Trouble diagnosing whether my Motherboard or PSU is dead

jackclements95

Prominent
Nov 11, 2017
2
0
510
Some background - my trusty 2.5 year old build suddenly wouldn't turn on a few days ago. Knowing that it was likely a component fault, I had a fiddle with the PSU cables and despite the onboard LED being lit, figured that a lack of any other power indicators meant the PSU was faulty.

After ordering a brand new PSU today, and hooking the whole thing up, the CPU and PSU fans spun for about a quarter-second before becoming stopping completely and requiring me to turn the PSU off/on again before I could boot it.

I've tried breadboarding the build with the components out of the case, using only the RAM (alternated with single sticks), CPU and PSU, but the problem remains the same. At this point I'm genuinely lost as to what the problem is, other than I believe it may be the motherboard as a brand new PSU shouldn't have a similar problem to the old one.

Just to rule out any rookie mistakes, yes I had both the 24-pin ATX and 4-pin CPU plugged in flush.

Specs
- Intel i7 Devil's Canyon
- Corsair Vengeance Pro Series 16GB (2x 8GB)
- Seasonic Focus Plus 650 W Gold 80 Plus Full Modular Power Supply Unit
- ASUS H81M-Plus motherboard
 
Solution
A paperclip test only means the PSU will power on and is in no way a test of it working or not.
You might need to hook a molex fan to the PSU during the test it does have Hybrid Silent fan Control and the fan might not even kick on without a load.
Does sound like the motherboard.
Do the paperclip test on PSU. If it passes, then most likely you have working unit (I would be surprised to see Seasonic DoA, but everything can happen), which would mean next most likely source of problem is motherboard. As a last step, remove all components from motherboard (CPU too), leave only fans and 24-pin cable. If at such setup you still can't get fans to run normally, I'd say you have dead motherboard.
 

jackclements95

Prominent
Nov 11, 2017
2
0
510


Yeah, that seems like the most likely solution. Will paperclip the PSU soon but I have a lot of trouble believing a new Seasonic would arrive broken. Given Asus' RMA turnaround time, I suspect a broken board is pretty much the worst thing that could happen short of breaking the CPU/GPU. Thanks.
 

Zerk2012

Titan
Ambassador
A paperclip test only means the PSU will power on and is in no way a test of it working or not.
You might need to hook a molex fan to the PSU during the test it does have Hybrid Silent fan Control and the fan might not even kick on without a load.
Does sound like the motherboard.
 
Solution