Should I Buy a Thunderbolt 3 or USB 3.0 7200rpm HDD RAID 1 Setup for Archiving Photo/Video?

hiphopanonymous4

Prominent
Dec 13, 2017
1
0
510
I have a 2017 iMac (27-inch, 1TB SSD, 4.2GHz Intel Core i7, 40GB Memory, Radeon Pro 580 8 GB) that has two Thunderbolt 3 ports and four USB 3.0 ports. I want to purchase a RAID 1 setup to archive photo/video files. Is there any reason (other than daisy-chaining) as to why I would purchase a more costly Thunderbolt 3 RAID 1 setup instead of a USB 3.0 RAID 1 setup?

I've tried to research this within the forums and on other sites and I haven't found a satisfactory answer to my question. I understand that rotational discs are the bottleneck for read/write speeds rather than the peripheral connections, but manufacturers are selling/marketing HDD Thunderbolt 3 drives. Why would anyone buy those (other than for daisy-chaining)? Are there any performace advantages that a Thunderbolt 3 HDD would have over USB 3.0?

I've been eyeing 12TB 7200rpm RAID setups by LaCie, G-Technology and OWC. Any guidance would be greatly appreciated so I don't unnecessarily spend an extra $200+ for Thunderbolt 3.
 
Solution
You are correct that your drives will not saturate either connection so the choice doesn't matter for speed.

I would go with USB 3 for two reasons, it is cheaper and second it will allow you to connect to many other computers as the Thunderbolt connector is rarely found outside some expensive Apple computers and very high end PC motherboards.

If you go to a much larger array 10GbE is an option that can be added between three devices for around $300 with the right choices, but that's really for very large arrays with frequent large transfers.

RealBeast

Titan
Moderator
You are correct that your drives will not saturate either connection so the choice doesn't matter for speed.

I would go with USB 3 for two reasons, it is cheaper and second it will allow you to connect to many other computers as the Thunderbolt connector is rarely found outside some expensive Apple computers and very high end PC motherboards.

If you go to a much larger array 10GbE is an option that can be added between three devices for around $300 with the right choices, but that's really for very large arrays with frequent large transfers.
 
Solution