Ok guy..just to clear up something that you dont seem to understand. At first it was P4 that was faster for encoding, which was right but now the P4 is faster at anything video, which is not true.
Video editing is not encoding. encoding is not rendering rendering is not editing.. So saying tha the P4 is better at encoding doesnt mean that it is better at rendering and editing.
Video editing is when you take a movie, take some parts out, put new parts in, add title, transitions, sounds, music,...
You need mostly a fast HDD here, and either a P4 or an AMD will perform good here. You dont work with rawe data here, but rather with timed event. So, basicly tell your computer to take that file, a x time you insert that sound, a x time you put that fade, and so on. The fast HDD come in handy when you sneek thru the video file to find some parts to edit, ...
Video rendering is when you finished piecing the parts of your movie and you want to have them assembledto create your movie.
Here to, a fast hdd will help as it has to read and write often on the disk. A fast CPU helps here too, and which one is better is hard to tell, as it depend of which apps you use and which codec is used. for the same movie, it can take 15 minutes with one application while the other may need 1 hours to do the same. Pinnacle Studio8 is a slow renderer, and Version9 add a better codec that cut rendering time in half on the same machine.
Video encoding is when you take an AVI movie and transform it into a Divx one or an mpeg movie to an AVI one.
The P4 is better here because of its higher clock. Encoding is a streamlined task that is well served by the fastest clock that the longer P4's pipeline has. A 2.8 P4 will outperform the 2800+ AMD... but maybe not the 2.8 Ghz overclocked AMD.
Now that you know the difference, I should see another post that says that P4 perform better at editing... because it is not always the case.
Ouf.. I think I stoped that soon enough to prevent some guru to start saying that the P4 is better at video taping, or video cassette recording... or at american funniest home video-ing, or at music video,...
-Always put the blame on you first, then on the hardware !!!
Video editing is not encoding. encoding is not rendering rendering is not editing.. So saying tha the P4 is better at encoding doesnt mean that it is better at rendering and editing.
Video editing is when you take a movie, take some parts out, put new parts in, add title, transitions, sounds, music,...
You need mostly a fast HDD here, and either a P4 or an AMD will perform good here. You dont work with rawe data here, but rather with timed event. So, basicly tell your computer to take that file, a x time you insert that sound, a x time you put that fade, and so on. The fast HDD come in handy when you sneek thru the video file to find some parts to edit, ...
Video rendering is when you finished piecing the parts of your movie and you want to have them assembledto create your movie.
Here to, a fast hdd will help as it has to read and write often on the disk. A fast CPU helps here too, and which one is better is hard to tell, as it depend of which apps you use and which codec is used. for the same movie, it can take 15 minutes with one application while the other may need 1 hours to do the same. Pinnacle Studio8 is a slow renderer, and Version9 add a better codec that cut rendering time in half on the same machine.
Video encoding is when you take an AVI movie and transform it into a Divx one or an mpeg movie to an AVI one.
The P4 is better here because of its higher clock. Encoding is a streamlined task that is well served by the fastest clock that the longer P4's pipeline has. A 2.8 P4 will outperform the 2800+ AMD... but maybe not the 2.8 Ghz overclocked AMD.
Now that you know the difference, I should see another post that says that P4 perform better at editing... because it is not always the case.
Ouf.. I think I stoped that soon enough to prevent some guru to start saying that the P4 is better at video taping, or video cassette recording... or at american funniest home video-ing, or at music video,...
-Always put the blame on you first, then on the hardware !!!