My friend, (I said friend because you played 2142 and aren't a COD baby)
BF2142 was, and will always be the last great Battlefield game. With the rise of COD4 it changed the whole genre of First Person Shooters and the console took over the FPS game majority. BF3 will never be great because they had to consider the console. While they may have developed the PC and console versions separately it IS the same game.
My list of things I miss from 2142:
-------------------------------------------
- Spotting: You can no longer spot where you THINK an enemy is or call out the type of unit. You have a single spot button and have to rely on the game to determine the action.
- Titan Mode: 2142 had Conquest and Titan, THAT was it. No RUSH maps that funneled players into a narrow map to be slaughtered by an incoming barrage of sniper rounds, noob tubes, rockets, and a giant peppering of automatic fire. Did 2142 even HAVE an under barrel grenade launcher? Oh wait, it had that Assault rocket add-on thingy, nevermind. That was like the FIRST noob tube.
- Commander > Squad Leader > Squad Member: Remember being the all mighty Commander? When you would camp out in a base with your SAT map and drop supplies, EMPs, Areal Bombardments, and UAV's? Not to mention order squads around and get angry when they didn't comply with your orders? Or better yet you sucked at the Commander roll and got voted off the island? Yeah, none of that in BF3. Just a yet to be determined squad management system that was not in beta. I think I saw something flash on the screen once that said "You are the squad leader". What the hell does that mean?
- Titans: It's a freaking Huge areal ship! Need I say more? Although 2142 is in the future. Bummer
- Walkers: Need I say more? Although BF3 does have some cool vehicles to play with. I have not seen a little quad yet though, but I think I did in a video so they are fun.
- Built in menus: Apparently EA thought it would be fun to make the entire game interface a giant facebook page called BattleLog. Gee thanks. We went from not being able to ALT+TAB out of 2142 without crashing, to, you MUST ALT+TAB in order to do anything outside of playing the game.
- Changing your soldiers name: Apparently my EA ID is now my Origin ID, and my Origin ID is now my BF3 soldier name. FTW EA! I created that user ID to sign into the EA site years ago, I don't want a soldier with that stupid name. I have a name that my CLAN knows me by. Way to kill my long lived gamer handle.
- Fast knifing: It now takes 2 full seconds to knife someone. Granted it is more realistic, but I could do without the small cut-scene that is now the action of knifing. I have found myself slicing at air because this action is to difficult to execute correctly . And when I do plant it correctly, I am almost instantly killed because my guy is doing his little knife dance in front of 2 dozen caffeine filled gamers ready to put my head in their cross-hairs.
- Full Map View: There is no full map view in BF3. I don't even know what the entire map looks like because when I hit the "M" button it no longer takes my mini map to a full screen, which shows me the entire battlefield. It just make my mini map bigger. I am not visually impaired, I want to see everything EA! That action is pointless to even include.
The game does look really good graphically, I think EA should have kept the essence of all the genuine battlefield games before instead of adding or taking away certain features. Just by playing BF3 you can tell they tried to add components that would entice COD players to come over to the dark side and also keep the console people happy with easy actions. Remember, consoles controllers don't have 104 key like we do, plus mouse. So they had to take the old school BF games and the COD games they are up again and meet somewhere in the middle, while at the same time keeping it easy to control for the console wienies. I will get used to it, and I will play it. Because lets face it, it is a far cry from the hordes of 12-18 year olds playing COD with the reflexes of a cheetah and the brain of a goldfish.
Hope you enjoyed my rant.
VIVA LA BATTLEFIELD 2142!