pootissandvichheavy :
What card were the capacitors taken from?
If they were not taken directly from the same model 460 I would NOT buy it.
If the broken capacitor is one of the 10-12 electrolytic/polymer bulk decoupling capacitors, then one missing or significantly sub-par cap might reduce the surviving caps' lifespan by increasing ripples. If it is a ceramic cap, 90+% of them are for power supply bypass and missing one or two won't make much of a difference since there are so many of them in a wide spread of values from 1nF to 10uF to provide sufficiently low ESR from DC to 2GHz with plenty of headroom and redundancy. Another way to put it: you wouldn't be able to achieve 10+% overclocks on GPUs if supply bypass capacitors were already anywhere near critical at stock clocks. For the remaining ~10% of ceramics, most of them are for PCIe AC-coupling and a mismatch there might disable half of the PCIe bus.
The most critical capacitors I can think of would be in the voltage regulator feedback loops: the wrong capacitors there may cause the regulators to become unstable and destroy the GPU. On modern cards though, those would be 0201 or 0402 size capacitors which are highly unlikely to get knocked out by accident or be noticed if they were due to their very small size, they're almost more solder pads than component.