Archived from groups: rec.video.desktop (
More info?)
James G wrote:
> My reasons for making the PC-to-Mac Transition isn't for the sake of my
> own future projects. If that were the case, I'd remain happily a PC
> user. My reason is that I want a job in the industry. Here in LA, most
> (if not all) post-production work is Mac-based.
>
>
>
> C.J.Patten wrote:
>> As always, these are my OPINIONS.
>> Take 'em or leave 'em but arguing ain't gonna change 'em.
>>
>> <rant mode on>
>>
>> Do you feel a Mac is going to make you MORE profitable than a WindowsXP
>> based environment?
>>
>> I switched FROM Mac TO Windows XP workstations about 2 years ago after about
>> a dozen Macs ranging from a IIvx to Quadra, PowerMac 7600 and several
>
>> Powerbooks, G3's, G4's etc.
>>
>> Mac served me for over a decade and did the job well - everything from
>> photo-retouching, illustration, layout and NLE. (Premiere "one-point-oh"
>> anyone?)
>>
>> The MacOS had an edge with Win98 - it's gone now against WinXP.
>>
>> Mac hardware will cost you more dollars than a comparably equipped PC. An
>> hour of DV25 is going to take 11GB on either platform regardless. You're
>> still going to have to remember what obscure folder you saved that file in
>> and your final product will look identical unless you slap a "Made with Mac"
>> logo on it. (don't - it's asinine)
>>
>> With Premiere Pro and Encore DVD, Adobe didn't feel they'd have a reasonable
>> ROI competing with Apple's own Final Cut Pro and DVD Studio Pro so they
>> aren't developing on the Mac platform.
>>
>> I doubt the MacOS will EVER lose Photoshop or Illustrator. If that rumour
>> got around, Apple would step in and pony up the cash to keep development
>> going because they know the Mac would die in the absence of those two
>
>> workhorses.
>>
>> *********
>>
>> If you want a bit of my background and specifically my work-environment
>> computer-history:
http://www.ncf.ca/~af895/links/PC_history.html
>>
>> At the end, you'll note a comparison I did between different notebook
>
>> computers. A LESSER equipped Powerbook would have been over $1500 more than
>> the HP Pavillion 17inch notebook I bought. You'll find that kind of delta
>> carries over into the desktop Macs as well.
>>
>> Bottom line: I was NOT going to be "$1500 more productive" on that Mac
>> laptop.
>>
>> *********
>>
>> Someone else here mentioned their facility uses PC's but they're picking up
>> a Mac-Mini so they can say they have it on the off-chance a client comes
>> along and demands they be able to use their Final Cut Pro project files.
>>
>> If you're honestly getting a lot of client demand for that type of service,
>> stick a MacMini on one end of a KVM switch so you can share a keyboard,
>> mouse and monitor with a production workstation - IF you feel you're losing
>> business because you don't have a Mac.
>>
>> For me, I don't stress about it. If someone has a problem with my using X,
>> I'll tactfully remind them it's not the tool, it's how you swing it.
>>
>> <rant mode off>
>>
>> Use whatever you're comfortable with but DON'T for a second think you can't
>> do something on one platform that you can do on the other.
>>
>> No question Apple makes *the most elegant* hardware on the market but style,
>> like upgrading from your Honda Accord to a BMW, comes at a price. Apple
>> squandered it's lead in the OS market while dealing with legacy corporate
>> culture and management issues throughout the 1990's. Windows just ain't that
>> bad anymore.
>>
>> If you got this far, thanks for listening and I hope it helps.
>>
>> C.
>>
>>
>>
>> "James G" <MisterJamesGovan@gmail.com> wrote in message
>> news:1112393457.006401.322300@o13g2000cwo.googlegroups.com...
>>> Hello all. I'm a one-man video production company who's turned out
>>> various documentary projects. I've seen two of my projects distributed
>>> and I've generally done the vast majority of the entire work on these
>>> projects. I've shot all the video, edited the footage and authored the
>>> DVD's. I average a year and a half on each project.
>>>
>>> But the projects are expensive to produce and the monetary returns have
>>> been minimal (read: my projects lose money). I've been self-financing
>>> all my projects with a non-production job that I despise and I'm
>>> wanting to transition my career path into the post-production world.
>>>
>>> The one problem that I foresee in the transition is that I only have
>>> pc-based experience and the industry as a whole is largely mac-based.
>>> With that in mind, I'm going to soon invest in the Dual 2.5mhz G5 and
>>> learn FCP and the mac system.
>>>
>>> I use Adobe products extensively and I'm sure that the PC-to-Mac
>>> Photoshop/After Effects transition will be a smooth one. I'm sure that
>>> the Mac OS, too, is fairly intuitive. What I'm most interested in is
>>> how to best go about the transition. I don't want to be simply a
>>> PC-user using a Mac and trying to clumsily find the Mac way of doing my
>>> ingrained PC-based workflow. Instead, I'd like to be Mac fluent.
>>>
>>> Are there any resources (net-based? books?) that address my situation?
>>> A PC-savvy person who needs to make the transition to Mac?
Avid is shipping on PC platforms these days. We have 6 Avids all PC based. 4 HPs
and 2 no-name computers. Our past Avids were IBM based. Way back we had some Mac
based Avids. Photoshop works just fine on a PC. Out of maybe 35 or so computers
we have 1 Mac and that is for DVD authoring. We are not Hollywood but we are a
large Midwest production house.
You said "Here in LA, most (if not all) post-production work is Mac-based"
What exactly do you mean by Mac-based? I'm not an anti-Mac person but PCs are
being used a lot in the post production world for more than scheduling.