Which of these CPU coolers should I choose?

Solution
freezer 11LP is looking best for cooling and form factor it is recommended for 100W TDP however Alpine 11 Plus: is also 100W TDP so its cooling performance is similar. now LP model looks better due to direct contact copper pipe and smaller form factor so have better efficiency for smaller size.

AniChatt

Distinguished
freezer 11LP is looking best for cooling and form factor it is recommended for 100W TDP however Alpine 11 Plus: is also 100W TDP so its cooling performance is similar. now LP model looks better due to direct contact copper pipe and smaller form factor so have better efficiency for smaller size.
 
Solution

AniChatt

Distinguished


Now interesting. Tell me your cpu model and why you want to change cooler? There are ton more better option available than what you have selected