Sign in with
Sign up | Sign in
Your question

Advice before installing Windows XP SP2

Last response: in Computer Brands
Share
Anonymous
August 27, 2004 1:15:11 AM

Archived from groups: alt.sys.pc-clone.compaq (More info?)

I am looking for advice prior to installing the Windows XP SP2
service pack.

I have 2 Compaq Desktops
#1 Compaq Presario S3010CL-B (Sam's Club 7/3/2003) AMD Athlon XP
2200+
#2 Compaq Presario S5000J (Compaq Direct 9/13/2003) AMD Athlon
XP 2400+

The machines are Windowx XP SP1 with all Critical Updates
installed.

I visited the Compaq website and found the "HP and Compaq
Desktop PCs - Important Information for Upgrading to Microsoft
Windows XP Service Pack 2" document. I did the "System Restore
Update". I also did the "Multimedia Keyboard Driver Update",
even though I did not think it was necessary. I haven't observed
any changes in the machines from that one. The rest don't seem
to apply to my machines.

They did recommend updating drivers prior to installing SP2. I
have been puting off the following driver updates, on the "If it
ain't broke, don't fix it" theory:

(1)Microsoft Corporation - Other Hardware - AMD K7 Processor
(Pub:5/15/04 Rel:12/17/02)
(2)Agere Systems - Modems - Agere Win Modem (Pub:8/10/04
Rel:12/12/03)
(3)Windows XP Driver 5.10.0.5410 for Realtec AC 97 Audio
(KB833846 Pub:6/4/2004)
(4)S3 Graphics, Inc. - Video - S3 Graphics ProSavageDDR
(Pub:5/17/04 Rel:3/2/04)
(5)VIA Technologies Inc. - Networking - VIA Rhine II Fast
Ethernet Adapter (Pub:8/3/04 Rel:7/22/04)

I guess I will finally install them, unless someone is aware of
a reason not to.

Does anyone have any warnings about any of these drivers or
Windows XP SP2 on these machines?

TIA
--
Ken Wampach - LastNameATeskimoDOTcom
August 27, 2004 9:41:21 AM

Archived from groups: alt.sys.pc-clone.compaq (More info?)

Ken,
I cannot speak for others, but right now, I have no desire to install SP2 on
my Presario S5200CL, an Athlon XP 2600+. I've had no security issues, which
is the prime reason MS rolled out SP2. I run both a hardware and software
firewall, plus a virus shield and anti-spyware software. and I never open
e-mail unless it is scanned first.
That said, there may be a time in the future when I would want to install
SP2.
But, most uimportantly, I'm a firm believer in the "If it ain't broke...."
adage.
HH

"Ken Wampach" <NOSPAM@myisp.com> wrote in message
news:1_qdnTtarbnROrPcRVn-jg@comcast.com...
> I am looking for advice prior to installing the Windows XP SP2
> service pack.
>
> I have 2 Compaq Desktops
> #1 Compaq Presario S3010CL-B (Sam's Club 7/3/2003) AMD Athlon XP
> 2200+
> #2 Compaq Presario S5000J (Compaq Direct 9/13/2003) AMD Athlon
> XP 2400+
>
> The machines are Windowx XP SP1 with all Critical Updates
> installed.
>
> I visited the Compaq website and found the "HP and Compaq
> Desktop PCs - Important Information for Upgrading to Microsoft
> Windows XP Service Pack 2" document. I did the "System Restore
> Update". I also did the "Multimedia Keyboard Driver Update",
> even though I did not think it was necessary. I haven't observed
> any changes in the machines from that one. The rest don't seem
> to apply to my machines.
>
> They did recommend updating drivers prior to installing SP2. I
> have been puting off the following driver updates, on the "If it
> ain't broke, don't fix it" theory:
>
> (1)Microsoft Corporation - Other Hardware - AMD K7 Processor
> (Pub:5/15/04 Rel:12/17/02)
> (2)Agere Systems - Modems - Agere Win Modem (Pub:8/10/04
> Rel:12/12/03)
> (3)Windows XP Driver 5.10.0.5410 for Realtec AC 97 Audio
> (KB833846 Pub:6/4/2004)
> (4)S3 Graphics, Inc. - Video - S3 Graphics ProSavageDDR
> (Pub:5/17/04 Rel:3/2/04)
> (5)VIA Technologies Inc. - Networking - VIA Rhine II Fast
> Ethernet Adapter (Pub:8/3/04 Rel:7/22/04)
>
> I guess I will finally install them, unless someone is aware of
> a reason not to.
>
> Does anyone have any warnings about any of these drivers or
> Windows XP SP2 on these machines?
>
> TIA
> --
> Ken Wampach - LastNameATeskimoDOTcom
>
>
Anonymous
August 27, 2004 5:36:43 PM

Archived from groups: alt.sys.pc-clone.compaq (More info?)

From a few of the reviews I've read on SP2, XP is broke and SP2 can't
fix the key problems in XP security. After all the delays and debate and
apparently despite MS best efforts, the key issue remains, XP is not fully
secure.

