FlintIronStagg :
Im just suprised at how people are confusing art direction over technical prowess.
this happened last time there was a thread like this, and someone argued about black ops being GORGEOUS.... HAHA!
1. Crysis. one word. scale.
2. Metro 2033. Lighting and shadows that will only be beat by Last light when it releases
3. BF3.
4. Witcher 2. DX9 my friends is no slouch.
5. Crysis 2 DX11
Oh man you have no idea how much I agree with you there. People are too quick to discard DX9 as "old" when beauties such as Crysis still exist and validly compete with the newest games on the market all "sporting" DX11 support.
I installed Crysis and played through it again a few weeks ago, and I was absolutely flabbergasted from the start. To me, the pure achievement this game reached in terms of graphical advancement will make it my top pick any day. It has a lot better detail, artwork (hell, artwork plays a role in graphics, there's no question about it) and overall epicness than most games today (those maps are HUGE and everything looks as beautiful as if it was individually drawn by hand). It remains my top pick of "best graphics games of all time" simply because of what it managed to pull off.
If you're looking at games purely at how detailed they must be to compete, everyone will agree that BF3 is top, followed by the likes of Witcher 2 and Crysis 2 (DX11 mod, DX9 didn't look much better than the first Crysis). We should keep an eye out for Far Cry 3 though, I hear the new Frostbyte engine has been really used in that game...