Help choosing new NAS for Home Media Server!

OnionKing

Commendable
Jul 25, 2016
40
1
1,565
Hello, I have about 2TB of home music and movies and the current WD My Book Live won't really cut it soon, what are some recommendations for higher end consumer NASs? I've heard good things about Synology and QNAS, but I am unsure of how to proceed. All help will be much appreciated! (It will be hooked up to the router via ethernet to service multiple household devices over the network)
 
You don't say what features you're looking for out of your NAS. 2 TB isn't really much so you probably don't need a 4-drive NAS (though I would recommend it if you can afford it). If you want redundancy (the NAS still works even if a drive dies), then look to run a 2-drive NAS in RAID 1 mode, or a 4-drive NAS in RAID 5 mode.

Look through reviews of some of the options on Small Net Builder. For ease of setup and maintenance I'd stick with QNAP or Synology. The other manufacturers tend to treat NASes like routers - they'll occasionally update the firmware or software every year or two. QNAP and Synology actively maintain and improve their NAS OSes.

https://www.smallnetbuilder.com/nas
 

OnionKing

Commendable
Jul 25, 2016
40
1
1,565


I'm leaning towards a Synology DS218+. I only plan to have one drive for now, but in the future, will expand. Is it as simple as slotting the enxt drive in, and configuring RAID? I have no experience with RAID.
 

USAFRet

Titan
Moderator


With a 2 drive box, you only get the choice of RAID 0 (striped) or RAID 1 (mirrored).
Both mostly useless in a home environment.
 

Synology also supports JBOD mode, so adding a second drive will increase capacity.

https://www.synology.com/en-us/knowledgebase/DSM/help/DSM/StorageManager/volume_diskgroup_what_is_raid
https://www.synology.com/en-us/knowledgebase/DSM/help/DSM/StorageManager/volume_diskgroup_expand_add_disk

You'll still lose data on the entire JBOD volume if a drive dies, just as with RAID 0. (Or more accurately, you'll lose the data on the dead drive. The data on the other drive could still be recovered if you wanted, it just wouldn't work as part of the JBOD volume anymore.) But this risk is rendered moot if he keeps backups. I assume he has other plans for backups, and the point of the NAS is always-on network-accessible storage.

If you haven't made plans for backups, do so. Having a NAS or RAID doesn't eliminate the need for a backup. Even if you call the NAS a backup because the original data also exists on other computers, the fact that it's always online and available makes it not-a-backup. If some ransomware got onto one of your computers, it could encrypt the "backed up" files on the NAS just as easily as it could encrypt the original files on the infected computer. And you would be SOL.

So ideally the backup should be offline (e.g. unplugged external drive) and off-site (on the cloud, or store the drive at work except the one day a month you backup). As photos tend to be the most valuable pieces of personal digital data, I will mention that:

  • ■If you have a Gmail acocunt, Google Photos gives you free unlimited storage of photos downsized to 2048x2048 or smaller. You also get a free 15 GB allowance with Google Drive which can be used to store higher resolution versions of particularly important photos.
    ■If you subscribe to Amazon Prime, Prime Photos gives you free unlimited storage of photos of any size.
    ■If you subscribe to Office 365, it includes 1 TB of storage on Microsoft OneDrive which you can use for cloud backup.
 

USAFRet

Titan
Moderator
Right. I forgot about the JBOD.
My QNAP does that as well if desired.

Along with mirroring to a remote NAS if you desire.

My NAS is backed up weekly to a USB connected drive, that goes offline at the end of the process.
Even when that 8TB USB drive is connected to the NAS, the Windows PC's in the house cannot see it. No permissions...it does not exist for them.

My backup routine here:
http://www.tomshardware.com/forum/id-3383768/backup-situation-home.html