NTFS drive files pointing to random and wrong part of disc..

Archived from groups: comp.sys.ibm.pc.hardware.storage (More info?)

I had a bunch of MP3's on a large hard disc (180GB) and after no
obvious problem that came to my attention I have just found that when
I play those favorites tracks some other, random, track is plays,
someplace part way through as well. It seems most of the track items I
play are referencing the wrong part of the hard disc and the wrong
track is playing.

The only think I can think that I did recently was run the MS Defrag
program.

Is there any chance I can recover the tracks on this disc? It consists
of only MP3 tracks.