AMD FX-8350 Watercooling

brutalsam90

Reputable
Dec 28, 2014
29
0
4,530
Hi, i was thinking on buying watercooler for my cpu. Double 120mm ones i guess.
I am going to do an intense overclocking, so what kind of watercooler is worth buying these days ?
I am leaning around FRACTAL DESIGN CELSIUS S24 and Deepcool GamerStorm Captain 240. And new AeroCool P7-L240. What do you guys suggest best to buy for my cpu ?
 
Solution
Actually, much depends on whether or not your case even supports water cooling or not, and if it does, what sizes it supports and where.

What is your case model?

If you have a case that does support 240mm coolers, then my suggestion would be that the ID Cooling Frostflow units were rated by our cooling system tester Crashman as one of the best ever tested by him and are much cheaper than most of the better known brands.

http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/id-cooling-frostflow-240l-closed-loop-liquid-cpu-cooler,4371-2.html

Our test results speak for themselves. ID-Cooling's Frostflow 240L offers the best full-speed temperature ever achieved on this test system, the best low-speed acoustic efficiency of any closed-loop cooler...
Actually, much depends on whether or not your case even supports water cooling or not, and if it does, what sizes it supports and where.

What is your case model?

If you have a case that does support 240mm coolers, then my suggestion would be that the ID Cooling Frostflow units were rated by our cooling system tester Crashman as one of the best ever tested by him and are much cheaper than most of the better known brands.

http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/id-cooling-frostflow-240l-closed-loop-liquid-cpu-cooler,4371-2.html

Our test results speak for themselves. ID-Cooling's Frostflow 240L offers the best full-speed temperature ever achieved on this test system, the best low-speed acoustic efficiency of any closed-loop cooler tested on this system, and the lowest price of any 2x 120mm cooler ever tested on our system. However, while some users prefer integrated fan and pump control, the Frostflow 240L uses motherboard-based controls.


https://www.ebay.com/itm/ID-COOLING-240L-AIO-Water-Cooler-Unique-Comet-tail-LED-Lighting-240mm-Radiator/401243304845?epid=2255308921&hash=item5d6bf6f38d:g:bikAAOSwSlBY0HsR


Aside from that, the Corsair H115i extreme cooling and EVGA CLC units rate at the top of nearly every AIO closed loop cooler roundup in recent memory.
 
Solution

brutalsam90

Reputable
Dec 28, 2014
29
0
4,530


My case is Aero-1000 Black Edition, which supports 240 WC
 
I'd stay away from the Deepcool AIO coolers personally. I'd also avoid the EK-XLC Predator 240 as it has a variety of quality issues and potential leak points that I've seen problems with on several users systems. Anandtech echoed this sentiment as they too had similar concerns and saw many of the same issues.

I'd stick to Corsair, EVGA, ID Cooling, NZXT and Alphacool for AIO closed loop cooling.
 

brutalsam90

Reputable
Dec 28, 2014
29
0
4,530


I see, but what about ID COOLING Frostflow+ 240? Is it better, newer of ID-COOLING Frostflow ?

And btw, my case supports both 240, 280 coolers, should i get 280 instead 240 ?
 
If you are doing the overclock for fun then that's all good. If you are doing the overclock because you actually need extra performance then Id say spending money on a high end cooling solution is a waste and it would be better put into a new cpu platform that will give far greater gains than any overclock will.
 

brutalsam90

Reputable
Dec 28, 2014
29
0
4,530


No, getting extra performance isn't the main goal. For fun maybe.
And to get a new cpu i guess i need to get a lot of new things, new mobo, new RAM.
And i am getting overheat buzzing sounds in summer, and also i think my cpu is bottlenecking my GPU a bit.
 
There is only one review of the Frostflow+ 240l that I can find, and it's somewhat questionable. I've never seen any reviews from that site before and there isn't much "meat" to the review, but since the original version was pretty good I'd guess that the revision should HOPEFULLY be even better. Companies don't usually revise their products unless there is something they can make better about it OR if they can reduce cost with a few changes.

