7350K, or 7500/7600K/7700K?

SilverJS

Distinguished
Dec 13, 2010
44
0
18,530
Here's the story :

Have a GA-Z270MX Gaming 5 mobo on a screaming deal. Want to upgrade my living room HTPC, currently on an i3-3240 with 120GB SSD and 4GB's of RAM. I am using a Scythe Big Shuriken 2, for silent operations, with 3 x Be Quiet 120mm fans (sides) and 2 x Be Quiet 80mm fans at the back. Speed and silence are the most important things for me, but I only do web browsing, office work, music streaming, basic image editing, etc, on the computer. Oh, of course - and I watch movies and TV series on it. =)

So, peak of my budget is about 350 CAD (aprx. 280 USD). Canada Computers has one remaining i3-7350K, for 180 CAD (apprx. 145 USD). I have also found a used i7-7700K for 350 CAD (apprx. 280 USD - that's about the peak of my budget), and could also get a new i5-7600K, for about 280 CAD. Also have available an open box 7500 for about 200 CAD. Which of the four would you guys recommend for my use case? I'm leaning towards the 7350K, for these reasons (but open to being told I'm potentially wrong) :

1. Price. I know the 7350K was overpriced on launch, but this is a very good sale price, and I already have an aftermarket cooler and the Z270 board (not that I NEED to overclock);

2. Single-threaded speed. I think that's the most important performance factor for my use case. I could go for a light overclock (say, 4.6-4.7 GHz) and not create that much more heat, thereby still keeping my silent operation. I don't think that would be possible on a quad-core solution.

Thoughts?

Thanks!
 
Solution
If you must upgrade, I'd suggest a quad core. There's hardly any point to go from dual to dual even if single threaded is all you need now, your future may not be. The heat difference will be minimal and you could still run a silent setup.
Here is how it works out in your case. The i3 can handle any of the tasks you have listed above, pretty well but if you do any combination of those tasks simultaneously, then the i3s' 2 cores might fall short. Now depending on that you should make a decision between i3 and i5.
i7 would be a overkill for the above tasks, so you can discard that idea.

 

SilverJS

Distinguished
Dec 13, 2010
44
0
18,530
Sorry, should've mentioned - I do tend to keep PC's for 5-6 years, so yes, future-proofing is indeed important. Also edited the first post to reflect another option I have - a 7500 for about 200 CAD. (Guy wants a bit more but indicated he's flexible.)

The 7600K was actually my first choice for a long time. I only recently started revisiting that choice....
 
If you must upgrade, I'd suggest a quad core. There's hardly any point to go from dual to dual even if single threaded is all you need now, your future may not be. The heat difference will be minimal and you could still run a silent setup.
 
Solution

SilverJS

Distinguished
Dec 13, 2010
44
0
18,530
OK. I probably also should have said that yes, I kind of feel I want to upgrade this rig. Not because I'm unhappy with the performance per se, but more because I have received various indications that lead me to not trust this system as much as I used to.
 

nachthavik

Distinguished
Feb 18, 2010
45
0
18,540
if you can wait for a month then you can get the 8100 with a B360 chipset and ddr4 ram i think its the best you can get for your purpose but the B360 chipset isnt available yet thats why i did nt sugest

 

SilverJS

Distinguished
Dec 13, 2010
44
0
18,530
Just for everyone's info - I did indeed buy that 7500, for 190 CAD, so pretty happy about that. Will be building it today and/or tomorrow.

Still really wish I could have seen what that 7350K could do though...=)