KC

"HH" <hahunt42@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:hkDXc.594$lV5.96@fe25.usenetserver.com...
> Ken,
> I cannot speak for others, but right now, I have no desire to install SP2
on
> my Presario S5200CL, an Athlon XP 2600+. I've had no security issues,
which
> is the prime reason MS rolled out SP2. I run both a hardware and software
> firewall, plus a virus shield and anti-spyware software. and I never open
> e-mail unless it is scanned first.
> That said, there may be a time in the future when I would want to install
> SP2.
> But, most uimportantly, I'm a firm believer in the "If it ain't broke...."
> adage.
> HH
>
> "Ken Wampach" <NOSPAM@myisp.com> wrote in message
> news:1_qdnTtarbnROrPcRVn-jg@comcast.com...
> > I am looking for advice prior to installing the Windows XP SP2
> > service pack.
> >
> > I have 2 Compaq Desktops
> > #1 Compaq Presario S3010CL-B (Sam's Club 7/3/2003) AMD Athlon XP
> > 2200+
> > #2 Compaq Presario S5000J (Compaq Direct 9/13/2003) AMD Athlon
> > XP 2400+
> >
> > The machines are Windowx XP SP1 with all Critical Updates
> > installed.
> >
> > I visited the Compaq website and found the "HP and Compaq
> > Desktop PCs - Important Information for Upgrading to Microsoft
> > Windows XP Service Pack 2" document. I did the "System Restore
> > Update". I also did the "Multimedia Keyboard Driver Update",
> > even though I did not think it was necessary. I haven't observed
> > any changes in the machines from that one. The rest don't seem
> > to apply to my machines.
> >
> > They did recommend updating drivers prior to installing SP2. I
> > have been puting off the following driver updates, on the "If it
> > ain't broke, don't fix it" theory:
> >
> > (1)Microsoft Corporation - Other Hardware - AMD K7 Processor
> > (Pub:5/15/04 Rel:12/17/02)
> > (2)Agere Systems - Modems - Agere Win Modem (Pub:8/10/04
> > Rel:12/12/03)
> > (3)Windows XP Driver 5.10.0.5410 for Realtec AC 97 Audio
> > (KB833846 Pub:6/4/2004)
> > (4)S3 Graphics, Inc. - Video - S3 Graphics ProSavageDDR
> > (Pub:5/17/04 Rel:3/2/04)
> > (5)VIA Technologies Inc. - Networking - VIA Rhine II Fast
> > Ethernet Adapter (Pub:8/3/04 Rel:7/22/04)
> >
> > I guess I will finally install them, unless someone is aware of
> > a reason not to.
> >
> > Does anyone have any warnings about any of these drivers or
> > Windows XP SP2 on these machines?
> >
> > TIA
> > --
> > Ken Wampach - LastNameATeskimoDOTcom
> >
> >
>
>
>
Related resources
Anonymous
August 28, 2004 1:59:21 AM

Archived from groups: alt.sys.pc-clone.compaq (More info?)

HH,
Thanks for your comments. I still would like to know if anyone
has tried
any of the hardware driver updates I listed with either good or
bad results.
> > (1)Microsoft Corporation - Other Hardware - AMD K7 Processor
> > (Pub:5/15/04 Rel:12/17/02)
> > (2)Agere Systems - Modems - Agere Win Modem (Pub:8/10/04
> > Rel:12/12/03)
> > (3)Windows XP Driver 5.10.0.5410 for Realtec AC 97 Audio
> > (KB833846 Pub:6/4/2004)
> > (4)S3 Graphics, Inc. - Video - S3 Graphics ProSavageDDR
> > (Pub:5/17/04 Rel:3/2/04)
> > (5)VIA Technologies Inc. - Networking - VIA Rhine II Fast
> > Ethernet Adapter (Pub:8/3/04 Rel:7/22/04)
--
Ken Wampach - FirstNameLastNameATyahooDOTcom

"HH" <hahunt42@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:hkDXc.594$lV5.96@fe25.usenetserver.com...
> Ken,
> I cannot speak for others, but right now, I have no desire to
install SP2 on
> my Presario S5200CL, an Athlon XP 2600+. I've had no security
issues, which
> is the prime reason MS rolled out SP2. I run both a hardware
and software
> firewall, plus a virus shield and anti-spyware software. and I
never open
> e-mail unless it is scanned first.
> That said, there may be a time in the future when I would want
to install
> SP2.
> But, most uimportantly, I'm a firm believer in the "If it
ain't broke...."
> adage.
> HH
>
> "Ken Wampach" <NOSPAM@myisp.com> wrote in message
> news:1_qdnTtarbnROrPcRVn-jg@comcast.com...
> > I am looking for advice prior to installing the Windows XP
SP2
> > service pack.
> >
> > I have 2 Compaq Desktops
> > #1 Compaq Presario S3010CL-B (Sam's Club 7/3/2003) AMD
Athlon XP
> > 2200+
> > #2 Compaq Presario S5000J (Compaq Direct 9/13/2003) AMD
Athlon
> > XP 2400+
> >
> > The machines are Windowx XP SP1 with all Critical Updates
> > installed.
> >
> > I visited the Compaq website and found the "HP and Compaq
> > Desktop PCs - Important Information for Upgrading to
Microsoft
> > Windows XP Service Pack 2" document. I did the "System
Restore
> > Update". I also did the "Multimedia Keyboard Driver Update",
> > even though I did not think it was necessary. I haven't
observed
> > any changes in the machines from that one. The rest don't
seem
> > to apply to my machines.
> >
> > They did recommend updating drivers prior to installing SP2.
I
> > have been puting off the following driver updates, on the
"If it
> > ain't broke, don't fix it" theory:
> >
> > (1)Microsoft Corporation - Other Hardware - AMD K7 Processor
> > (Pub:5/15/04 Rel:12/17/02)
> > (2)Agere Systems - Modems - Agere Win Modem (Pub:8/10/04
> > Rel:12/12/03)
> > (3)Windows XP Driver 5.10.0.5410 for Realtec AC 97 Audio
> > (KB833846 Pub:6/4/2004)
> > (4)S3 Graphics, Inc. - Video - S3 Graphics ProSavageDDR
> > (Pub:5/17/04 Rel:3/2/04)
> > (5)VIA Technologies Inc. - Networking - VIA Rhine II Fast
> > Ethernet Adapter (Pub:8/3/04 Rel:7/22/04)
> >
> > I guess I will finally install them, unless someone is aware
of
> > a reason not to.
> >
> > Does anyone have any warnings about any of these drivers or
> > Windows XP SP2 on these machines?
> >
> > TIA
> > --
> > Ken Wampach - LastNameATeskimoDOTcom
August 28, 2004 3:28:44 PM

Archived from groups: alt.sys.pc-clone.compaq (More info?)

