Lost calls with Verizon Data

[john]

Archived from groups: alt.cellular.verizon (More info?)

I will be getting a wireless PDA but am concerned about lost calls
while it is doing "wireless sync" to get email. Does anyone know if
this happens on VZ with the blackberry, Treo 600 or others? I know
CDMA will not handle voice and data at the same time - but will it
drop a data call for a voice call?
Thanks,
-JAX

 

[Guest]

Archived from groups: alt.cellular.verizon (More info?)

John wrote:

> I will be getting a wireless PDA but am concerned about lost calls
> while it is doing "wireless sync" to get email. Does anyone know if
> this happens on VZ with the blackberry, Treo 600 or others? I know
> CDMA will not handle voice and data at the same time - but will it
> drop a data call for a voice call?

On both Verizon and Sprint, if the phone has an active data call, it will not
ring if someone makes a voice call to you. The call will eventually go to
voicemail. Verizon and Sprint are both CDMA carriers.

--
JustThe.net Internet & New Media Services, http://JustThe.net/
Steven J. Sobol, Geek In Charge / 888.480.4NET (4638) / sjsobol@JustThe.net
PGP Key available from your friendly local key server (0xE3AE35ED)
Apple Valley, California Nothing scares me anymore. I have three kids.

 

[Guest]

Archived from groups: alt.cellular.verizon (More info?)

> On both Verizon and Sprint, if the phone has an active data call, it will
> not ring if someone makes a voice call to you. The call will eventually go
> to voicemail. Verizon and Sprint are both CDMA carriers.

Yes, however, my 1x data calls seem to go into dormant mode very quickly
whenever I am not actively using the connection. One can receive voice
calls if the data connection is dormant. In general I consider this an
annoyance rather than a feature, but this may be the one case where it has
an advantage (fast dormant
status enables voice calls much of the time).

GSM/GPRS carriers have several advantages over CDMA/1X carriers today:
1) Voice priority over data (true for GPRS, not true for 1x).
2) GPRS is capable of allowing both simultaneous data and voice.
3) GPRS data works even when roaming. AT&T's plans include roaming
access to data at the same rate as on their own network.

CDMA/1X advantages over GSM/GPRS:
1) 1x tends to be faster at each development cycle. i.e. 1x compared to
GPRS

or EV-DO compared to EDGE etc.
2) 1x tends to be cheaper for customers (if you consider unadvertised things
like
Verizon allowing folks to use 1x for just the cost of minutes and no
additional monthly).

For me, the casual user, Verizon's data is cheaper and works acceptably
well. If I was a business traveller I would definitely choose GPRS mainly
to get data access when roaming.

-Dan

PS: I'd look at T-Mobile or AT&T for better data access with voice priority
and roaming.
1x is faster than GPRS, but only slightly. 1x EV-DO will not permit
simultaneous
voice either, so the wait for CDMA carriers will be long until EV-DV is
deployed (which will allow simultaneous voice for CDMA carriers).

--
Eugene, Oregon -- Pacific Northwest
http://cell.uoregon.edu