Since these coolers are so inexpensive to start with, that wouldn't surprise me, but overall ID cooling has some pretty decent products for the budget prices they sell for, so I would not be against using one of their coolers if I was inclined to use a water cooled setup.

https://www.goldfries.com/hardware-reviews/id-cooling-frostflow-240-review/
 

brutalsam90

Reputable
Dec 28, 2014
29
0
4,530


What about 240 and 280 difference ? Frostflow+ has 280, i am willing go for that if 280 is worthy and better than that
 
280 is definately better than 240, for several reasons. One, the radiators are larger, with more surface area, since they are wider and longer, and being wider and longer than offer more fins, and more fin surface area which potentially means more ability to dissipate heat. Two, they use 240mm fans which can generally move more air through the radiator therefore facilitating better heat transfer away from the radiator. Also, while it is a fact that 120mm fans tend to have a higher static pressure, in general, it's also true that 140mm fans are available in much higher static pressure ratings if you are interested at some point in buying them.

Truthfully, almost all closed loop coolers sold today come with fans that are lacking in one way or another and that none of them come with the very high quality fans that are out there because manufacturers want to offer their coolers at the best possible prices in order to be competitive in a very competitive market. That means that the really excellent fans, with high air movement, high static pressure AND low sound pressure/decibel levels are almost never going to come with an AIO closed loop cooler. Still, most of them come with decent, if not great fans. Further, most of these fans don't come with bearing designs that offer really good longevity, for that, you almost certainly want to buy a premium fan but unless you find the fans that come with your cooler to be annoying you will probably want to wait until the fans start showing signs of performance loss or bearing noise.

Usually the 280mm coolers outperform the smaller models by a fairly decent margin. In an area where 2-3 degrees is a selling point, a 5-7°C difference is worth paying a little more for IMO.
 

brutalsam90

Reputable
Dec 28, 2014
29
0
4,530
Thanks guys, especially @darkbreeze.
I am going for Frostflow+ 280, just searched it in chinese stores, found it for about 60 usd, my bro is coming from china he will grab that for me.
 
I think you will be happy with it. The only complaints I've seen on any of the Frostflow AIO coolers is that there is potential for issues with the mounting system on the waterblock/coldplate assembly, but our cooler system tester Crashman didn't note having any problems with them in his review so it may have just been the individual reviewer. I'd just recommend paying close attention that you get a good, fairly high pressure mount when you install it. Might want to do some research on the installation of that unit and watch a few video tutorials of it so you can familiarize yourself with the process before the actual installation.

Other than that, good luck to you and happy computing. Oh, and merry Christmas too. If you celebrate.
 

brutalsam90

Reputable
Dec 28, 2014
29
0
4,530


Hi darkbreeze.

So i bought Frostflow+ 280 as you suggested, fans are bit loud, but i guess that doesn't concern me a lot.
What worries me, is that the temps are fluctuating around 27-40 C. Is this normal ? Im on stock clocks and have recently reset bios settings to default optimized settings.

 
So, restart the system, do not open any programs except for whatever program you are using to monitor temps. I recommend using HWinfo or CoreTemp. I do NOT recommend using bundled motherboard utilities, HWmonitor, Open Hardware monitor or Speedfan.

Let the system stabilize for about five minutes after you open the monitoring application. Note the CPU core and package temps at full idle.

Next, run Prime95 version 26.6. Choose the Small FFT option. After five minutes note the max CPU core and package temps. If at any point while running Prime95 you see an individual core or package temp go above 70 degrees Celcius immediately open the File options in Prime 95 and choose Stop all workers and then exit program.

My first guess is that the mount is not good. I have read about a few indications that mounting pressure is a little more difficult to achieve on these coolers due to the mounting design, and it seems as though you probably either didn't get the right mounting pressure OR something is interfereing with the water block/cold plate assembly fully seating on top of the CPU lid. Make sure the bottom of the cold/water block plate is not touching anything except for the CPU lid. No capacitors or anything else stopping it from going down all the way.

Also, it is fairly common for users new to AIO cooling or even aftermarket air cooling to not get the standoff/backplate assembly as tight as it should be, which will compound the problem of not getting the cold plate fully seated against the CPU lid even if it is completely tightened against the standoffs. If the backplate is slightly loose, the water block plate cannot fully tighten against the cpu. You might want to double check that you've also used the CORRECT standoffs. Usually coolers come with multiple sets for Intel or AMD, and sometimes more than one set for each of those depending on the socket used.