I applied all of the driver and other updates available through Windows
Update as they were released. That includes the Agere Win Modem 12/12/03,
VIA Technologies multimedia (4/23/04 3/17/04 2/11/04 12/19/2003 10/20/2003),
S3 Graphics display 3/2/04, AMD processor 12/17/02. No problems on my Compaq
Presario S4020WM with Windows XP Home (SP1). The only thing special I did
before installing SP2 was to install the recent System Restore update
available from the Compaq/HP website, so that prior restore points would
still work if needed. Then I applied the SP2 update yesterday using the free
CD from Staples. No problems.

I went to great pains to totally disable all software before running the SP2
update, including my firewall and anti-virus. I don't know if that was
necessary but didn't want to take chances.

Note: apparently the 12/12/03 Agere modem update put a new item in my
msconfig startup list "LTMSG.EXE" which I worried about for awhile, but
believe it's probably OK. I tried turning it off, and my connection
throughput speed was poor. Then turned it back on, and things are normal
again. That's not proven absolutely, just a one time observation and some
assumptions. I try not to keep any startup items unless their value is
proven, but of course there are uncertainties about some of them.
-E


"Ken Wampach" <NOSPAM@myisp.com> wrote in message
news:ud6dncCd8IT6nq3cRVn-gg@comcast.com...
> HH,
> Thanks for your comments. I still would like to know if anyone
> has tried
> any of the hardware driver updates I listed with either good or
> bad results.
>> > (1)Microsoft Corporation - Other Hardware - AMD K7 Processor
>> > (Pub:5/15/04 Rel:12/17/02)
>> > (2)Agere Systems - Modems - Agere Win Modem (Pub:8/10/04
>> > Rel:12/12/03)
>> > (3)Windows XP Driver 5.10.0.5410 for Realtec AC 97 Audio
>> > (KB833846 Pub:6/4/2004)
>> > (4)S3 Graphics, Inc. - Video - S3 Graphics ProSavageDDR
>> > (Pub:5/17/04 Rel:3/2/04)
>> > (5)VIA Technologies Inc. - Networking - VIA Rhine II Fast
>> > Ethernet Adapter (Pub:8/3/04 Rel:7/22/04)
> --
> Ken Wampach - FirstNameLastNameATyahooDOTcom
>
> "HH" <hahunt42@hotmail.com> wrote in message
> news:hkDXc.594$lV5.96@fe25.usenetserver.com...
>> Ken,
>> I cannot speak for others, but right now, I have no desire to
> install SP2 on
>> my Presario S5200CL, an Athlon XP 2600+. I've had no security
> issues, which
>> is the prime reason MS rolled out SP2. I run both a hardware
> and software
>> firewall, plus a virus shield and anti-spyware software. and I
> never open
>> e-mail unless it is scanned first.
>> That said, there may be a time in the future when I would want
> to install
>> SP2.
>> But, most uimportantly, I'm a firm believer in the "If it
> ain't broke...."
>> adage.
>> HH
>>
>> "Ken Wampach" <NOSPAM@myisp.com> wrote in message
>> news:1_qdnTtarbnROrPcRVn-jg@comcast.com...
>> > I am looking for advice prior to installing the Windows XP
> SP2
>> > service pack.
>> >
>> > I have 2 Compaq Desktops
>> > #1 Compaq Presario S3010CL-B (Sam's Club 7/3/2003) AMD
> Athlon XP
>> > 2200+
>> > #2 Compaq Presario S5000J (Compaq Direct 9/13/2003) AMD
> Athlon
>> > XP 2400+
>> >
>> > The machines are Windowx XP SP1 with all Critical Updates
>> > installed.
>> >
>> > I visited the Compaq website and found the "HP and Compaq
>> > Desktop PCs - Important Information for Upgrading to
> Microsoft
>> > Windows XP Service Pack 2" document. I did the "System
> Restore
>> > Update". I also did the "Multimedia Keyboard Driver Update",
>> > even though I did not think it was necessary. I haven't
> observed
>> > any changes in the machines from that one. The rest don't
> seem
>> > to apply to my machines.
>> >
>> > They did recommend updating drivers prior to installing SP2.
> I
>> > have been puting off the following driver updates, on the
> "If it
>> > ain't broke, don't fix it" theory:
>> >
>> > (1)Microsoft Corporation - Other Hardware - AMD K7 Processor
>> > (Pub:5/15/04 Rel:12/17/02)
>> > (2)Agere Systems - Modems - Agere Win Modem (Pub:8/10/04
>> > Rel:12/12/03)
>> > (3)Windows XP Driver 5.10.0.5410 for Realtec AC 97 Audio
>> > (KB833846 Pub:6/4/2004)
>> > (4)S3 Graphics, Inc. - Video - S3 Graphics ProSavageDDR
>> > (Pub:5/17/04 Rel:3/2/04)
>> > (5)VIA Technologies Inc. - Networking - VIA Rhine II Fast
>> > Ethernet Adapter (Pub:8/3/04 Rel:7/22/04)
>> >
>> > I guess I will finally install them, unless someone is aware
> of
>> > a reason not to.
>> >
>> > Does anyone have any warnings about any of these drivers or
>> > Windows XP SP2 on these machines?
>> >
>> > TIA
>> > --
>> > Ken Wampach - LastNameATeskimoDOTcom
>
>
Anonymous
August 28, 2004 3:28:45 PM

Archived from groups: alt.sys.pc-clone.compaq (More info?)

