i7-5820k vs i9-7980XE

bluefightingcat

Prominent
Feb 5, 2018
5
0
510
Background: I run software that does a lot of calculations and should is capable of multi-threading.

So I just upgraded to the i9-7980XE. I managed to over clock it to 4.5GHz whilst my i7-5820K runs at 4.2Ghz. I ran the same test with both systems and much to my disppointment the i9 doesn't show any improvement in speeding up the calculations despite the faster clock time and substantially more threads used (33 vs 9). I've tried to sort of some settings in the BIOS but nothing seems to give me any improvement.

Is the i9 architecture so inefficient? Or could it should be that the software isn't using the threads properly (unlikely since it is slower when I set the i9 to use 9 threads instead of 33). Or maybe I just have all my settings wrong somehow.

Any ideas on what might be the issue?
 
Solution
i'm not computer literate enough to advise you or make any suggestions except what i already suggested, ie calling the software vendor's tech support people

but you might post your full system specs for anyone else that might have some ideas


i had a similiar experience - after building a pc with a i7-4790(non-k) cpu for video rendering, then 2 yrs later building a pc with i7-5960x (described in my sig below) - the 4790 has 4 cores / 8 threads, while the 5960x has 8 cores/16threads. On some of the programs i run, the rendering times were not that appreciably faster on the 5960x.

I finally called the software vendor and got thru to one of their techs and they walked me thru some tweaks that made a big difference. But i learned with some programs, they're coded for 4 cores, and don't fully utilitze more than 4.

Have you looked at the load or cpu usage in task manager? What does it show for each cpu running same calculations?
 

bluefightingcat

Prominent
Feb 5, 2018
5
0
510
All Threads I have allowed the software to use are at 100%. So it is actually using them. My suspicion is that there is some sort of memory issue when the data is being accessed from the memory.