Archived from groups: comp.security.firewalls (
More info?)
csekar21@yahoo.com (Shekar) wrote in message news:<5e014759.0404071732.ed1fb91@posting.google.com>...
> rick@bcm.tmc.edu (Richard H Miller) wrote in message news:<c4s3kn$79m@gazette.corp.bcm.tmc.edu>...
> > Shekar (csekar21@yahoo.com) wrote:
> > : No problem with SIC, In fact i can push the policies without any problem.
> >
> >
> >
> >
> > : "Beoweolf" <Beoweolf@pacbell.net> wrote in message news:<TPVbc.45983$rB4.3033@newssvr25.news.prodigy.com>...
> > : > SIC? has it been established between the FW and Nokia?
> > : >
> > : >
> > : > "Shekar" <csekar21@yahoo.com> wrote in message
> > : > news:5e014759.0404040414.4795cfa@posting.google.com...
> > : > > Hi All,
> > : > >
> > : > > We are configuring new firewall in our local and remote office.
> > : > > Check point AI R55 with HFA-02
> > : > > Nokia IPSO 3.7.1
> > : > > Windows 2000 SP4
> > : > >
> > : > > Local vpn-1 pro enforcement module - Nokia IP 350
> > : > > Local checkpoint express smart center server - Windows 2000
> > : > > (Statically NATed and enabled control connection located in LAN)
> > : > >
> > : > > Remote vpn-1 pro enforcement module - Nokia IP 130
> > : > >
> > : > > We can push the policies no problem. But we are not getting log from
> > : > > remote module.
> > : > > Site vpn also failed even the time sync is correct.
> > : > > We have the following error in local log file - IKE: phase 1 received
> > : > > notification from peer, invalid certificate.
> > : > > Remote firewall module log shows the following error message.
> > : > > IKE : Main mode validation timed out.
> >
> >
> >
> > Ok
> >
> > 1) Did you define a rule in both modules policy to allow IKE. This will be before any encryption rules
> > and allows the two module to exchange key information
> >
> > 2) Did you export your CA information and install a certificate on the remote box and setup the appropriate
> > trust for the cert's [From the error message it looks like you have the vpn define as a cert]. Is there a
> > reson to use this instead of shared secret?
> >
> > 3) Have you setup a rule to allow the enforcement module to completly talk with the management server
> >
> > Richard H. Miller, MCSE, CCSE+
> > Information Security Manager
> > Information Technology Security and Compliance
> > Information Technology - Baylor College of Medicine
>
> 1. VPN comuunity rule allows from any and all service. Installed both
> firewalls
> 2. I do not have export option since both firewalls are internally
> managed
> 3. My first rule allows any service from remote firewall to management
> server
>
> My setup is like this,
> Local Firewall
> Nokia IP 350 - Enforcement Module (IPSO 3.7.1) (CP AI - R55 with
> HFA-2)
> Int interface - 10.65.16.1
> DMZ interface - 10.65.8.98
> Ext interface - 209.20.128.60.198
>
> Local Managment server
> Windows 2000 sp4 - Smart center (CP AI - R55 with HFA-2)
> IP address - 10.65.16.19 (Enabled static nat with ip address -
> 209.20.128.199) (Also enabled the control connection)
>
> Remote firewall
> Nokia IP 130 - Enforcement Module (IPSO 3.7.1) (CP AI - R55 with
> HFA-2)
> Int interface - 10.86.16.1
> DMZ interface - 10.86.6.2
> Ext interface - 211.158.158.220
>
> First rule allows remote firewall to access management server (Service
> - ANY)
> also VPN community rule for site to site vpn (service - ANY)
> Remote gateway & local gateway is the member of community.
> Mangement server is also a Certificate authority. (Default)
>
> I can do SIC and push policies to remote firewall. But when I try to
> ping remote internal ip address, It is trying to establish the tunnel.
> But error msg shows ( IKE phase 1 - recieved notification from
> peer.invalid certificate) Even i am not receiving log from remote
> firewall.
> Both firewalls hosts file has the name and public IP address of
> firewall and management server. So no problem with name resolution.
> Date & time is correct in firewalls and management server.
Hi,
My problem has been resolved by doing the following.
1) Install a NAT rule on the Remote module
* Original Source: Remote module
* Original Destination: INTERNAL IP address of the mgmt server
* Original Service: ANY
* Translated Source: original
* Translated Destination: EXTERNAL IP address of the mgmt server
* Transalted servcie: original
2) Disable client side NATting for manual NAT rules
Policy - Global properties - NAT - Uncheck 'Translate destination on client side'
Facebook
Twitter
Instagram