Euclid,
Thanks for the information. I believe your machine is a close
cousin
to mine, so I will try installing most of the driver updates. I
may skip
the modem one, since we have cable high-speed internet and
rarely
use the modems.
--
Ken Wampach - FirstNameLastNameATyahooDOTcom

"Euclid" <Euclid@mmiv.nu> wrote in message
news:M%ZXc.1673$JT3.672@newsread3.news.atl.earthlink.net...
> I applied all of the driver and other updates available
through Windows
> Update as they were released. That includes the Agere Win
Modem 12/12/03,
> VIA Technologies multimedia (4/23/04 3/17/04 2/11/04
12/19/2003 10/20/2003),
> S3 Graphics display 3/2/04, AMD processor 12/17/02. No
problems on my Compaq
> Presario S4020WM with Windows XP Home (SP1). The only thing
special I did
> before installing SP2 was to install the recent System Restore
update
> available from the Compaq/HP website, so that prior restore
points would
> still work if needed. Then I applied the SP2 update yesterday
using the free
> CD from Staples. No problems.
>
> I went to great pains to totally disable all software before
running the SP2
> update, including my firewall and anti-virus. I don't know if
that was
> necessary but didn't want to take chances.
>
> Note: apparently the 12/12/03 Agere modem update put a new
item in my
> msconfig startup list "LTMSG.EXE" which I worried about for
awhile, but
> believe it's probably OK. I tried turning it off, and my
connection
> throughput speed was poor. Then turned it back on, and things
are normal
> again. That's not proven absolutely, just a one time
observation and some
> assumptions. I try not to keep any startup items unless their
value is
> proven, but of course there are uncertainties about some of
them.
> -E
>
>
> "Ken Wampach" <NOSPAM@myisp.com> wrote in message
> news:ud6dncCd8IT6nq3cRVn-gg@comcast.com...
> > HH,
> > Thanks for your comments. I still would like to know if
anyone
> > has tried
> > any of the hardware driver updates I listed with either good
or
> > bad results.
> >> > (1)Microsoft Corporation - Other Hardware - AMD K7
Processor
> >> > (Pub:5/15/04 Rel:12/17/02)
> >> > (2)Agere Systems - Modems - Agere Win Modem (Pub:8/10/04
> >> > Rel:12/12/03)
> >> > (3)Windows XP Driver 5.10.0.5410 for Realtec AC 97 Audio
> >> > (KB833846 Pub:6/4/2004)
> >> > (4)S3 Graphics, Inc. - Video - S3 Graphics ProSavageDDR
> >> > (Pub:5/17/04 Rel:3/2/04)
> >> > (5)VIA Technologies Inc. - Networking - VIA Rhine II Fast
> >> > Ethernet Adapter (Pub:8/3/04 Rel:7/22/04)
> > --
> > Ken Wampach - FirstNameLastNameATyahooDOTcom
> >
> > "HH" <hahunt42@hotmail.com> wrote in message
> > news:hkDXc.594$lV5.96@fe25.usenetserver.com...
> >> Ken,
> >> I cannot speak for others, but right now, I have no desire
to
> > install SP2 on
> >> my Presario S5200CL, an Athlon XP 2600+. I've had no
security
> > issues, which
> >> is the prime reason MS rolled out SP2. I run both a
hardware
> > and software
> >> firewall, plus a virus shield and anti-spyware software.
and I
> > never open
> >> e-mail unless it is scanned first.
> >> That said, there may be a time in the future when I would
want
> > to install
> >> SP2.
> >> But, most uimportantly, I'm a firm believer in the "If it
> > ain't broke...."
> >> adage.
> >> HH
> >>
> >> "Ken Wampach" <NOSPAM@myisp.com> wrote in message
> >> news:1_qdnTtarbnROrPcRVn-jg@comcast.com...
> >> > I am looking for advice prior to installing the Windows
XP
> > SP2
> >> > service pack.
> >> >
> >> > I have 2 Compaq Desktops
> >> > #1 Compaq Presario S3010CL-B (Sam's Club 7/3/2003) AMD
> > Athlon XP
> >> > 2200+
> >> > #2 Compaq Presario S5000J (Compaq Direct 9/13/2003) AMD
> > Athlon
> >> > XP 2400+
> >> >
> >> > The machines are Windowx XP SP1 with all Critical Updates
> >> > installed.
> >> >
> >> > I visited the Compaq website and found the "HP and Compaq
> >> > Desktop PCs - Important Information for Upgrading to
> > Microsoft
> >> > Windows XP Service Pack 2" document. I did the "System
> > Restore
> >> > Update". I also did the "Multimedia Keyboard Driver
Update",
> >> > even though I did not think it was necessary. I haven't
> > observed
> >> > any changes in the machines from that one. The rest don't
> > seem
> >> > to apply to my machines.
> >> >
> >> > They did recommend updating drivers prior to installing
SP2.
> > I
> >> > have been puting off the following driver updates, on the
> > "If it
> >> > ain't broke, don't fix it" theory:
> >> >
> >> > (1)Microsoft Corporation - Other Hardware - AMD K7
Processor
> >> > (Pub:5/15/04 Rel:12/17/02)
> >> > (2)Agere Systems - Modems - Agere Win Modem (Pub:8/10/04
> >> > Rel:12/12/03)
> >> > (3)Windows XP Driver 5.10.0.5410 for Realtec AC 97 Audio
> >> > (KB833846 Pub:6/4/2004)
> >> > (4)S3 Graphics, Inc. - Video - S3 Graphics ProSavageDDR
> >> > (Pub:5/17/04 Rel:3/2/04)
> >> > (5)VIA Technologies Inc. - Networking - VIA Rhine II Fast
> >> > Ethernet Adapter (Pub:8/3/04 Rel:7/22/04)
> >> >
> >> > I guess I will finally install them, unless someone is
aware
> > of
> >> > a reason not to.
> >> >
> >> > Does anyone have any warnings about any of these drivers
or
> >> > Windows XP SP2 on these machines?
> >> >
> >> > TIA
> >> > --
> >> > Ken Wampach - LastNameATeskimoDOTcom
> >
> >
>
>
Anonymous
August 29, 2004 4:23:29 PM

Archived from groups: alt.sys.pc-clone.compaq (More info?)

