Prebuild gaming PCs; which one would you choose?

Mar 26, 2018
6
0
10
In the market for a gaming PC and custom building is now around the same price of prebuilt systems. I have found a couple potential options and wondering for input on which one is more worth the buck.

PC#1
Price: $860
CPU: i7-8700
GPU: GeForce 1060 - 3gb
RAM: 8GB DDR4
1TB Hard Drive

PC#2
Price: $800
CPU: Ryzen 7 1700x
GPU: AMD RX 580 - 4gb
RAM: 8GB DDR4
1TB Hard Drive


 
Solution
Junk or not, though, he has a point about price.

https://pcpartpicker.com/list/9BQZRJ: just the i7, GTX 1060, 1TB HDD, & 8GB of DDR4-2600 RAM will run $733 USD. That leaves only $127 USD for the motherboard, case, PSU, Windows, keyboard, DVD drive, etc.

https://pcpartpicker.com/list/gTvnHh: just the R7 1700X, CPU cooler (since it isn't included), RX 580, 1TB HDD, & 8GB of DDR-2600 RAM will run $883 USD. Not only do you not have anything left for any other hardware, but you've already spent $83 more than the prebuilt system.

Neither sets of components so far is drawing a lot of power (220W for the Intel, 315W for the AMD), so any sort of halfway decent 500-600W PSU will be more than sufficient (or a crappy 750-900W PSU, for...


800$ for a 1700x and 580 is hard to beat tho.

I would honestly just get the second one and when an upgrade is due just get a new psu with it.
 

Zerk2012

Titan
Ambassador


Most prebuild power supplies are just garbage and should not be used and again look for both builds to use the cheapest MB you can buy.
I would also expect a single 8gb stick of memory again the cheapest they can get.
 

spdragoo

Expert
Ambassador
Junk or not, though, he has a point about price.

https://pcpartpicker.com/list/9BQZRJ: just the i7, GTX 1060, 1TB HDD, & 8GB of DDR4-2600 RAM will run $733 USD. That leaves only $127 USD for the motherboard, case, PSU, Windows, keyboard, DVD drive, etc.

https://pcpartpicker.com/list/gTvnHh: just the R7 1700X, CPU cooler (since it isn't included), RX 580, 1TB HDD, & 8GB of DDR-2600 RAM will run $883 USD. Not only do you not have anything left for any other hardware, but you've already spent $83 more than the prebuilt system.

Neither sets of components so far is drawing a lot of power (220W for the Intel, 315W for the AMD), so any sort of halfway decent 500-600W PSU will be more than sufficient (or a crappy 750-900W PSU, for that matter), especially if it's not overclocked.
 
Solution
Mar 26, 2018
6
0
10
Well unfortunately the $800 price point for the Ryzen 7/580 expired and is now $900. I'm leaning towards the i7/1060 or may just wait out for another good deal. Thanks for the input everyone.