Need a little help between Gigabyte GTX 1080 Windforce and Asus 1070 ROG Strix

Meety Peety

Distinguished
Dec 2, 2011
50
0
18,630
Hello all, I am still pretty unfamiliar with the things that make a solid GPU tick. I am building a new machine and I was originally planning to pick up a 1060 but figured I would save a bit more and treat myself to a 1070. Today I saw the Gigabyte GeForce GTX 1080 on sale bundled with Destiny 2 (a game I was already planning to buy so that is a plus) for right around the same price as most of the 1070s I am seeing. Specifically, the 1070 I had my eye on was the ASUS ROG Strix (links to both below).

While trying to decide between the two, I am having a hard time determining which specs are most important. It looks like the two cards are clocked very similarly but with the 1080 card having a bit more cuda cores.

Being roughly the same price, I am inclined to lean towards the 1080 for obvious reasons, however the reviews mentioning intense noise on this card are making me second guess whether I want to go with this card and looking at the specs, they appear very similar (perhaps high end 1070 vs low end 1080?)

I am having a really hard time finding benchmarks that include the Gigabyte 1080 which also seems odd to me.

Can anyone shed some light? Im sure this is probably a stupid question so I apologize in advance. I am open to other suggestions as well, however I want to stay away from Quadro cards. My budget is already being stretched at about $500. I could maybe go up a tiny bit but not by much. Being that I already plan to get Destiny 2, the bundle actually makes this card significantly cheaper than the 1070, which makes me start to wonder if it is really a 1080 on par with the other 1080s out there or if this is more like a 1070 with a fancier name.

For reference, the machine is not yet complete but will be an i7-7700k on an MSI pro carbon, liquid cooled, 32gb of gskill 3000 ddr4 and a 500gb ssd. Time on this machine will be split about 50/50 between AutoCAD/Revit/Navisworks 3D modelling (And messing around with photoshop on occasion) and the other half for casual-ish gaming. While my gaming will be fairly casual, I would like to build a system that will last a good few years.

Thanks

https://m.newegg.com/products/N82E16814125880

https://m.newegg.com/products/N82E16814126109
 
Solution
The link doesnt work for me, but yes. Factory overclocks are usually on the very mild side, easily achievable on any card with the same GPU.

I prefer the Asus Strix cards, but getting any 1080 will be better than even the best 1070.
Get the 1080.
Newegg and other major retailers are filled with bad reviews on PC components for a few reasons.
Generally, people are more likely to leave a bad review if something happened to go wrong, so most people who get working cards stay quiet.
Additionally, a lot of negative reviews stem from user error anyway.

There is no reason to buy a 1070 at a 1080 pricepoint.
 

Meety Peety

Distinguished
Dec 2, 2011
50
0
18,630
Thanks for the reply. Id like to learn more about all of the different specs and how they compare against each other when slecting a card (Not just between different series of card but between different brands of similar 1080 cards). Does anyone have a link to a good article or sticky explaning what to look for when comparing similar cards and how to determine if a small change in the numbers will really affect anything?

Also, anyone have a benchmark of how the windforce 1080 compares to other similarly priced cards? Not sure why im having trouble finding info on this card, usually there is a ton of info out there. Maybe Im just not searching the right terms..
 

RobCrezz

Expert
Ambassador
Put simply, all GTX 1070 will have the same GPU from nvidia, just as all gtx 1080 will have the same gpu from nvidia. Nvidia set the specs.

The only differences within the lines will be the differences in the card, better coolers, power delivery, and factory overclocks (manufacturers can overclock the gpus from the factory).

I would not pay attention to any of the factory overclocks, as these can be achieved on any card with the same gpu.
 

Meety Peety

Distinguished
Dec 2, 2011
50
0
18,630
Thanks Rob that makes a lot of sense. So would I be correct then in assuming that I should be able to take the Gigabyte 1080 linked above and overclock it to match the speeds of similar cards myself (provided that the hardware and heat dissipation allows me to)?

I am not planning to overclock for a while, just want to make sure I understand my options for now. I have a lot still to learn before I will attempt an overclock on my own.

Thanks again for clarifying.
 

RobCrezz

Expert
Ambassador
The link doesnt work for me, but yes. Factory overclocks are usually on the very mild side, easily achievable on any card with the same GPU.

I prefer the Asus Strix cards, but getting any 1080 will be better than even the best 1070.
 
Solution