Puzzling Memory Issue

Mar 18, 2018
2
0
10
I upgraded my sticks from 8GB to 16GB....

Old:
XPG AData
2 x 4GB
10-11-10-30

New:
G. SKill - F3-12800CL10D-16GBXL
2 x 8GB
10-11-10-30-2T

I had the G. Skill sticks working great for a few months. The PC started to get BSOD and complete freeze/lockups, unresponsive keyboard and mouse. It also didn't matter what I was doing, idle or in a high demanding game the results are the same. This could happen 1 time a day or it could happen 10 times. I put the old sticks back in and had 0 issues, logically I sent the new sticks back. When the RMA went through I received brand new 16GB Sticks from G. Skill. When I put them in the PC BSOD within 10 minutes.

Oddly enough 1 week later my 1TB Toshiba HDD failed, could a faulty HDD have caused these issues? I do not understand why these sticks don't work as they are compatible in every way with my setup. It's been a few hours running only on the SSD and I have not received any crashes, but its clear the old sticks had 0 issues on both.

Specs:
Asus Z97-A
Intel i7 4790
Nvidia Geforce GTX 980
1TB Toshiba HDD
250GB Samsung EVO SSD


 
Solution
Possibly because the load on the motherboard/PSU has been reduced slightly with the disconnection of the HDD, any faults are now minimized due to the reduced load.

But, could try another working HDD and see what happens also.

It is (slightly) possible that the Toshiba HDD may have been causing excessive power draw due to it faulting which in turn might cause other system issues due to motherboard/PSU unable to handle the HDD excessive power draw.
Mar 18, 2018
2
0
10


Interesting, I can try that out. However oddly enough I haven't had a crash or BSOD today with the HDD Unplugged.
 
Possibly because the load on the motherboard/PSU has been reduced slightly with the disconnection of the HDD, any faults are now minimized due to the reduced load.

But, could try another working HDD and see what happens also.

It is (slightly) possible that the Toshiba HDD may have been causing excessive power draw due to it faulting which in turn might cause other system issues due to motherboard/PSU unable to handle the HDD excessive power draw.
 
Solution