 core during editing in Premiere but surely it would do better during rendering.

I have not seen any reviews where quad channel RAM actually made a real life difference. I have seen 3200Mhz RAM make a difference over 2400Mhz RAM but mostly in Min FPS in games being higher. You can probably spend your money better concentrating on the CPU and GPU for content creation than quad channel RAM. Also, lots of RAM will be the way for you. 16Gb Minimum but 32GB I would think will not be a waste.

You have not mentioned an SSD. I assume that you already use a large SSD for editing. If not, well then I would recommend doing that.
I would recommend SSD for all current work and only using HDD for backups.

As for what graphics card you should get, it is worth taking a look at this https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g7cQK8jFPzo
A little bit old, but still applies.

I had an IPS 1440k 27" monitor which was much blurrier than my new TN panel of the same spec. The TN panel cost double though, due to it being a 144Hz screen. Something to keep in mind. Do you reeeealy need that extra few percent of gamut accuracy vs more motion blur in your life? Up to you.

G
 
Solution

baterax

Honorable
Aug 28, 2013
106
0
10,680
Yeah I've been considering. What I'll do at first is get the Vega 64+Samsung monitor combo, following your advice on not getting an IPS panel. This saves me $200 and I need a new monitor and card for sure. Way more than I need the other stuff.
Right now I already have 4 sticks of RAM so I'll hold off on buying more.
Yes my PC currently sits on 4 SSDs and one HDD for storage. I won't be changing this either (might get an external for 4K stuff since the space demands will go up).