Archived from groups: alt.comp.periphs.videocards.ati (
More info?)
<doug.drodskie@eskom.co.za> wrote in message
news:cp67f3$2tsv$1@newsreader02.ops.uunet.co.za...
> "Neil" <neil@chapellane69.free-online.co.uk>
> wrote in message
> news:41b64fb4$0$52997$ed2619ec@ptn-nntp-reader03.plus.net...
>> On the other hand the performance difference
>> between the two video cards is apparently so
>> marginal (according to the one article I've
>> seen) that anyone prepared to shell out the
>> extra for the 850 isn't going to balk at
>> changing their mainboard. There's no reason
>> for buying the 850 other than to have
>> absolutely the latest card.**
>> Anyone buying it for that reason strikes me as
>> "a fool" - and they're not well known for their
>> affinity for money.
>>
>> Neil
>>
>> ** Apart from (perhaps) the possibility that
>> the 850 (it is claimed) may be slightly more
>> readily available than the 800, but that
>> remains to be seen.
>>
> Don't be judgemental, you cannot know
> everyone's circumstances. I have a 9700 Pro
> and although I am starting to back off on AA,
> AF, res, and latest game quality settings a
> little, it's not imperitive I upgrade the VPU
> now. However, I have a time-limited
> opportunity to SAVE about $850 on an
> 'absolutely the latest card'. If I could find an
> X800XT PE AGP I would get it but it looks as
> though it, and the X850, will become available
> at the same time, making it better for me to
> buy the X850, but not if I have to upgrade
> everything else to the latest as well. That's
> why it sux so bad for me.
>
I still think the only reason for buying an 850 is
if it is more readily available than an 800, which
I admit, appear to be almost non-existant. The
cards are "the same". The performance is "the
same". (If you were really insistent, I'd bet you
stand a chance of running the 800 at the same
clock speeds as the 850). I personally am a fan
of buying "one notch down" from the current latest
and greatest, and I've ended up with a 9800Pro
from about the time the X800 was being "released"
(which I've managed to turn into a 128MB XT). But
if there is a peculiar opportunity for you to buy
the latest and greatest at a knock-down price,
then fair enough. At the moment though, from ATi,
the X800 XT PE and the X850 XT PE are both
equally late and great. If you have an AGP
mainboard you get the former, if you have a PCI-E
board you buy the former as well (and save a few
quid, if you can find it - otherwise you buy the
latter).
If you wanted the latest and greatest video card
that you could use in your current AGP board, and
still use in your next mainboard, I reckon you're
stuffed. And for that reason I think a lot of
people's next serious upgrades are going to have
to involve changing the lot, i.e. mainboard,
processor and video card. Would you really want
to be able to spend £400 (or whatever) on a new
AGP video card and then have to "throw it away"
next year when you want a processor upgrade and
the only way to do it is with a PCI-E mainboard?