"Ken Wampach" <NOSPAM@myisp.com> wrote in message
news:LOmdnTYA5siESa3cRVn-pQ@comcast.com...
> Euclid,
> Thanks for the information. I believe your machine is a close
> cousin
> to mine, so I will try installing most of the driver updates. I
> may skip
> the modem one, since we have cable high-speed internet and
> rarely
> use the modems.
> --
> Ken Wampach - FirstNameLastNameATyahooDOTcom
>
> "Euclid" <Euclid@mmiv.nu> wrote in message
> news:M%ZXc.1673$JT3.672@newsread3.news.atl.earthlink.net...
>> I applied all of the driver and other updates available
> through Windows
>> Update as they were released. That includes the Agere Win
> Modem 12/12/03,
>> VIA Technologies multimedia (4/23/04 3/17/04 2/11/04
> 12/19/2003 10/20/2003),
>> S3 Graphics display 3/2/04, AMD processor 12/17/02. No
> problems on my Compaq
>> Presario S4020WM with Windows XP Home (SP1). The only thing
> special I did
>> before installing SP2 was to install the recent System Restore
> update
>> available from the Compaq/HP website, so that prior restore
> points would
>> still work if needed. Then I applied the SP2 update yesterday
> using the free
>> CD from Staples. No problems.
>>
>> I went to great pains to totally disable all software before
> running the SP2
>> update, including my firewall and anti-virus. I don't know if
> that was
>> necessary but didn't want to take chances.
>>
>> Note: apparently the 12/12/03 Agere modem update put a new
> item in my
>> msconfig startup list "LTMSG.EXE" which I worried about for
> awhile, but
>> believe it's probably OK. I tried turning it off, and my
> connection
>> throughput speed was poor. Then turned it back on, and things
> are normal
>> again. That's not proven absolutely, just a one time
> observation and some
>> assumptions. I try not to keep any startup items unless their
> value is
>> proven, but of course there are uncertainties about some of
> them.
>> -E
>>
>>
>> "Ken Wampach" <NOSPAM@myisp.com> wrote in message
>> news:ud6dncCd8IT6nq3cRVn-gg@comcast.com...
>> > HH,
>> > Thanks for your comments. I still would like to know if
> anyone
>> > has tried
>> > any of the hardware driver updates I listed with either good
> or
>> > bad results.
>> >> > (1)Microsoft Corporation - Other Hardware - AMD K7
> Processor
>> >> > (Pub:5/15/04 Rel:12/17/02)
>> >> > (2)Agere Systems - Modems - Agere Win Modem (Pub:8/10/04
>> >> > Rel:12/12/03)
>> >> > (3)Windows XP Driver 5.10.0.5410 for Realtec AC 97 Audio
>> >> > (KB833846 Pub:6/4/2004)
>> >> > (4)S3 Graphics, Inc. - Video - S3 Graphics ProSavageDDR
>> >> > (Pub:5/17/04 Rel:3/2/04)
>> >> > (5)VIA Technologies Inc. - Networking - VIA Rhine II Fast
>> >> > Ethernet Adapter (Pub:8/3/04 Rel:7/22/04)
>> > --
>> > Ken Wampach - FirstNameLastNameATyahooDOTcom
>> >
>> > "HH" <hahunt42@hotmail.com> wrote in message
>> > news:hkDXc.594$lV5.96@fe25.usenetserver.com...
>> >> Ken,
>> >> I cannot speak for others, but right now, I have no desire
> to
>> > install SP2 on
>> >> my Presario S5200CL, an Athlon XP 2600+. I've had no
> security
>> > issues, which
>> >> is the prime reason MS rolled out SP2. I run both a
> hardware
>> > and software
>> >> firewall, plus a virus shield and anti-spyware software.
> and I
>> > never open
>> >> e-mail unless it is scanned first.
>> >> That said, there may be a time in the future when I would
> want
>> > to install
>> >> SP2.
>> >> But, most uimportantly, I'm a firm believer in the "If it
>> > ain't broke...."
>> >> adage.
>> >> HH
>> >>
>> >> "Ken Wampach" <NOSPAM@myisp.com> wrote in message
>> >> news:1_qdnTtarbnROrPcRVn-jg@comcast.com...
>> >> > I am looking for advice prior to installing the Windows
> XP
>> > SP2
>> >> > service pack.
>> >> >
>> >> > I have 2 Compaq Desktops
>> >> > #1 Compaq Presario S3010CL-B (Sam's Club 7/3/2003) AMD
>> > Athlon XP
>> >> > 2200+
>> >> > #2 Compaq Presario S5000J (Compaq Direct 9/13/2003) AMD
>> > Athlon
>> >> > XP 2400+
>> >> >
>> >> > The machines are Windowx XP SP1 with all Critical Updates
>> >> > installed.
>> >> >
>> >> > I visited the Compaq website and found the "HP and Compaq
>> >> > Desktop PCs - Important Information for Upgrading to
>> > Microsoft
>> >> > Windows XP Service Pack 2" document. I did the "System
>> > Restore
>> >> > Update". I also did the "Multimedia Keyboard Driver
> Update",
>> >> > even though I did not think it was necessary. I haven't
>> > observed
>> >> > any changes in the machines from that one. The rest don't
>> > seem
>> >> > to apply to my machines.
>> >> >
>> >> > They did recommend updating drivers prior to installing
> SP2.
>> > I
>> >> > have been puting off the following driver updates, on the
>> > "If it
>> >> > ain't broke, don't fix it" theory:
>> >> >
>> >> > (1)Microsoft Corporation - Other Hardware - AMD K7
> Processor
>> >> > (Pub:5/15/04 Rel:12/17/02)
>> >> > (2)Agere Systems - Modems - Agere Win Modem (Pub:8/10/04
>> >> > Rel:12/12/03)
>> >> > (3)Windows XP Driver 5.10.0.5410 for Realtec AC 97 Audio
>> >> > (KB833846 Pub:6/4/2004)
>> >> > (4)S3 Graphics, Inc. - Video - S3 Graphics ProSavageDDR
>> >> > (Pub:5/17/04 Rel:3/2/04)
>> >> > (5)VIA Technologies Inc. - Networking - VIA Rhine II Fast
>> >> > Ethernet Adapter (Pub:8/3/04 Rel:7/22/04)
>> >> >
>> >> > I guess I will finally install them, unless someone is
> aware
>> > of
>> >> > a reason not to.
>> >> >
>> >> > Does anyone have any warnings about any of these drivers
> or
>> >> > Windows XP SP2 on these machines?
>> >> >
>> >> > TIA
>> >> > --
>> >> > Ken Wampach - LastNameATeskimoDOTcom
>> >
>> >
>>
>>
>
>

