650W PSU doesn't satisfy GPU 120% power limit (GTX 1080)

brunor

Prominent
Jan 11, 2018
9
0
510
As the title reads, I have quite a strange problem with my system. I just built it today, got everything refitted from my old case + a new 650W PSU and CPU cooler, ran RealBench benchmark, no issues (this was with an overclock on the GPU but stock CPU speeds, specs further down). Then I ran GTA V, which crashed after about 30 seconds. Restarted the game, crashed again. I then thought to myself, it probably has to do with my cables. Reseated the 24-pin connector, double-checking that all connections to the PSU were in the correct order, and they were. I then added a lonely 6+2 pin connector to the GPU alongside one of the split 2 x 6 + 2 pin connectors, instead of only using the splitter cable. Same issue (tried PUBG, crashed in main menu, and FurMark), so I got quite frustrated, because here's the thing: The only difference between this system and my old one is I went from a 600W PSU to a 650W PSU and replaced my Hyper Evo 212 with a NH D15 (+ I switched case to a Define R6, not that that matters). With the 600W PSU I could run games with an overclocked CPU and GPU with no issues, so I am immediately ruling it down to not being a power shortage issue, thus I really am clueless as to what's going on.

My system is completely stable when watching YT videos and just browsing my desktop (with overclocked GPU), and running FurMark stress test at stock GPU speeds is perfectly stable. It seems that as soon as the power limit reaches above 105% things go downhill.

Specs:

Motherboard: Asus Maximus VIII Gene
CPU Cooler: NH D15
CPU: i7 6700K @ 4.2 GHz
GPU: GTX 1080 @ +145 MHz Core Clock, +500 MHz Memory Clock, 120% power limit, 100% core voltage (MSI Afterburner) (this overclock was fully stable in my old system)
PSU: EVGA G3 650W

I have yet to test my old PSU, which would be the best way to find out if the new PSU is at fault or not, because I'm quite exhausted after all this work. Thought I'd turn to this forum as a last resort!

Update: My old PSU was not modular and it had two separated PCI-E 6 + 2 pin connectors.

Thanks in advance for any clues as to what might be wrong!
 

brunor

Prominent
Jan 11, 2018
9
0
510


I read elsewhere that a splitter should work fine, but it might be wrong, and like I said, I tested using two separate PCI-E cables, one lonely 6 + 2 connector and one of the two 6 + 2 connectors from the splitter cable (occupying one VGA slot each), but to no avail.

At the moment only the VGA 1 slot is taken up by the PCI-E 6 + 2 splitter cable, which I have connected to the GPU. Other than that, a split 24 pin connector, the CPU 8 pin connector and two SATA connectors. No other splitters!

 

brunor

Prominent
Jan 11, 2018
9
0
510


The G3 650W only comes with one lonely 6 + 2 pin connector, so I would assume the splitter should be capable of powering any graphics card, otherwise why do they have the splitter in the first place? I shouldn’t have to buy another separate 6 + 2 pin connector, right?
 
220-G3-0650-Y1_XL_3.png


On the right, 2nd and 3rd cables can be used
 

brunor

Prominent
Jan 11, 2018
9
0
510


Those are the ones I've tried. The 2nd one on the right I've been referring to as a splitter, but it only splits at the neck of the cable. I've tried both of them in separate slots already but no success. However I only tried one of the split cables, and there are two, one at the end and one further up, but that shouldn't make a difference.

 

brunor

Prominent
Jan 11, 2018
9
0
510


I'd think so too, but I can't increase the power consumtion of my GPU above the default 100% limit, which I could do before.

The pics on this website shows the VGA connector on the PSU is an 8 pin:
https://www.evga.com/products/product.aspx?pn=220-G3-0650-Y1

And according to the reviews of this splitter on Amazon, there's no problem:
https://www.amazon.com/PCI-Express-Video-Y-Splitter-Adapter-Supply/dp/B00A3OVG4W/ref=pd_sbs_328_2?ie=UTF8&refRID=0T7HTY2C48H2AZEGCCPP&dpID=31kQ9ZDMhTL&dpSrc=sims&preST=_AC_UL160_SR160%2C160_

But according to one reviewer, https://www.amazon.com/gp/customer-reviews/R26CEH4ZKWAEWD/ref=cm_cr_getr_d_rvw_ttl?ie=UTF8&ASIN=B00A3OVG4W, it shouldn't be done.

I have no idea what and what not to do so far, I just can't imagine EVGA would include a cable that can't power an overclocked GTX 1080, especially considering their PSU released the same year.



 

brunor

Prominent
Jan 11, 2018
9
0
510
I have now tried all configurations of the supplied PSU PCI-E cables (that is, all the ways they can connect to the GPU), and the issue persists. Have sent a support ticket to EVGA, hoping to get a reply by the beginning of next week. Might also get some PCI-E 6 + 2 extension cables to rule out the possibility that the splitter is causing the issue.