Router / Modem Recommendations

mmitsch

Distinguished
Sep 12, 2010
130
2
18,685
We had a house fire and are getting our place rebuilt. I have cat 5 cable being ran need some advice on setting up the wireless network. We have a 2 Story home and use Comcast as our Internet provider. The cable modem on router are going in a closet downstairs.

I have had pretty good luck with Netgear and was able to get an R8000 router at a good price. I was also considering their Orbi line but it was more expensive. I was wondering, if I have the R8000, if I can put another wired ethernet wireless device upstairs (running ehternet to the R8000) to ensue connectivity? Or would I be better to sell the R8000 and get the Orbi Router and Satellite RBK50? I understand they can be wired.

For a cable modem, I initially thought I would get a Motorola MB8600. The folks at Netgear are recommending their CM1000.

Let me know your ideas for the best setup. I notice Netgear says their devices are Amazon Echo enabled as well. Guess I am wondering how Echo could work with these things?

Any advice would be GREATLY appreciated!
 
Solution
If you're putting the modem and router in the wiring closet, and you have distances of 20+ feet to reach certain rooms in the house, you might consider WoCA (wifi over coax). Then you'd only need to worry about the one wifi router, rather than needing to troubleshoot/maintain/upgrade multiple Orbi APs in multiple rooms. (Orbi doesn't support Fast Roaming AFAIK.)

I'm in the process of replacing a Netgear R7000 (3 antennas, 363 Mbps max tested throughput on 5 GHz, 1 GHz CPU with 256 RAM) with an Asus RT-AC88U (4 antennas, 583 Mbps max tested throughput on 5 GHz, MU-MIMO support, 1.4 GHz CPU with 512 MB RAM) and will use WoCA to reach the far ends of a 5,000+ sq. ft. house. Since I'm the second owner, I don't know if the Cat5e in the...

kanewolf

Titan
Moderator
I would recommend that you consider putting "smoke detector" style WIFI access points on each floor. The UniFI line from Ubiquiti is a good choice. Put your router in a convenient place for wired networking and add WIFI access points throughput the house for WIFI.
 
You might as well run cat6 cable instead of cat5.

Having a router + an access point (wire ethernet wireless device) is a great way to ensure the signal is able to reach every room.

You would need to test the signal with all walls and other wiring in place to see if a problem even exists.

For a cable modem, it does not matter which brand you buy as long as they have enough downstream and upstream channels to support the speeds that you purchased from your ISP.

https://www.bestbuy.com/site/arris-surfboard-docsis-3-0-cable-modem-white/4600801.p?skuId=4600801

Should be a fast enough modem for 99% of all cases.
32 downstream and 8 upstream channels
1.4 gigabit down / 240 megabit up
 

vmfantom

Notable
Nov 28, 2017
181
0
860
If you're putting the modem and router in the wiring closet, and you have distances of 20+ feet to reach certain rooms in the house, you might consider WoCA (wifi over coax). Then you'd only need to worry about the one wifi router, rather than needing to troubleshoot/maintain/upgrade multiple Orbi APs in multiple rooms. (Orbi doesn't support Fast Roaming AFAIK.)

I'm in the process of replacing a Netgear R7000 (3 antennas, 363 Mbps max tested throughput on 5 GHz, 1 GHz CPU with 256 RAM) with an Asus RT-AC88U (4 antennas, 583 Mbps max tested throughput on 5 GHz, MU-MIMO support, 1.4 GHz CPU with 512 MB RAM) and will use WoCA to reach the far ends of a 5,000+ sq. ft. house. Since I'm the second owner, I don't know if the Cat5e in the walls is copper clad aluminum or pure copper, but would rather not risk the fire hazard of sending PoE voltage through those runs in case the Cat5e jackets are broken in the crawl space somewhere. At least RG-6 is thicker.

For modems, your ISP probably has a list of compatible modems. Just check which DOCSIS 3.x bonding profile is necessary for the bandwidth you plan to subscribe to.
 
Solution