Always decline any driver updates offered by Windows Update. Check with
Compaq support if you see a driver update. There are far too many
problems reported with these WU drivers. Some are applicable as
advertised, many are not. Those who do use the WU drivers often report
significant problems.

Drivers are not the main issue with SP2. IMO, from the reports of
problems on the microsoft news servers, the source is failing to clean
up computers prior to installation. Complete virus scan from Safe Mode.
Complete Disk Cleanup. Defrag. If the folder i386 exists on the
computer or you have a true XP install CD (not a restore CD), then run
sfc /scannow from a command prompt to verify all existing files for
backup during the installation. Clear out old system restore points and
make a final SP1 restore point. Back up personal files. Before
installing check your vendor for driver updates. Before installing,
disable all background programs except for anti-virus and firewall.
Disable these also and disconnect from the internet if installing from a
local SP2 update file. Disconnect peripheral devices like printers and
USB devices before the install.

If the SP2 install fails, do not use system restore before trying
Add/Remove programs to remove SP2.

Q
August 30, 2004 4:45:13 AM

Archived from groups: alt.sys.pc-clone.compaq (More info?)

> Always decline any driver updates offered by Windows Update. Check with
> Compaq support if you see a driver update. There are far too many
> problems reported with these WU drivers. Some are applicable as
> advertised, many are not. Those who do use the WU drivers often report
> significant problems.

I've heard this same advice from other respected experts, however... I've
installed all of the WU driver updates offered for my Compaq Presario
S4020WM since I bought it a year ago at Walmart. No problems so far. It's a
really convenient method, and personally I tend to trust Microsoft more than
Compaq/HP in such regards.

Microsoft only offers selected driver updates, presumably only those that
interact with their Windows op system and office products. Most driver
updates have to be obtained elsewhere such as at the Compaq/HP website or
manufacturers websites, and that requires research as well as technical
judgements. A lot of people don't have the time nor ability to keep updated,
so the WU method is easiest.
-E
Anonymous
August 31, 2004 12:05:54 PM

Archived from groups: alt.sys.pc-clone.compaq (More info?)

"Euclid" <Euclid@mmiv.nu> wrote in message
news:tMuYc.4476$JT3.3427@newsread3.news.atl.earthlink.net...
>> Always decline any driver updates offered by Windows Update. Check
>> with Compaq support if you see a driver update. There are far too
>> many problems reported with these WU drivers. Some are applicable as
>> advertised, many are not. Those who do use the WU drivers often
>> report significant problems.
>
> I've heard this same advice from other respected experts, however...
> I've installed all of the WU driver updates offered for my Compaq
> Presario S4020WM since I bought it a year ago at Walmart. No problems
> so far. It's a really convenient method, and personally I tend to
> trust Microsoft more than Compaq/HP in such regards.
>
> Microsoft only offers selected driver updates, presumably only those
> that interact with their Windows op system and office products. Most
> driver updates have to be obtained elsewhere such as at the Compaq/HP
> website or manufacturers websites, and that requires research as well
> as technical judgements. A lot of people don't have the time nor
> ability to keep updated, so the WU method is easiest.
> -E
>
>

You have been extremely lucky using WU for drivers. The microsoft
support NGs are replete with failed driver updates, many requiring an OS
repair/reinstall to correct. Microsoft does not warrant any driver
update; they supply the function as a convenience to vendors. Microsoft
does not develop the drivers they supply on WU (unless it is a Microsoft
product); the applicability is determined by the developer who might not
have taken any HPAQ proprietary requirements into consideration. HPAQ
is notorious for making OEM mods to their computers which can make the
vendor's driver fail the OS or the device. Get to know the support site
for your computer and check it regularly. Even the Microsoft MVP's
recommend against using WU for driver updates.

Q
August 31, 2004 7:50:15 PM

Archived from groups: alt.sys.pc-clone.compaq (More info?)

I allowed Windows Update to install updated audio drivers on my Presario
S5200CL and the audio started breaking up. Rolling back to the Compaq
supplied Realtek drivers put it right again.
HH

