Looking to Upgrade, Should I Wait For Ryzen 2 or Intel Refresh or Upgrade Now/ What Z370 Mobo Should I Get?

Sithtiger

Distinguished
Mar 5, 2007
117
2
18,715
Ok, so I'm looking to upgrade. My original plan was to wait until Black Friday of 2018 (I know a long time off) or wait until the new Ryzen 2 CPU's are released or wait until Intel released a refresh or successor to Coffee Lake?

So, I mainly game and surf and watch movies. I have an i7 4790k and 1070. I'd love nothing more than to upgrade my whole system, but I currently only have about $680 on hand but I have another $300 that's owed to me. I've used Intel CPU's forever. The last AMD CPU I've owned was the Athlon XP 2500+....great CPU. I've also owned the Athlon 1.33GHz Thunderbird....oh, that was beautiful, but I buy whoever has the fastest CPU and for the longest time Intel has dominated that until Ryzen and even now Ryzen is beat by Intel especially with Coffee Lake.....so.

If I knew AMD's Ryzen 2 (which is just a refresh as I understand it....nothing huge....the Zen2 architecture isn't due until 2019 from what I've heard and I know that will be a big upgrade to Ryzen) or will Intel release a Coffee Lake refresh or a whole new architecture because of Spectre and Meltdown, not to mention AMD's now a real serious threat again.

So, I'll assume nothing amazing is going to come out this year. The reason I actually need to upgrade now, is partly because it doesn't look like anything faster than the i5 8600k. I could get an i7 8700k, but truth be told, I went from an i5-3570k to an i7-4790k and while it was obviously faster, I couldn't visually discern any difference between that rig that had two GTX 970's in SLI and this one. Well, GPU-wise I could tell a big difference between the 970's and the one GTX 1070, but just booting up or loading apps....nothing. What's worse is literally a month later Skylake came out. So, had I waited, I could have gotten a 6700k with 32GB of DDR4 RAM.

So, I'm looking at a few motherboards. I'm looking at the Asrock Z370 Pro4 or an Asrock Z370 for $129.99, Asrock Z370 Extreme4 for $144.99, Asrock Z370 Kill SLI/ac for $149.99 or the MSI Z370 Gaming Plus for $129.99. I'm leaning heavily toward the Asrock Z370 Extreme or the Asrock Z370 Kill SLI/ac....or even the Asrock Z370 Pro4. I actually built a system with the Asrock Z370m Pro4 with Team T-Force Dark DDR4 16GB and an MSI GeForce GTX 1070 Armor OC. This was before the GPU prices doubled. The 1070 was around $500 or so. I was soooo impressed with the UEFI in that cheap Asrock Z370m Pro4. Without any O/Cing, save Turbo Boost feature enabled. I think the difference was I was comparing it to my i7 4790k which is a quad-core against the i5 8600k with an hex-core. It had a Samsung 850 EVO. I had a Samsung 850 EVO too. Mine is super fast, but only takes about 4 to 5 seconds after the UEFI/BIOS screen pops up. This 8600k and that Asrock mobo booted in 2 seconds are under.

For memory, I'm having a really hard time. Pretty much everything I like isn't on the supported list on either. I'm looking at G.Skill 2400MHz and really G.SKILL Ripjaws V Series 16GB 2666MHz Model F4-2666C15D-16GVR for $181.99 This seems like the sweet spot. Also, the G.SKILL Ripjaws 4 Series 16GB Model F4-2400C15D-16GRR for $159.99. I like the first one better, but the G.SKILL Ripjaws 4 Series 16GB Model F4-2400C15D-16GRR is listed on the compatible list for at least one (maybe more) for the Asrock boards and it's $20 cheaper. The last one, which I like the least is the CORSAIR Vengeance LPX 16GB Model CMK16GX4M2A2400C16 for $179.99. Corsair is pretty good, but I see this particular memory with pretty much all the bundles. It's listed on most compatibility lists for both Asrock and MSI, but some reviews seem to indicate it's had a few issues. It's good for the most part. Shouldn't any 288-pin DDR4 module work with pretty much any Z370 mobo as long as it's not something like 4200 or something like that?
 

beshonk

Distinguished
May 26, 2011
164
0
18,710
If you didn't notice a difference between your 970's and your 1070, and your 3570k and 4790k, you probably won't notice a difference if you upgraded today. The 4790k's IPC is comparable to the current Ryzens, which fall less than 10% below the IPC of an 8-series intel chip. I would toss your money into a high-return savings account and wait for next year, your rig is more than strong enough to remain competitive.
 

larkspur

Distinguished
I don't think you are going to find a noticeable upgrade from your i7-4790k this year. The 1070 should be kicking butt and GPU and RAM prices are just ridiculous. Your i7-4790k should be great. I'd wait until Zen 2 comes out (not this year's Zen+) and then re-evaluate your options.
 

