Which CPU to choose?

Sep 16, 2018
3
0
10
I have been having a real hard time choosing between AMD or Intel and I really need ya'll to help me. I know that Intel is the best for gaming and some multitasking but, AMD on the other hand can game well but is mainly for multitasking. I want to build a computer that can game very well but also be able to use it for multitasking because I'll be using it for school. So this is where I really need ya'll to help me make a choice between the two.
 
Solution
Any CPU can do that. Honestly, I'd probably recommend using Ryzen. It's going to be cheaper, and being a student you can probably use every extra penny you can save, unless you're lucky enough to have family with or your own deep pockets. Most don't.

Plus, it's not just the CPUs that are less expensive, but the boards are generally a bit cheaper as well unless you plan to overclock and go with a higher end board and cooling solution. If that's the plan, then you might as well go Intel as you'll have a lot more headroom for overclocking, which brings enough performance to put it out of the reach of Ryzen in most cases. Memory compatibility is another area where Intel is a lot more promising. Practically any memory will work on most...
Which CPU models are you looking at? What sort of multitasking are you intending to be doing? Do you plan to simultaneously be recording, streaming or encoding while gaming? Lot's of browser tabs open at the same time while gaming? What exactly is your definition of multitasking?

What is your budget like? What graphics card are you intending to run?

Do you currently have a power supply or do you need to get one for the build? If you already have one, what is the model number? PSU should honestly be the primary consideration if you are building from scratch. The rest of the system should be built around that. Most users don't understand the relationship between the PSU and the rest of the hardware, and don't place any significance to the role it plays. This is the one component you absolutely don't want to cheap out on.

What CPU camp to place your flag in should be a secondary consideration, but still, important.
 
Sep 16, 2018
3
0
10
The CPU's I'm looking at is the ryzen 5 2600 or the i7-8700k. I don't want to do any livestreaming or anything like that at the moment and for multitasking part of I will more or less have multiple tabs open while running other apps in the background and some encoding because I will be going to school for software engineering. Budget I want to go with a high-end system so a GTX 1080 ti is the graphics card I intend to choose. For the power supply I plan on getting a 750 watt either from EVGA or Corsair.
 
I would say gaming and multitasking are two different things. Gaming is just that, running a game. Multitasking would be doing more than one thing. So streaming a game is multitasking for example.

In terms of value per dollar, I think for gaming only, Intel is worth it. For multitasking I think you get more for less cost with AMD. If you want it all you buy Intel but it will cost you a lot more. This assumes you're pairing it with other components, such as the videocard, that are also capable. "School" is a vague term, so it's impossible to say Intel or AMD would be better for 'school'.

edit: I was writing the above while you posted your last bit of information. It sounds like you have the money to go with a top end Intel system, so I wouldn't bother with anything else.
 
Sep 16, 2018
3
0
10


When I say school I should have said college because I will be going to get a degree for software engineering so I want a computer that can game and handle the task that I would have to do during the course
 
Any CPU can do that. Honestly, I'd probably recommend using Ryzen. It's going to be cheaper, and being a student you can probably use every extra penny you can save, unless you're lucky enough to have family with or your own deep pockets. Most don't.

Plus, it's not just the CPUs that are less expensive, but the boards are generally a bit cheaper as well unless you plan to overclock and go with a higher end board and cooling solution. If that's the plan, then you might as well go Intel as you'll have a lot more headroom for overclocking, which brings enough performance to put it out of the reach of Ryzen in most cases. Memory compatibility is another area where Intel is a lot more promising. Practically any memory will work on most Intel configurations. Ryzen has some compatibility issues, especially on lower end boards, and despite a series of BIOS updates since the launch of Ryzen that have improved memory compatibility. It still persists, although not to the level that it was at early on.

Gaming and multitasking are absolutely not two different things. These days, aside from productivity usage, multitasking usually means gaming while also running streams, or recording, or encoding, or browsing (Often with many tabs open), or using resource intensive overlays or a variety of other gaming centric processes, all while gaming. In some cases, doing many of these things simultaneously. In this type of scenario Ryzen is easily the better choice, for the time being. It remains to be seen if the 9th gen Intel CPUs are going to change that or not.

And just because somebody is headed to school to be a software engineer, doesn't mean that they are currently any better off than anybody else. Especially when you factor in the probability of student loans, living expenses and housing. Being a student ain't cheap. Many a student has survived on boxes of Top Ramen while waiting for the day when they can put their schooling to earning some bank.

Do you have a built already, at least somewhat semi-outlined, or is this really in the early stages of planning? Do you have a firm budget to work with or is it rather flexible? Any other considerations aside from performance and quality, or are aesthetics a concern for you as well?
 
Solution

larrycumming

Prominent
Aug 15, 2018
422
0
410
the cost of a computer is like a drop in a bucket compared to college tuition and student loans these days.


however, I think most college kids use laptops these days. makes going around campus much easier and there isnt' a lot of space in most dormitories


for laptops, i'd definitely go with intel