"Quaoar" <quaoar@tenthplanet.net> wrote in message
news:UYqdnQ1yHJhVGKncRVn-qg@comcast.com...
>
> "Euclid" <Euclid@mmiv.nu> wrote in message
> news:tMuYc.4476$JT3.3427@newsread3.news.atl.earthlink.net...
> >> Always decline any driver updates offered by Windows Update. Check
> >> with Compaq support if you see a driver update. There are far too
> >> many problems reported with these WU drivers. Some are applicable as
> >> advertised, many are not. Those who do use the WU drivers often
> >> report significant problems.
> >
> > I've heard this same advice from other respected experts, however...
> > I've installed all of the WU driver updates offered for my Compaq
> > Presario S4020WM since I bought it a year ago at Walmart. No problems
> > so far. It's a really convenient method, and personally I tend to
> > trust Microsoft more than Compaq/HP in such regards.
> >
> > Microsoft only offers selected driver updates, presumably only those
> > that interact with their Windows op system and office products. Most
> > driver updates have to be obtained elsewhere such as at the Compaq/HP
> > website or manufacturers websites, and that requires research as well
> > as technical judgements. A lot of people don't have the time nor
> > ability to keep updated, so the WU method is easiest.
> > -E
> >
> >
>
> You have been extremely lucky using WU for drivers. The microsoft
> support NGs are replete with failed driver updates, many requiring an OS
> repair/reinstall to correct. Microsoft does not warrant any driver
> update; they supply the function as a convenience to vendors. Microsoft
> does not develop the drivers they supply on WU (unless it is a Microsoft
> product); the applicability is determined by the developer who might not
> have taken any HPAQ proprietary requirements into consideration. HPAQ
> is notorious for making OEM mods to their computers which can make the
> vendor's driver fail the OS or the device. Get to know the support site
> for your computer and check it regularly. Even the Microsoft MVP's
> recommend against using WU for driver updates.
>
> Q
>
>
>
Anonymous
September 1, 2004 11:12:11 AM

Archived from groups: alt.sys.pc-clone.compaq (More info?)

I've never had any problems with the driver updates,but the size of
SP2(over 70 mbs)made me leery,it's obviously a major change.I started
looking for info on it before trying it out,and found the various Microsoft
newsgroups absolutely swamped with hundreds of complaints about the damage
this update has caused to systems.I think MS rushed this service pack out
without proper testing because of problems with security in XP,and it's full
of bugs.It's more a beta version than a finished product,and XP users are
being used as test subjects.Considering the miminal benefits it offers,this
update isn't worth the risk.

"HH" <hahunt42@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:p z4Zc.22$KQ5.21@fe25.usenetserver.com...
> I allowed Windows Update to install updated audio drivers on my Presario
> S5200CL and the audio started breaking up. Rolling back to the Compaq
> supplied Realtek drivers put it right again.
> HH
>
> "Quaoar" <quaoar@tenthplanet.net> wrote in message
> news:UYqdnQ1yHJhVGKncRVn-qg@comcast.com...
> >
> > "Euclid" <Euclid@mmiv.nu> wrote in message
> > news:tMuYc.4476$JT3.3427@newsread3.news.atl.earthlink.net...
> > >> Always decline any driver updates offered by Windows Update. Check
> > >> with Compaq support if you see a driver update. There are far too
> > >> many problems reported with these WU drivers. Some are applicable as
> > >> advertised, many are not. Those who do use the WU drivers often
> > >> report significant problems.
> > >
> > > I've heard this same advice from other respected experts, however...
> > > I've installed all of the WU driver updates offered for my Compaq
> > > Presario S4020WM since I bought it a year ago at Walmart. No problems
> > > so far. It's a really convenient method, and personally I tend to
> > > trust Microsoft more than Compaq/HP in such regards.
> > >
> > > Microsoft only offers selected driver updates, presumably only those
> > > that interact with their Windows op system and office products. Most
> > > driver updates have to be obtained elsewhere such as at the Compaq/HP
> > > website or manufacturers websites, and that requires research as well
> > > as technical judgements. A lot of people don't have the time nor
> > > ability to keep updated, so the WU method is easiest.
> > > -E
> > >
> > >
> >
> > You have been extremely lucky using WU for drivers. The microsoft
> > support NGs are replete with failed driver updates, many requiring an OS
> > repair/reinstall to correct. Microsoft does not warrant any driver
> > update; they supply the function as a convenience to vendors. Microsoft
> > does not develop the drivers they supply on WU (unless it is a Microsoft
> > product); the applicability is determined by the developer who might not
> > have taken any HPAQ proprietary requirements into consideration. HPAQ
> > is notorious for making OEM mods to their computers which can make the
> > vendor's driver fail the OS or the device. Get to know the support site
> > for your computer and check it regularly. Even the Microsoft MVP's
> > recommend against using WU for driver updates.
> >
> > Q
> >
> >
> >
>
>
>
Anonymous
September 1, 2004 11:12:12 AM

Archived from groups: alt.sys.pc-clone.compaq (More info?)

I don't agree. The security updates alone are worth the upgrade. There are
literally millions of people that have upgraded without problems.

