water cooling over kill?

[HomeChicken]

I have a Abit IT7 and a P4 1.6a. I want to get at least 150fsb, and i was wondering if watercooling would be overkill for a P4 set up. For me, extreme air cooling and water cooling come out to be about the same amount, but water cooling is quieter. But do i even need extreme air or water cooling to hit 150fsb on that P4? first hand experience would be very appreciated.

 

[chuck232]

Yuo probably don't need anything but the stock fan. Fatburger was able to get his 1.6A to 155MHz FSB with just the stock fan.

Falling down stairs saves time

 

[10GHZ]

but water cooling will give u stability in the long run and a piece of mind, it also allow you to overclock it even higher than 150