Ap vs main router

Aug 7, 2014
29
0
4,540
Hi need some technical help here.

I bought the ubiquity amplify hd (mesh) a while ago, but have not been getting satisfactory speeds.
my subscribed speeds is 1Gb up and 1 Gb down. On wired I do get in excess of 900mbps so I definitely have close to what i pay for on wire.

now because my modem that links to the outside internet is in a very bad position in an enclosed room, I have used my amplify as an AP (bridged mode) instead. The main unit is now in a more central position.

amplify main unit - hardwired via switch - modem. 125~mbps

amplify main unit -- wireless -- to satellite/beacon 1 whatever you call them.
amplify main unit -- wireless -- to satellite/beacon 2 whatever you call them.

in this setup, i get only 120-125mbps. I mean this is what i get too on non mesh single asus routers...
asus ac3200 - wired via switch - modem - 185mbps

I am on cat7 cables too.

My question now is, to enjoy high speeds of say 300 and up, does my amplify need to be the modem that connects to the outside internet? I am on the verge of changing to the eeros gen2 because i am not satisfied with this result but dont want to end in the same state if this is technically not possible... or somewhere in my setup there is a problem? like i am not getting fantastic speeds too on the asus ac3200.

some advise will help thanks guys.

 
Solution
Not sure what you are asking. You will never get really fast speeds on any wireless. The more complex you make it..ie mesh..the more overhead you get. Almost all the solutions you see are to increase the coverage in exchange for slower speeds.

Now lets say you have 2 identical routers. If you were to compare using just one device to provide all function to using the main router with the WiFi disabled and the second connected as a AP via ethernet you should get almost the same wireless speeds. This assume you put the 2 units in exactly the same locations.

Wireless is affected by massive number of things in your house so it is very hard to suggest which solution will work the best. Unfortunately it is a lot of trial and error
Not sure what you are asking. You will never get really fast speeds on any wireless. The more complex you make it..ie mesh..the more overhead you get. Almost all the solutions you see are to increase the coverage in exchange for slower speeds.

Now lets say you have 2 identical routers. If you were to compare using just one device to provide all function to using the main router with the WiFi disabled and the second connected as a AP via ethernet you should get almost the same wireless speeds. This assume you put the 2 units in exactly the same locations.

Wireless is affected by massive number of things in your house so it is very hard to suggest which solution will work the best. Unfortunately it is a lot of trial and error
 
Solution