In some respects I would agree with you but one of the things I think is missing from the 'modern' era for lack of better term, is the variety and willingness to try crazy things. In part this is due to the expense and time it takes to make games today but it still seems to me that there are two different philosophies between the two eras (in general, I don't mean to apply this to all games or studios) and that is what leads me to say that I prefer classic games. Furthermore, if I do as you suggest and play a modern version and a classic one such as the original LoZ and the newest one, I genuinely prefer the old one. That is not to say that i didn't thoroughly enjoy Twilight princess but it is staring to feel repetitive and been tehre done that. I feel this way about a lot of current games as well and is partly the reason for the poll. You are right though, it is very subjective and there are some games which I would put up there with my favorites which would be considered modern as I defined them (System Shock 2, Soul Reaver etc). I just would like to see something new, different. Gears of War offered a refreshing twist of FPS game play but I have lost interest in it. It is really tough to pin down but as I said I really feel something missing from games today that was present in the past.