Which case fan is better?

Solution

Zerk2012

Titan
Ambassador

Noctua = overrated and over priced.
Those PureWings are good fans.
 

JoeMomma

Distinguished
Nov 17, 2010
860
1
19,360

be quiet! SilentWings came with my case.
It is freaky magic how quiet they are!
 


I had access to 4-5 and the Noctua and Fractal design were the least annoying. The Fractal might be quieter, but the sound from the Noctua was at a frequency which unlike most of the fans I tested could not be heard outside the case. The fans on the NH-d15s is slightly more annoying but quieter than the ones on the older nh-d15. When I added case fans I added two more Noctuas. The extra 5-10 bucks I paid for them is chump change for a silent PC which stays silent.
 
Sound is a personal experience. One sound you love an another one might hate.

I would not arguee that the Noctua fans are bad, just the opposite.
But from what I have seen less people are complaining about the sound the SW makes compared to the Noctua.