Sithtiger

Distinguished
Mar 5, 2007
117
2
18,715
Thanks for your input guys! I have no doubt Zen2 next year will blow everything away. I could wait until next year if I knew I'd be getting more money. The only problem is I'm disabled and getting the odd PC job here and there usually doesn't pay much; however recently I've had a lot of work. My main problem is my wife borrowing the money. She pays it back, but then ends up borrowing it again. She's not buying crazy things and most things are for bills, but a birthday comes up or this or that and it disappears and all my disability goes into our rent, so. She already owes me $200+. If it wasn't for that I'd wait. If I don't, something will happen that will require the money. My son is graduating this year and other expenses. If GPU prices were where they should be, I could probably do a full upgrade.

The system I built for someone this past December was noticeably faster and it was the i5-8600K as mentioned above. I've decided on upgrading, but I've decided on getting the Asrock Z370 Killer SLI, the i5-8600K and 16GB of G.Skill DDR4 2666MHz memory, or I could get an i7-8700K G.Skill DDR 16GB of 2400GHz memory and the Asrock Z370 Pro4. I could get either one, but I'll definitely have to wait for the new GPU, most likely next year at the earliest, hopefully a Volta card. I know I mainly game, but the 8700K i7 will futureproof for a little longer and assuming games start using more cores, the 8700K will prove more valuble, but will take away from the money for the GPU, but that's a long way off, even if I'll have the money for that.
 

Sithtiger

Distinguished
Mar 5, 2007
117
2
18,715
After doing more research and thinking, I'm going to try my best to hang on to my money. If I see that it's going to be "borrowed" I'll go ahead and buy an i5-8600k. The i7-8700k is too hot, I don't have enough money to buy a good Noctura HSF, but I do have a CM Hyper 212 EVO. The i5-8600k is cooler and I can get the same performance from gaming. In fact, I saw a video pitting an i7 2600k "Sandy Bridge" CPU (which I had at one point) against the i7-8700k using a GTX 1070. At 1080p, almost every single game benchmark gave the exact same performance. Now, there are some games that are CPU bound, which would benefit from a newer CPU. The higher the resolution, the smaller the gap because most games are GPU bound.

Anyway, my hope is that a Zen+ refresh due out soon can at least match the gaming performance. I'm a bit pissed off at Intel moving away from soldering and using glue (to save time and money no doubt) but in the end, creates more heat. I remember AMD was the one that had heating issues. Now, they have the cooler CPU's. If I had a GTX 1080 Ti or even a GTX 1080 then I'd just get a Ryzen 1800X.

I really would like to get a Ryzen this time around, but at 1080P, CPU performance makes a bigger impact. I also read Z390 mobo's for Intel are going to be released soon and they will support up to 8-Core CPU's, so there's some good future proofing there and like Larkspur said, AMD's Zen+ architecture will be released soon. I'd like to see how fast they they are over the present Ryzen CPU's. I know Zen2 will probably be good, but there's absolutely NO WAY I could hang on to my money until next year when they are released, not to mention you can bet Intel will have something too.

I'm glad AMD is back in the game, because now they will push each other now. Intel released Cofee Lake earlier because of AMD, but the only down side to that is they didn't have the Z390 ready, so they released Z370. Z370 can only support a 6-core CPU. If I can hang on to my money, I'll wait. I really want to get a brand new released architecture, but then you get those initial problems that come with new releases.
 
Honestly even with current ryzen I don't think you'll see a difference at 1080p 60hz. Nice thing about ryzen is that socket am4 is supposed to be supported until 2020. Intel seems like many times they require you to get a new motherboard ever so often. AMD in the past seems like they are better about letting you keep the same boards. So it's nice to be able to upgrade as you go.