EVGA is a solid brand with good warranty coverage in the US. I don't think you will go wrong buying another brand though. It really will come down to looks, cooling solution, and price as each brand will have a different way of segmenting their product stack, and differentiating themselves from their competition. For example even though I like the look of EVGA cards, they do seem to charge a slight premium compared to other brands and did make a difference in a recent gift purchase.
You can take a look at other forum posts if you're worried about warranty, but I can guarantee you that you will find plenty of people who have good and bad experiences. If your card goes bad, well it is just the luck of the draw. I still encourage you to do your own research as the most important thing is that you feel good about your purchase.