Some users have found that installing small plastic washers between the backplate and motherboard allows the standoff to backplate fasteners to fully tighten up a little better, which can help the tightness of the water block to CPU lid mounting pressure by making sure no fasteners are bottoming out before they are tight. This can happen sometimes because not all motherboards are the same thickness and thinner motherboards might case the stand off to backing plate fasteners to bottom out before becoming fully tightened.


In order to help you, it's often necessary to SEE what's going on, in the event one of us can pick something out that seems out of place, or other indicators that just can't be communicated via a text only post. In these cases, posting an image of the HWinfo sensors or something else can be extremely helpful. Here's how:

*How to post images in Tom's hardware forums



Run HWinfo and look at system voltages and other sensor readings.

Monitoring temperatures, core speeds, voltages, clock ratios and other reported sensor data can often help to pick out an issue right off the bat. HWinfo is a good way to get that data and in my experience tends to be more accurate than some of the other utilities available. CPU-Z, GPU-Z and Core Temp all have their uses but HWinfo tends to have it all laid out in a more convenient fashion so you can usually see what one sensor is reporting while looking at another instead of having to flip through various tabs that have specific groupings.

After installation, run the utility and when asked, choose "sensors only". The other window options have some use but in most cases everything you need will be located in the sensors window. If you're taking screenshots to post for troubleshooting, it will most likely require taking three screenshots and scrolling down the sensors window between screenshots in order to capture them all.

*Download HWinfo


For temperature monitoring only, I feel Core Temp is the most accurate and also offers a quick visual reference for core speed, load and CPU voltage:

*Download Core Temp

 

brutalsam90

Reputable
Dec 28, 2014
29
0
4,530


Hey, um sry for late reply.
So i did ran prime95. just as you told me, with coretemp, i got stable 50-51 C temp, in 5-6 minutes.
Does this mean my cooler is mounted okay ? My idle temps are about 30-32, and my room temp is kinda hot as well.
 
Yes, those temps are actually pretty great if you ran the Small FFT option. Run it again for 15 minutes, just to be sure. If your max temps don't go past maybe 70°C, tops, then it's good. Usually after five minutes it's not going to get any hotter, but occasionally we see a small spike. After fifteen minutes, if it was going to get hotter, it would have by then.

Were those temps at stock or overclocked settings? If it was at stock, then it seems about right. If overclocked, it seems too low to be correct. If you are good, about the same, with a fifteen minute test then I'd say you are good to go for working on the overclock now. Every time you make a frequency or voltage adjustment, restest the thermal compliance by running Prime Small FFT again for fifteen minutes.

Run it for 15-24 hours to verify stability. 24 is better. I've seen systems crash between 15 and 24 hours before, but not usually after that, so 24 is the standard if you REALLY want to be sure the system is practically stable and no silent data corruption is likely.
 

brutalsam90

Reputable
Dec 28, 2014
29
0
4,530


Yeah, those are stock clocks.

I will try to run prime95 bit more than usual and try to record logs.(got to figured how to do that)

And by the way, the reason why i thought i have installed cooler incorrect was that, the fans react abnormally, they are sort of breathing, sometimes loud, it was very loud before i have opened my case. I figured i have airflow problems, maybe because i have too much hdds installed, but my case comes with stock fans not sure, i am keeping it open for now before i can have time to sort things out.
Anyway most annoying problem right now is loud fan spin ups.
 
If the fans and thermal issues go away with the side panel off, then there are clearly either restriction issues because of the drives and drive cages, or just not enough case airflow due to lack of fans, intake fans that don't have adequate static pressure to be used as intake fans, not balanced correctly with an equal number of intake and exhaust fans using all front fans for intake and all top/rear fans as exhaust or some other configuration issue.

Negative pressure is desirable. Balanced is almost as good. Positive pressure from having two or three intakes but only a single exhaust, usually at the rear, is generally going to result in poor cooling performance.

You want high CFM fans on all exhaust locations, but they DO NOT have to be high static pressure, because there is very little resistance to airflow on an exhaust fan.

