Ryzen or Coffee lake?

Xavier1 2584

Honorable
Mar 11, 2017
12
0
10,510
I am looking to upgrade to a ryzen 5 1600. I just want to know if I should still buy the r5 1600 after Intel Coffee lake's launch. I have a gtx 1050ti as a gpu. Tx!!
 
Solution

Both are solid choices, but I would highly recommend the i5 8400. Ho,d out till early 2018 and get a cheap mobo that supports it, and you won't regret it. Single and Multi core of a 7700k, gaming performance quite a lot better than ryzen. The upgrade path goes up to a 6c 12t 8700k, which does as good/better than ryzen in Multi and single core test respectively.

Mohan_27

Reputable
Jun 2, 2017
437
2
4,965


With intel being way too expensive, it is said that the AMD sockets will not change until 2022 meaning the Ryzen processors will be around for a long time therefore I would invest in a Ryzen. I have the processor 1600 and have no issues whatsoever.
 


That's not true in many situations. I've proven that myself and saw up to 20% improvements with an overclocked i7-7700K for some games and benchmarks.

However, an R5-1600 is almost certainly the best choice unless he has a much higher budget and would for example build an i7-8700K setup, then very SHORTLY after (next year) buy a much more expensive video card.

PCPARTPICKER is great for comparing parts. Here's some tips on that for RYZEN:
1) get 3000MHz or 3200MHz DDR4 memory
2) use Dual Channel
3) if you can afford only 8GB, get 2x4GB and also ensure the motherboard has FOUR SLOTS for DDR4 memory (to add another identical kit later)

4) don't skimp too much on the motherboard. make sure it's got fairly good customer feedback.
5) Use the stock cooler, and overclock as much as you can while keeping the temperature for demanding loads (not Prime95 as that's too stressful, but something like Handbrake during 100% thread utilization) to about 75degC max.

OTHER:
I though about recommending to wait for cheaper Coffee Lake boards and reevaluate CPU costs, however since AM4 most likely supports the ZEN2 CPU's you have an upgrade path with AMD.

***You may have no need for better than an R5-1600, however an 8-core ZEN2 is likely to be available should you need it. Since AM4 is hanging around that should also make it easier to sell the R5-1600, or buy a motherboard if yours fails after Warranty.

I'd estimate the 8-core ZEN2 to be capable of at least 20% more performance per core (partially due to clock upgrades).

Additionally, Ryzen CPU's aren't fully utilized yet due to using an inefficient compiler to make programs. Once games and applications are compiled with a better compiler we'll see benefits like we did with AotS and Tomb Raider earlier this year.

I'm doubting many people would upgrade from an R5-1600 (as a percentage of buyers) but at least it's an option.
 
My answer above assumes a relatively weak CPU already. Any pre-Ryzen AMD CPU would suffice.

If you have a modern i5/i7 Intel CPU I wouldn't jump to upgrade. The R5-1600 is comparable (per core) to an i7-3770K running 4.4GHz but it has 50% more cores which can help in some games.

Any newer i5/i7 Intel with at least 3.6GHz with all cores under load would be something I'd keep and not upgrade from for a while in general, though it's hard to get SPECIFIC without knowing exactly how you use your computer.
 

AziWazzi

Commendable
Dec 23, 2016
80
0
1,660

Both are solid choices, but I would highly recommend the i5 8400. Ho,d out till early 2018 and get a cheap mobo that supports it, and you won't regret it. Single and Multi core of a 7700k, gaming performance quite a lot better than ryzen. The upgrade path goes up to a 6c 12t 8700k, which does as good/better than ryzen in Multi and single core test respectively.
 
Solution

AAGG02

Reputable
Mar 22, 2017
81
0
4,630
I've got Ryzen 5 1600 and i sold it to get i7 8700 and it was the best decision. I don't want to compare those two CPUs but i will always go with Intel after my AMD experience.