Tom
"Gojira" <nospam@yahoo.com> wrote in message
news:fDeZc.3752$P46.1320@trndny03...
> I've never had any problems with the driver updates,but the size of
> SP2(over 70 mbs)made me leery,it's obviously a major change.I started
> looking for info on it before trying it out,and found the various
> Microsoft
> newsgroups absolutely swamped with hundreds of complaints about the damage
> this update has caused to systems.I think MS rushed this service pack out
> without proper testing because of problems with security in XP,and it's
> full
> of bugs.It's more a beta version than a finished product,and XP users are
> being used as test subjects.Considering the miminal benefits it
> offers,this
> update isn't worth the risk.
>
> "HH" <hahunt42@hotmail.com> wrote in message
> news:p z4Zc.22$KQ5.21@fe25.usenetserver.com...
>> I allowed Windows Update to install updated audio drivers on my Presario
>> S5200CL and the audio started breaking up. Rolling back to the Compaq
>> supplied Realtek drivers put it right again.
>> HH
>>
>> "Quaoar" <quaoar@tenthplanet.net> wrote in message
>> news:UYqdnQ1yHJhVGKncRVn-qg@comcast.com...
>> >
>> > "Euclid" <Euclid@mmiv.nu> wrote in message
>> > news:tMuYc.4476$JT3.3427@newsread3.news.atl.earthlink.net...
>> > >> Always decline any driver updates offered by Windows Update. Check
>> > >> with Compaq support if you see a driver update. There are far too
>> > >> many problems reported with these WU drivers. Some are applicable
>> > >> as
>> > >> advertised, many are not. Those who do use the WU drivers often
>> > >> report significant problems.
>> > >
>> > > I've heard this same advice from other respected experts, however...
>> > > I've installed all of the WU driver updates offered for my Compaq
>> > > Presario S4020WM since I bought it a year ago at Walmart. No problems
>> > > so far. It's a really convenient method, and personally I tend to
>> > > trust Microsoft more than Compaq/HP in such regards.
>> > >
>> > > Microsoft only offers selected driver updates, presumably only those
>> > > that interact with their Windows op system and office products. Most
>> > > driver updates have to be obtained elsewhere such as at the Compaq/HP
>> > > website or manufacturers websites, and that requires research as well
>> > > as technical judgements. A lot of people don't have the time nor
>> > > ability to keep updated, so the WU method is easiest.
>> > > -E
>> > >
>> > >
>> >
>> > You have been extremely lucky using WU for drivers. The microsoft
>> > support NGs are replete with failed driver updates, many requiring an
>> > OS
>> > repair/reinstall to correct. Microsoft does not warrant any driver
>> > update; they supply the function as a convenience to vendors.
>> > Microsoft
>> > does not develop the drivers they supply on WU (unless it is a
>> > Microsoft
>> > product); the applicability is determined by the developer who might
>> > not
>> > have taken any HPAQ proprietary requirements into consideration. HPAQ
>> > is notorious for making OEM mods to their computers which can make the
>> > vendor's driver fail the OS or the device. Get to know the support
>> > site
>> > for your computer and check it regularly. Even the Microsoft MVP's
>> > recommend against using WU for driver updates.
>> >
>> > Q
>> >
>> >
>> >
>>
>>
>>
>
>
Anonymous
September 1, 2004 2:07:59 PM

Archived from groups: alt.sys.pc-clone.compaq (More info?)

But if he happens to be one of the unfortunates that has severe problems,
will you fix his computer for him?

I have never yet seen an upgrade from MS that being cautious caused major
problems.

My philosophy to let guys like you, that need the latest and greatest, take
the risk.

>g<


"Tom Scales" <tomtoo@softhome.net> wrote in message
news:nbudnR-BAsS9D6jcRVn-tA@comcast.com...
> I don't agree. The security updates alone are worth the upgrade. There
are
> literally millions of people that have upgraded without problems.
>
> Tom
> "Gojira" <nospam@yahoo.com> wrote in message
> news:fDeZc.3752$P46.1320@trndny03...
> > I've never had any problems with the driver updates,but the size of
> > SP2(over 70 mbs)made me leery,it's obviously a major change.I started
> > looking for info on it before trying it out,and found the various
> > Microsoft
> > newsgroups absolutely swamped with hundreds of complaints about the
damage
> > this update has caused to systems.I think MS rushed this service pack
out
> > without proper testing because of problems with security in XP,and it's
> > full
> > of bugs.It's more a beta version than a finished product,and XP users
are
> > being used as test subjects.Considering the miminal benefits it
> > offers,this
> > update isn't worth the risk.
> >
> > "HH" <hahunt42@hotmail.com> wrote in message
> > news:p z4Zc.22$KQ5.21@fe25.usenetserver.com...
> >> I allowed Windows Update to install updated audio drivers on my
Presario
> >> S5200CL and the audio started breaking up. Rolling back to the Compaq
> >> supplied Realtek drivers put it right again.
> >> HH
> >>
> >> "Quaoar" <quaoar@tenthplanet.net> wrote in message
> >> news:UYqdnQ1yHJhVGKncRVn-qg@comcast.com...
> >> >
> >> > "Euclid" <Euclid@mmiv.nu> wrote in message
> >> > news:tMuYc.4476$JT3.3427@newsread3.news.atl.earthlink.net...
> >> > >> Always decline any driver updates offered by Windows Update.
Check
> >> > >> with Compaq support if you see a driver update. There are far too
> >> > >> many problems reported with these WU drivers. Some are applicable
> >> > >> as
> >> > >> advertised, many are not. Those who do use the WU drivers often
> >> > >> report significant problems.
> >> > >
> >> > > I've heard this same advice from other respected experts,
however...
> >> > > I've installed all of the WU driver updates offered for my Compaq
> >> > > Presario S4020WM since I bought it a year ago at Walmart. No
problems
> >> > > so far. It's a really convenient method, and personally I tend to
> >> > > trust Microsoft more than Compaq/HP in such regards.
> >> > >
> >> > > Microsoft only offers selected driver updates, presumably only
those
> >> > > that interact with their Windows op system and office products.
Most
> >> > > driver updates have to be obtained elsewhere such as at the
Compaq/HP
> >> > > website or manufacturers websites, and that requires research as
well
> >> > > as technical judgements. A lot of people don't have the time nor
> >> > > ability to keep updated, so the WU method is easiest.
> >> > > -E
> >> > >
> >> > >
> >> >
> >> > You have been extremely lucky using WU for drivers. The microsoft
> >> > support NGs are replete with failed driver updates, many requiring an
> >> > OS
> >> > repair/reinstall to correct. Microsoft does not warrant any driver
> >> > update; they supply the function as a convenience to vendors.
> >> > Microsoft
> >> > does not develop the drivers they supply on WU (unless it is a
> >> > Microsoft
> >> > product); the applicability is determined by the developer who might
> >> > not
> >> > have taken any HPAQ proprietary requirements into consideration.
HPAQ
> >> > is notorious for making OEM mods to their computers which can make
the
> >> > vendor's driver fail the OS or the device. Get to know the support
> >> > site
> >> > for your computer and check it regularly. Even the Microsoft MVP's
> >> > recommend against using WU for driver updates.
> >> >
> >> > Q
> >> >
> >> >
> >> >
> >>
> >>
> >>
> >
> >
>
>
!