Intake fans should be high static pressure, but do not need to be as high as say, for a radiator or heatsink. Anything over 1.5-2.0mm H2O static pressure is fine for an intake. I usually suggest a minimum of two 140mm intakes and two 140mm exhaust fans, on systems that can use a 140mm rear exhaust. If only a 120mm is possible there, then I recommend three exhaust fans if you are using two 140mm fans in front. If you are only using two 120mm fans in front then two 120mm exhaust fans, in the rear and top rear locations should be sufficient.

Two and two gives you equal pressure, which has good cooling performance but also helps somewhat to suppress dust collection inside the case. Having more exhaust than intake creates negative pressure, which improves cooling performance but tends to pull more dust in on cases that do not have dust filters. Having more intake than exhaust is not as good for cooling performance, but suppresses dust intake.

I always opt for either balanced or negative pressure. I'd rather blow the case out inside every now and then, which you'll have to do anyhow no matter what kind of configuration you have or how many dust filters there are, some ends up getting in anyhow, so might as well have the better cooling performance of equal or negative.
 

brutalsam90

Reputable
Dec 28, 2014
29
0
4,530


Constant loud fan issue was gone after i have left my case open, but it might just be me after all, it took some time after getting used to it, it is louder than my old air cooler.
And by the way more than 1 hour has passed since i left prime95 running, stable 50-52 C.

Also, just took a photo of my rig, those are all stock fans they were placed there already were placed when i bought this case. There are two intake fans of the same size(i think) on the right side, but all those case fans are rotating fairly slow, both in and out. maybe it has something to do with controls i'm not sure. I have plugged radiator fans on CPU_FAN and pump on pwr_fan just as suggested by Frostflow support(which by the way never replied me back after i told them i got everything right but fans are still loud).
I think it has something to do with fan controls ? Maybe it's reacting to cpu temp spikes and going up and down by that ?
I know i have airflow problems but aside that AIO fans are not being controlled properly.

P.S Going to try closing the case while running prime95 right now.
 
You should be able to set the fan speed profiles in the bios using the CPU FAN header profile.

I'll certainly be willing to help you figure that out, and possibly make a plan on case fans as well if that's something you want to tackle. Case fan profiles are likely configurable as well through the bios. Will need the motherboard model number so I can check that out.

If you can also provide the case model (Can't remember if you did already) and fan model numbers, that would help too. Might be able to figure out what fans you have just by the case model if they all came with the case. Have to be tomorrow though, I'm hitting the sack for tonight.
 

brutalsam90

Reputable
Dec 28, 2014
29
0
4,530


Oh yeah, sure, it's okay, here are infos you've asked, Thanks a lot, appreciate it.
MB: Gigabyte 990fxa-ud3
Case: Aerocool 1000

 
Ok, that means there IS an airflow issue. Also, I will point out that if you put the time and money into getting the case fan cooling configuration RIGHT, you will not only NOT go up in temps, but should actually go DOWN compared to simply having the side panel off because you will exchange the heat away from everything inside at a faster rate than with just having mostly still ambient air.

The effect on the CPU and GPU card cooling will be minimal, since they have their own fans and can pull that cooler ambient air in from outside the case, but the effect on everything else will be, hopefully, a few degrees better. Memory, storage drives, motherboard components and anything else inside the case like the pump housing itself should all see at least a small amount of additional cooling if there is a high enough rate of exchange.

So let me ask a few other questions.

Where did you end up mounting the radiator, front or top?

Are you willing/able to invest anything more into the cooling system? I have a few ideas, but obviously there are few things a person can do to add cooling capability for free. Totally understand if that's not something you want to or can do at the present time. If it is something that needs to wait until down the road we can always revisit it whenever you are ready and able.
 

brutalsam90

Reputable
Dec 28, 2014
29
0
4,530


Radiator is was mounted at top.
By the way i just noticed one intake fan(front side) is not plugged because there is no other fan pin. I think i need to buy splitter to connect them as one. Maybe thats the problem ?

I might invest some, i would like to know what exactly you have in mind.
But still fan spin ups issue remains.
And i will remove some of my hard drives soon. No reason to keep them all.

 
Both the CPU and case fans are able to be controlled via the bios. I'm not sure that this bios allows for a custom profile, but certainly the fan profiles can be switched between smart fan enabled or disabled. They may be disabled now, you'll need to check settings. If you can't get the fans tailored where you like them you might need to consider adding a fan controller hub.


2rx77yq.jpg